Submitted by Katie  (Jul 19, 2005)I was, I confess, disappointed in Order of the Phoenix. True, I raced through it in a couple of days and I recently read it again, but it seemed she'd lost some of the things I loved about the earlier Harry Potter books. She was still funny, quirky and creative, but her characterization was off with Harry. All right, he's fifteen and he's had a hard time, but he could not have changed so much in a few weeks (end GoF to start OP). He's so aggressive and moody it just doesn't correlate with old Harry. Also, the ending was weaker than usual, both plotwise but mostly just her writing. She simply tried to hard to make it tragic enough, what with Dumbledore's lamentations etc.
On the whole, I can still recommend it. The Harry Potter series remains the one and only Harry Potter series, but I sincerely hope she gets her act together for the Half-Blood Prince.
|