Home Literature Stories Movies Games Comics Blogs News Discussion Forum Art Gallery
  Science Fiction and Fantasy News
SFFWorld News – 11/16/09 (11-16)
SFFWorld News – 10/31/09 (10-31)
MERLIN Book Signing at Forbidden Planet UK (10-22)
Coming Soon TEMPEST RISING (10-09)

Official sffworld Reviews
The Words of Making by David Forbes (11-16 - Book)
Transitions by Iain M. Banks (11-16 - Book)
The Dragon Book: Magical Tales from the Masters of Modern Fa by Jack & Gardner Dann & Dozois (11-09 - Book)
Wolfbreed by S. Andrew Swann (11-02 - Book)

Author

Site Index

Official sffworld.com Book Review     Bookmark and Share

Tides by Scott Mackay


(2006-01-08)


Submit Your Own Review

 

340pp
ISBN: 1-59102-334-3
Pyr

Two races, two continents, two moons and one world, under the power of the 40-foot-plus tides of the great ocean - these elements flavor Scott Mackay’s aptly titled novel, Tides. Mackay delivers a interesting tale of two races meeting for the first time, after thousands of years of evolving on separate from each other. The protagonist, Hab is the most distinguished mariner in his native land of Parras being the only person to brave the enormous tides and successfully sail to the planet’s equator and back. Parras’s inhabitants refer to their country as the Golden Land, due to its near utopian lifestyle; people live rather simple lives, there is very little criminal activity and war has been outlawed/banned for five hundred years.

On one of the voyages Hab captains, a scientists informs him of another landmass, which he deduced from the remnants of volcanic ash falling out of the sky. This is later confirmed when Hab sees an ash cloud floating over the ocean. After journeying in the ocean for much of his life, and growing weary of life in Parras, Hab has the unquenchable desire to cross the ocean and prove there is life other than the gilded land of Parras. Hab urges his ruler to sanction him to lead an expedition across the enormous unforgiving ocean, in search of the mythical other continent. The proposition is very risky, both for the safety of the crews of the ships and the cost for mounting the expedition. Despite this, and the fact that his father died in the ocean after his ship was destroyed by the tides, Hab persists in this newfound drive. After a failed attempt at crossing the ocean, Hab rather sneakily signs away his family’s fortunes in order to secure a second three-vessel fleet.

Despite the loss of life and damage to the vessels, Hab and his remaining crew arrive on the newly discovered continent. However, when Hab and crew finally arrive, the inhabitants they meet and the land are not what he or his crew expected. Bleak, dark and desolate, Ortok, as the continent is called by its native lizard-men, is quite the opposite of Hab’s Golden Land. There is very little green or vegetative life and the land is pockmarked with volcanoes and the ever-threatening Lizard men. These lizard-men tower over the humans and because of the strength and power in their legs, bound or jump rather than walk. Hab and his crew aptly enough, come to call the Lizard-men hoppers. Hab eventually becomes a prisoner of Rango, one of the hopper drillmasters, and the two educate each other about their respective cultures and lands. Hab soon realizes just as the land and people of Ortok are very different, so is the philosophy and approach to life. Where honesty is the rule in Parras, the lie is the way in Ortok.

Mackay does some interesting things in Tides. In particular, I thought the two nations were well drawn. In some passages, as Rango takes Hab on a tour of Ortok, Mackay evokes the feel of the land nicely. There is a mystery behind the two races and the legends both races build about each other added a mythic feel to the story and world. I think Mackay also gave Hab a good supporting cast of secondary characters.

However, I did have some difficulties with Mackay’s execution. Perhaps my largest problem was with the character of Hab. He was somewhat inconsistent and for all intents and purposes, not a very bright guy. Granted, he was brought up in a land where truth rules just about everything, I still felt he revealed too much information to his captor too easily. Given how he was not exactly truthful in securing the second expedition, this blind faith on his part was tough to swallow. Also, about one third into the book a characteristic/hobby is revealed about Hab, that worked for the moment in the plot, but was either not obvious or mentioned very much prior to that point in the story.

Even though the plot and outcome were both fairly predictable, and the protagonist was frustrating at times, I still feel Mackay put forth an interesting and thought-provoking novel. While the novel ended with closure, the world itself may be ripe for more stories Parras and Ortok. In total, Tides was a entertaining novel of cultural conflict and rite of passage.

© 2006 Rob H. Bedford

Bookmark and Share



Copyright © sffworld.com. If quotet please credit "sffworld.com, name of reviewer".


Sponsor ads

 

Latest

The Words of Making by David Forbes
11-16 - Book Review
Transitions by Iain M. Banks
11-16 - Book Review
SFFWorld News – 11/16/09
11-16 - News
The Dragon Book: Magical Tales from the Masters of Modern Fa by Jack & Gardner Dann & Dozois
11-09 - Book Review
Wolfbreed by S. Andrew Swann
11-02 - Book Review
Diving into the Wreck by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
11-02 - Book Review
SFFWorld News – 10/31/09
10-31 - News
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
MERLIN Book Signing at Forbidden Planet UK
10-22 - News
Salamander by Nick Kyme
10-19 - Book Review
The Windup Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi
10-12 - Book Review
Triumff: Her Majesty's Hero by Dan Abnett
10-11 - Book Review
Coming Soon – TEMPEST RISING
10-09 - News
Something that is not a packaging device.
10-09 - News
How Victorious is the Victorious Parasol?
10-07 - News
The odd neighbors of a first-time homeowner
10-07 - News
Silly Fantasies
10-06 - News
Leviathan by Scott Westerfeld
10-05 - Book Review
X-Isle by Steve Augarde
10-04 - Book Review
“It Somehow Always Involved an Assassin with Extraordinary Powers And A Love of Espressos”
10-02 - News
In Their Own Words: K.J. Parker on The Company
10-02 - News
The Drowning City by Amanda Downum
10-01 - Book Review
Antarctica by Kim Stanley Robinson
09-28 - News
Beauty by Sheri S. Tepper
09-28 - News
The Black Raven by Katharine Kerr
09-28 - News
The Bone Doll's Twin by Lynn Flewelling
09-28 - News
Brightness Reef by David Brin
09-28 - News

New Forum Posts




About - Advertising - Contact us - RSS - For Authors & Publishers - Contribute / Submit - Privacy Policy - Community Login
Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use. The contents of this webpage are copyright © 1997-2009 sffworld.com. All Rights Reserved.