[Mrs. Cadvan]

Well if that's all his character was supposed to do, how on earth do you know that he'd be any good at playing a character who does do stuff, and doesn't have the emotional complexity of a slug??

Sirion: Far be it from me to decide on behalf of everyone else (though it would please me to do so :D). I just think, having seen the range of Hans' acting abilities, and taking into account how shexy he is, that he would be ideal to play old Cadders.

[Gemini]

and taking into account how shexy he is, that he would be ideal to play old Cadders.
*cough*never*cough*

Well if that's all his character was supposed to do, how on earth do you know that he'd be any good at playing a character who does do stuff, and doesn't have the emotional complexity of a slug?? More than likely Leonie's seen him in other shows, that you may not be aware of.

Hmmm imagine that, in other shows you say?

And having said that, I could claim that Hans has absolutely no acting ability and it would have just as 'valid' as you saying that Richard has none, seeing as i have never seen Hans in anything.

In short, don't judge an actor based on a solitary performance and then say that they have the 'emotional complexity of a slug' (even if that was true and it isn't) when the character was meant to be played that way... :rolleyes: just my two cents

[bai_xu]

Hello, everyone.
I'm officially tuning out of this conversation...

[Mrs. Cadvan]

More than likely Leonie's seen him in other shows, that you may not be aware of.

Well, why don't you research him on a Film/TV database, then? He's done some British TV, but its not a particularly impressive C.V...

And having said that, I could claim that Hans has absolutely no acting ability and it would have just as 'valid' as you saying that Richard has none, seeing as i have never seen Hans in anything.

Excuse me!? Have you not read my previous comments? I explained eight posts ago that I do not think Richard is a bad actor, just that there are loads more actors who could do better justice to the complexity of Cadvan's character. So get thy facts straight! :p

In short, don't judge an actor based on a solitary performance and then say that they have the 'emotional complexity of a slug' (even if that was true and it isn't) when the character was meant to be played that way...

Another misinterpretation of what I wrote. If you had read more carefully, you'd have noticed I was talking about the character, not the actor. I'm not shallow enough to judge the personalities of people I don't even know, thankyou very much. *crosses arms*

[Suzie]

nice said mrs.C :D use r relly gettin argumentitive :p :D

[Becks]

God, calm down mrs Cadvan!!! Im sure hueva said that didnt actually mean it !!!! Calm down!!!!

PS. next time u say sumfin b sure that uv read it properly, we dont want ppl gettin hurt!!!

[Mrs. Cadvan]

God, calm down mrs Cadvan!!! Im sure hueva said that didnt actually mean it !!!! Calm down!!!!

PS. next time u say sumfin b sure that uv read it properly, we dont want ppl gettin hurt!!!

Me calm down? Me calm down?! ME CALM DOWN?!?!?

Wait a minute, whilst I mouth wordlessly like a goldfish...
...Ok. I'm OK.
Mine is not the only temper being frayed. Did you see Gemini's previous post! :D

[Suzie]

Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah y doesnt any1 speak on this thread

[Gemini]

b/c it's rather usless considering that the 'pellinor as movies' thread performs exactly the same function :D

[Gemini]

Oh Mrs Cadvan, i have an idea, lets reconcile this debate shall we? Agree to disagree, perhaps?

and BTW i have seen his IMDb profile and might i remind you it's the quality not the quantity that counts :D

so anyhoo, shall we all move on now...

Maybe we should discuss something different, like possible locations to shoot certain scenes? :rolleyes: