[aedhe]

The Gift... I don't know why, but it seems better to me.

When the Singing comes out, though, I'm pretty sure I'll obsess over that one.

[Rheingold]

Me too!!!!!!! :D:D:D

[piglover4551]

i liked the riddle more myself, b/c u had already gotten to know the character snad saw more progress, but then in the gift its the firt one and like the start 2 it all..so..yeah:rolleyes: :D

[Anna]

the riddle was for me! i loved the gift. In the riddle you became more connected with the characters, it had some great twists, it was very emotional. i think for mainly these reasons i liked the riddle more

[piglover4551]

yeah, same here, i love them all though!:rolleyes: :D

[FireLilyElednor]

hi..(staying on topic) I like the Naming (Gift) better....I thought the Riddle was a little darker..........and I wish she was nicer to Cadvan in the second one...that really annoyed me!:mad: :p :D so anyways, thats what I think!!

[cuteshortie]

I agree with u FireLilyElednor.I liked the naming better then the riddle.:D :D :D yeah i aso wished that she was more nicer to cadvan in the book.:D :p

[Bree]

I loved the Riddle most. I'm not sure what it was about it. i mean the Gift was the book that made me fall in love with the Pellinor seires, but the Riddle had a certain darkness about it that the Gift didn't. I liked the crow too, but I was a bit annoyed that it didn't follow Maerad for a while.

[Calypso]

The Riddle was definately the best in my opinion. The Gift was really, really good, but i thought the riddle had a better storyline. The Crow wasn't as good as the other 2 but it was still quite good.

[piglover4551]

the riddle is still my fav. too. The crow was good, but i guess i was distracted w/o M +c