[Power to the J]

what would you guys say

[alison]

"Leaf by Niggle" from Tree and Leaf.

The essay's pretty good too.

[Power to the J]

Alright thanks alot.

[Evil Agent]

Obviously, THE SILMARILLION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Power to the J]

Obviously, THE SILMARILLION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I've read that. What did everybody think of Children of Hurin?I haven't read it.

What about other stuff, like The Road Goes Ever On?

[Celebriän]

I've read Children of Hurin. Didn't really gain anything from it that you don't already get in the Silmarillion except a continous storyline. Good if you get confused by the various jumps in Silmarillion.

What is The Road Goes Ever On?

[goldhawk]

For me, it's a toss up between Smith of Wootton Major and Farmer Giles of Ham.