Home Literature Stories Movies Games Comics Blogs News Discussion Forum Art Gallery
  Science Fiction and Fantasy News
SFFWorld News – 11/16/09 (11-16)
SFFWorld News – 10/31/09 (10-31)
MERLIN Book Signing at Forbidden Planet UK (10-22)
Coming Soon TEMPEST RISING (10-09)

Official sffworld Reviews
The Words of Making by David Forbes (11-16 - Book)
Transitions by Iain M. Banks (11-16 - Book)
The Dragon Book: Magical Tales from the Masters of Modern Fa by Jack & Gardner Dann & Dozois (11-09 - Book)
Wolfbreed by S. Andrew Swann (11-02 - Book)

Site Index

    Bookmark and Share


View Full Version :

Critique: Converting screenplay montage to novel scene...does this work?


lin
August 20th, 2007, 12:52 AM
This is a section from a novel I'm working on. Bambina is a sort of feral teenager found on an isolated beach on a special preserve planet who has fallen into the care of Erin, the MC's girlfriend.

In the film script I am basing this book on, this was a montage under a music number, a "girl bonding" thing and for fun, mostly.

My posting it here is in response to a post in another thread about cinematic writing and conversions and my main concern is how it works in the format.

Thanks for any input.



The first invasion of Connecticut Post Mall by an extra-planetary lifeform ended in a standoff with collateral casualties on both sides.

Bambina, energetic though unfocused in the role of Alien Horde, was agog for the first hour of buzzing through the shops in Erin’s wake. The past few weeks had been rough on a nervous system honed by seventeen years of featureless beach and stormless ocean, but here the overload was like a relentless machine gun drilling her full of input and jaggedly mixed signals. But Erin was a seasoned mall campaigner and conscientious guide. The shiny toys, outré clothes, clamoring jewelry, insistent food odors, dazzled men, intimidated women, and otherworld design washed over her in a jumbling, jangling, intoxicating montage of stimuli, soundtracked by constantly shifting music.

When it looked like her head might explode, Erin schlepped them into Brookstone and plunked them down in futuristic massage chairs. Bambina lounged and gurgled, rapt in pleasure. She grinned at Erin, undulating slightly as the robot shiatsu wheels traversed her spine. She smiled fetchingly at the two male clerks who happened to be around that section of the store a lot, nothing loath to have the chairs in their front window occupied by a smashing redhead and this Polynesian movie star in the killer new halter top.

It only took about three times for Erin to convince her new mascot to use dressing rooms, not just strip down anytime she saw clothes she wanted. The worst one had been the jersey in the SportsLocker franchise, where the stripshow had an audience of a dozen male jocks. She was learning a few things, herself. Like not to try to get Bambina into shoes. She would tolerate sandals, but would also walk right out of them at any moment.

A pause to re-energize at a coffee chain so soul-less and blandly evil it might as well have been a Starbucks hit a snag when Bambina held her Americano up and lapped from it with her tongue. Shortly before throwing the cup across the room and wailing while holding her tongue and staring at Erin in hurt betrayal. Erin chilled that one out with an iced cappuccino and a tip to the kid with the mop.

In Victoria’s Secret an arch, elegant saleswoman practically purred to have such model-class customers. When she showed them a pair of lowcut, snaky black lace panties Bambina took them to examine, then sniffed them and licked them. The saleswoman shot Erin a knowing look that brought an instant flush, not all that becoming on a freckled redhead.

In the food court, Erin managed to control Bambina’s predictable impulse to graze the intriguing stalls of tantalizing odors, grabbing something tasty from each. She was not to prove popular with the sub-hourly employees of the burger and salad stations, but made a huge hit with two little girls at the next table when she sniffed at a bagel with cream cheese, stuck her finger through the hole and started nibbling around the edge, streaking her face with globs of Philadelphia’s finest. The little girls laughed uproariously at her technique, taking it as adult permission to smear their own faces with ice cream and donut filling.

Erin stalked the upper deck in sultry new finery, giving lethal looks to passing men. At the escalator landing she stopped to lean on the rail, peering over her sunglasses to scan the veldt for prey. She nodded to Bambina, who stepped off an imitation of her slinky glide that cracked up not only Erin, but twenty onlookers. When she reached the rail and did her take on the slouch and Vuarnet flourish the laughter mingled with applause. Erin mined a bow, so Bambina gave one, too, sweeping her hair to the floor.

Unwinding after a grueling day in the fashion trenches, Erin lolled in a stylish booth among their bags of new purchases, nibbling at a Long Island Iced Tea in an environment of ferns, beveled glass and big photos of people you’d be embarrassed to admit you didn’t recognize. She’d tipped the waiter extravagantly and dropped a few names, so Bambina also enjoyed a non-Tea, though in a paper takeout cup. Erin was marveling at the degree of bonding she’d achieved with this big, bouncy, dangerous puppychild: Bambina was having trouble sipping.

“I can’t feel my lips,” she said in a way that made it clear she was telling the truth. “Are they broken?”

“They’re just fine,” Erin told her. “Believe me.”

Bambina threw back her head and poured a finger of cocktail down her throat without any need for lip seal. She blinked around the room and fingered her lips wonderingly. “Can you kiss with numb lips?”

“Oh, it happens a lot.”

lin
August 23rd, 2007, 10:13 PM
Well....that's nice to know.

Sponsor ads
BrianC
August 24th, 2007, 06:27 AM
It's clever and well-written (but you know that already). It read light-hearted to me, a little flippant, playful and teasing. Nothing much happens, but if your purpose is to show that these women can become friends despite their obvious differences, and that Bambina (interesting name) isn't all that alien in every way, then it works for me.

lin
August 24th, 2007, 03:32 PM
Thanks for you comments, Brian.

Yeah, Bambina was found wandering naked on a tropical beach on another world. Place there to mature while awaiting a rich asshole who would come and use her for a sex toy.

The guys who find her (including Erin's boyfriend) try to communicate with her, but she is pretty feral. One guy is pointing and doing names, but she doesn't catch on. His buddy laughs and says, "Me Tarzan, you Bambi".
So they guy...who is Mexican... names her Bambina.

She ends up as Erin's roomie because she has nowhere else to go. As Erin says, "I like her, actually. And I'm not generally crazy about gorgeous bimbos with perfect bodies who **** my boyfriends."

Dawnstorm
August 29th, 2007, 08:32 AM
In the film script I am basing this book on, this was a montage under a music number, a "girl bonding" thing and for fun, mostly.

My posting it here is in response to a post in another thread about cinematic writing and conversions and my main concern is how it works in the format.

I wish I hadn't read these lines before reading the text itself. Now I can't help feeling that the first paragraph + first line of second paragraph read a bit like summary, or stage direction. Or a marketing pitch. After that it picks up, though.

It's fun to read, which is to say: it works.

A pause to re-energize at a coffee chain so soul-less and blandly evil it might as well have been a Starbucks hit a snag when Bambina held her Americano up and lapped from it with her tongue. Shortly before throwing the cup across the room and wailing while holding her tongue and staring at Erin in hurt betrayal.

That's a bit convoluted, I feel.

First, I'd either make a comma after tongue (effectively making the sentence even longer), or replace "shortly before throwing" with a simple "And then/and immediately/... threw" (<- examples, not specific advice). That's because I feel that breaking up at that point and making the next a standalone sentence fragment is a bit undermined by the anaphoric effect of "Shortly before throwing"; you reference the entire sentence yet again. (So: either don't separate, or reduce the anaphoric effect.)

Erin mined a bow, so Bambina gave one, too, sweeping her hair to the floor.

mined? (mimed?)

***

Me nit-pick, you writer. Heh.

lin
August 29th, 2007, 01:36 PM
Thanks, Dawn. And my nits thank you as well.

Yes, mimed. The are closer in meaning than one would think.

Traversing the mimefield of Central Park, for instance.

Dawnstorm
August 30th, 2007, 01:51 AM
Traversing the mimefield of Central Park, for instance.

Oh my, sounds bad. I think I distantly remember a film? Enemy Mime. Where a WASP stock broker goes into post-operative depression (throat cancer) and through a series of misunderstanding gets chased into the wilderness of Central Park, where he has to team up with a mime (the noble savage kind) to survive? There isn't much dialogue.

 

Latest

The Words of Making by David Forbes
11-16 - Book Review
Transitions by Iain M. Banks
11-16 - Book Review
SFFWorld News – 11/16/09
11-16 - News
The Dragon Book: Magical Tales from the Masters of Modern Fa by Jack & Gardner Dann & Dozois
11-09 - Book Review
Wolfbreed by S. Andrew Swann
11-02 - Book Review
Diving into the Wreck by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
11-02 - Book Review
SFFWorld News – 10/31/09
10-31 - News
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
Isis by Douglas Clegg
10-26 - Book Review
MERLIN Book Signing at Forbidden Planet UK
10-22 - News
Salamander by Nick Kyme
10-19 - Book Review
The Windup Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi
10-12 - Book Review
Triumff: Her Majesty's Hero by Dan Abnett
10-11 - Book Review
Coming Soon – TEMPEST RISING
10-09 - News
Something that is not a packaging device.
10-09 - News
How Victorious is the Victorious Parasol?
10-07 - News
The odd neighbors of a first-time homeowner
10-07 - News
Silly Fantasies
10-06 - News
Leviathan by Scott Westerfeld
10-05 - Book Review
X-Isle by Steve Augarde
10-04 - Book Review
“It Somehow Always Involved an Assassin with Extraordinary Powers And A Love of Espressos”
10-02 - News
In Their Own Words: K.J. Parker on The Company
10-02 - News
The Drowning City by Amanda Downum
10-01 - Book Review
Antarctica by Kim Stanley Robinson
09-28 - News
Beauty by Sheri S. Tepper
09-28 - News
The Black Raven by Katharine Kerr
09-28 - News
The Bone Doll's Twin by Lynn Flewelling
09-28 - News
Brightness Reef by David Brin
09-28 - News

New Forum Posts




About - Advertising - Contact us - RSS - For Authors & Publishers - Contribute / Submit - Privacy Policy - Community Login
Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use. The contents of this webpage are copyright © 1997-2009 sffworld.com. All Rights Reserved.