[vortexreader]

I find that there is a definite prejudice against SF in the broader reading community. I'v often had to defend my reading choices to people who have never even attempted to read a SF title.

Has anyone else ever been in the same situation? If so, how do you explain the appeal of SF to 'outsiders'?

[Erebus]

Never had to defend myself for reading anything actually! http://www.sffworld.com/ubb/smile.gif Although, once, I had a low-loader bring home a Jordan book from the local library, and I was asked: "Surely, you don't actually intend to read that do you?" http://www.sffworld.com/ubb/wink.gif

[Sammie]

Never have to defend Science Fiction reading - but fantasy....now that's a little different. Some of my friends kinda sneer at fantasy books. Though they all read Lord of the Rings, so you figure it out.....!

[Cadfael]

I have never felt I needed to, hence I read Goodkind http://www.sffworld.com/ubb/wink.gif

[SusF]

Hmm the only time I had anyone mention my reading only science fiction was in a directed reading course in high school. One day my teacher said that the next book I read can't be science fiction (that's all I'd read up to then).

So I brought in Portrait of Dorian Gray. Interesting read that sort of fit in with the other stuff I'd been reading. http://www.sffworld.com/ubb/smile.gif

My teacher wasn't unhappy with my choice of books. She read SF too. She just wanted me to mix it up a little.

Susan

[saintjon]

I've never had to defend reading any genre so much as reading in general. No one would try to tell me to stop reading in high school but everyone else always acted like I was some kind of oddity for reading so much.

[GevuldeKex]

There is a widespread belief that science fiction books are of low artistic or literary value. Some of them are, others are not. The point is, is that what you have to look for every time you open a book?
Another thing is that you have to be able to apply suspension of disbelief when you read science fiction, otherwise you couldn't even start to swallow the idea of, say, mixed crews of humans, dolphins and chimps cruising in deep space and communicating in haikus; and that's a question of imagination.
It is probably a shortcoming of "literature" its being often unable to address themes that are deemed too close to science fiction to be taken seriously by highbrow criticism.
I could go on forever, but already now it looks like the ones who loose here are prejudiced readers...

[Shehzad]

Well, I've had problems, true. Most people I know don't read fantasy and don't even know of it. Oft-times the only fantasies they know of and read are of a slightly, err, different kind.

Nancy Friday, anyone?

[vortexreader]

A number of my more 'literary' minded friends are highly critical of SF. When we discuss it I point out that I think reading SF has made me a better reader all round (only about half of what I read is SF, the rest is capital L 'literature'). The suspension of disbelief that someone else has mentioned makes you more open to the authors intent when reading mainstream novels. I think SF readers are better able to go with the flow of a book, allowing the story to progress naturally as they are more open to odd concepts and new ideas.

[nicba]

Have any of you ever read 'Fallen Angels' by Larry Niven, Jerry Pournelle & Michael Flynn?

It's one great tribute to Science-Fiction (and a rant at mindless ecology, btw). In the book, Science-Fiction has basicly been outlawed as not beeing 'proper litterature,' while fantasy is barely tolerated as escapist crap. Of course the three writers have a thing or two to say about that http://www.sffworld.com/ubb/smile.gif.

In the book the world is badly deepleted of resources and in the middle of an ice age. Some policemen find some SF books belonging to a fan and are about to trash them:

(Quote from the book below, hope it's allright with copyright and all that)


...

The books were The Sixth Winter, The Man Who Awoke, and Fahrenheit 451.

"Look at this crap, would you," Conte said in disgust. "With all the problems here on Earth, why would anybody waste their time with this escapist stuff? We oughta take these and throw them right into the trash can."

"What're the stories about, anyway?" Arteria took the dry, brittle volumes from Conte and read the back covers. Won't do to let them know I know already . . . "Get this. It says here that The Sixth Winter is about the sudden onset of an ice age; and The Man Who Awoke is about a scientist in 1933 who goes to sleep and wakes up in a future of depleted resources and ruined environments."

Conte took the books back. He scowled at them. "Yeah? What's the third one about?"

"Burning books."

...


He He, loved that scene http://www.sffworld.com/ubb/smile.gif