[Gary Wassner]

I am going on vacation and I need to pick four books to take with me. I rarely read these days because I am always in the middle of a book of my own, either writing or editing it seems, so this is a very very important decision. I am leaving my laptop at home and taking a real break for two weeks.

If you had to pick only four books to read, knowing that you will probably not be able to read again for a while, what would they be? Please try to think of four of the very best, the greatest you can remember! Those four that left indellible marks upon you and whose characters you will always remember for whatever reason. It doesn't have to be fantasy, in fact as long as it's fiction, it can be any genre. But please don't list any classics or fantasy that was published before 1999. Anything after would be excellent.

[Erfael]

Not sure if you've read it yet, but I've recently enjoyed Scott's Darkness That Comes Before quite a lot, but it definitely makes you want to keep going in the series, so if you're pressed for time after vacation, maybe not the best. But there's a lot of really good stuff in there, just the kind of things you're always on about epic fantasy being made for and I'm always on about that aren't in most of the epic fantasy out there.

[Gary Wassner]

Scott and I agreed to exchange books a month or so ago. I am anxious to read both of his, and he now has the first three of mine as well.

[Eventine]

Jonathan Carroll - White Apples
Jeff Vandermeer - Veniss Underground
Mary Gentle - Ash, A Secret History (Single Volume Edition)
China Mieville - The Scar

All are superbly written fantasy with a scope of imagination beyond what a lot authors are churning out these days. The Scar is Mieville's second novel in his Bas-Lag universe, but was much more enjoyable a read for me than its predecessor, Perdido Street Station.

Veniss Underground was nominated for the last World Fantasy Awards (and was my favourite of the nominations) and is written with an amazing narrative style and has imagery that will stay wit you for ages.

White Apples is the latest offering from the well repsected Carroll and appealed to me because of the characterisation.

Ans Ash, well, ask Hobbit :)

[Gary Wassner]

I read Perdido St and didn't really enjoy it very much, though Mieville has tremendous talent. It seemed all over the place at times and I did struggle through many chapters. It's just not my taste I suppose.

[Radone]

Why don't you read something new like Scott's books and something old that you haven't read in awhile. I re-read Thomas Covenant after a gap of alomst 15 years and it felt like a brand new book again. I vaguely remembered some of the important details (such as the ending), but the journey of the character was new once more.

[juzzza]

The Scar ~ China Meiville (just to see if you think he has improved, it is brilliant)

Heroes Die ~ Matt Stover

Dawnthief ~ James Barclay

A Game of Thrones ~ GRR Martin

[Rob B]

The Adventures of Kavalier and Klay by Michael Chabon. A Pulitzer Prize winner and one of the best books, maybe top 5, I have read in my 30 years of life. Being a NYC guy, Gary, I really think you'd appreciate some of what goes on in the book, it takes place in and around NYC.

The Wizard Knight by Gene Wolfe. Simply amazing, more accessible than his Sun books and a pure joy to read.

Heroes Die

Fallen Dragon by Peter Hamilton. A big book, very epic and many layers.

[KatG]

Nope, can't do it. First of all, lots of books. Second, why the 1999 limit? (And how am I going to remember the pub date of the books anyway.) Third, it's just a vacation, man. Can't you read something just for fun? :)

How about:

Neil Gaiman's "American Gods"
Stewart O'Nan's "A Prayer for the Dying"
Lindsay Davis's Marcus Didius Falco mystery series (the most recent are after 1999)
Tim Powers' "Expiration Date"

Of course, I could do lots of other four combinations. And there are all the epic fantasy series that I like, most of which started before 1999. If you're looking for newbies, or simply those you can find in print, the following are on my to read list:

David Sesnowski -- "Vamped"
Scott of course -- "The Darkness that Comes Before"
Cory Doctorow -- "Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom"
Sharon Shim -- "The Shape-Changer's Wife"

[Gary Wassner]

KatG - How did I know you wouldn't follow the rules? No only didn't you follow them, but you don't even like them! I thought all reading was for fun?
But, thanks for the suggestions.

I did not like American Gods. I was bored, terribly bored. And I was surprised that I was so bored with it. I tried very hard to enjoy it, but no matter how hard I tried, I just didn't care about the characters.

Some great ideas so far.