Results 1 to 8 of 8

Threaded View

  1. #1
    Edited for submission Holbrook's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    In the Shire
    Blog Entries

    A letter to Mr Stover.

    This is a copy of a letter I sent to Matt Stover, concerning his book, Heroes Die. He asked that I consider putting it up in the hope it might spark some discussion on how different people view a work.

    Anyway a request of this nature is something I take seriously so here goes.

    I have just finished reading Heroes Die and have been somewhat surprised in the book and my reaction and thoughts about it.

    To be honest I was off put at first by the comments on the many forums and boards concerning this work, most seemed to concentrate on the macho/male/violence content and attitude/nature of the main character in the book. This made me think it was not my type of book. On reading it I have found I enjoyed it and formed my own opinions about the character and his world.

    I feel that the two worlds or existences that Caine lives reflect a schism in his personality. That his fear and what he sees as his cowardice when dealing with the “real” world and its rigid caste system, corrupt society and the way everyone uses everyone else, (wait, am I talking about an fictional world here ) has lead to a form of impotence. He dare not act for fear of loosing the very things he believes he needs, his position, caste, money etc.

    It is only when faced with losing the one thing that was given to him freely (not bought or in any way given as a reward by the society he lives in) the love and companionship of another human being. The soul mate you might say if you believe in such. Even though at the being of the book it seems this relationship has been lost, it hasn’t as far as Hari/Caine is concerned.

    That he has to fight for this love in another world a world where he believes he is free from the very things that bind his existence elsewhere adds another layer. Because he is not free, is he? Caine is as much bound by the same things in that world as he is in the real world. They take a different form, but they are extensions of the “real” world holding him just as tight.

    As I read the book I began to realise that under all the various layers, the comments on society, class and the using of others for ambition, personal gain and pleasure. The hollowness that can lie at the heart of and society, there is another story, least for me.

    Strip everything away from us and what is the one thing worth fighting for and even dying, the love of another human being, given freely. To have one person that sees you, the whole you with all your flaws and still loves you. Accepting what you are, wanting you as you are. To give yourself completely to that other person and they to you, even if part of you doesn’t think it will last for ever, not to do it, to do everything to protect it is something you can’t contemplate.

    Anyway back to Caine, by fighting for the one thing that others would dismiss as unimportant, a mere sensual pleasure(a lot don't get what love is really about and never will), he shatters the bonds that hold him in both worlds and becomes a whole person? Perhaps? He certainly changes both worlds in some respects.

    You have sir under all the layers written quite a good love story One of the best I have read in a long time, I rate it up there with Joe Haldeman’s “Forever War” which for all its comments about the uselessness and waste of war had at its heart a true example of the emotional bond that exists between one human being and another.
    Last edited by Holbrook; September 18th, 2005 at 04:01 PM.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts