Pellinor "What If's" (spoilers)

**Firefall** · February 24th, 2007, 02:21 AM

I'm not sure if something like this has ever been done before, whether in general discussion or a specific thread, so if it has someone please tell me.

I got this from a forum for another book series I used to be on - it's Pellinor "What If's?". Basically you just speculate on what might have happened in the series if certain things had or had not happened. You can either just ask the question or try to answer/elaborate on it as well, for example:

What if Maerad had actually left at the end of The Gift, when she thought Cadvan worked for the Dark (chapter "Old Scars")? - Would she still have ended up in Zmarkan and Arkan-Da somehow? Where would she and Hem have gone? Would she still have lost her fingers? Would Cadvan have managed to track her down eventually and if so, would they have joined up again?

What if Maerad hadn't let Cadvan scry her at the beginning?

What if Hem hadn't let himself be scried? - Would everyone except Maerad have continued to suspect him of being a tool of the Dark?

They can be joking or serious, long or short, it doesn't really matter.

**The Phoenix** · February 24th, 2007, 03:04 PM

hmm, this is interesting. . .

What if. . . haha, i don't know!

What if Maerad hadn't remembered the elidhu pipes when she was stranded after the avalanche? would she have died? would hem have become the one?

hehe, what if cadvan had become a hull? what if maerad became a hull?

**piglover4551** · February 24th, 2007, 08:34 PM

What if Maerad never got to have mushrooms?!?!

the whole story would be imcomplete

**The Phoenix** · February 25th, 2007, 11:07 AM

nooooo! not the mushrooms!

**StarLily** · February 25th, 2007, 12:52 PM

what if maerad and cadvan never got seperated in the riddle?

**spring** · February 25th, 2007, 02:31 PM

what if maerad never escaped the winterking?

**summer** · March 3rd, 2007, 01:28 PM

what if cadvan actually had died ? or if thats a little too sad what if melina hadn't?

**Ingu** · May 25th, 2007, 03:46 AM

lol. Here's a thought: How would Maerad react if Cadvan admitted he loved her?

I think she'll be shocked, scared and then become depressed and confused all over again... and then think about her own feelings... and then come to an conclusion... and then tell Cadvan.

What would that conclusion be? O.o

lol. Any other how woulds?

How would Hem and Maerad react if Millana and Dorn reappeared?
How would Cadvan react if his dead love reappeared?
How would Hem and Cadvan react if Maerad and Arkan were together?
How would Maerad react if Cadvan told her that she couldn't have another bath ever again?
How would everyone react if they suddenly appeared in our world?

I think they'll all freak out... O.o

It's a bit like What if... except more wild!

lol. Any other how woulds?

**Ollie** · May 25th, 2007, 03:52 AM

How would everyone react if they suddenly appeared in our world? Surely one of them would be hit by a car....

**Sirkana** · May 25th, 2007, 06:51 AM

How would Dernhil react if he came back to life and found M+C engaged?
I'm not sure...

**Bree** · May 25th, 2007, 12:47 PM

How would Cadvan feel if mushrooms were banned?

He'd be sad..then he'd rebel

How would they react if all of a sudden all the pellinorites arrived in Annar?

Freak out and try and escape our randomness, then realise we are awesome and like us

**Rheingold** · May 26th, 2007, 07:08 PM

Ollie, you're too morbid for your own good.

How would everyone feel if PINEAPPLES started raining down from the sky?

or--How would Sharma react to a dream in which singing and dancing PINEAPPLES told him he was hot?

or more seriously, how would Hem react to Maerad calling him Cai?

**waahoo!** · July 31st, 2008, 02:27 PM

Omg I can't wait for The Singing to come out, I know it is already out in Australia so any who have read it NO SPOILERS!!!!!! How do you think it will end???
Do you think Maerad and Cadvan will get together?
Who do you think will die?
Do you think Maerad will defeat Sharma and everthing will end happily?

I for one am a definate M+C shipper!!!! If Cadvan dies the world will end!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I know there are already threads about this but I still want to know what others think about it!