Results 1 to 15 of 26

Thread: September 2008 BOTM: Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Administrator Administrator Hobbit's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2001
    Location
    Hobbit Towers, England
    Posts
    11,364
    Blog Entries
    126

    September 2008 BOTM: Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson

    Discussion is now open on this fairly recent publication.

    Here's the cover:



    and here's what Rob thought when he reviewed it for SFFWorld back in May 2006:

    With an impressive debut novel under his belt (Elantris), Brandon Sanderson launched the Mistborn trilogy in 2006 with Mistborn: The Final Empire. The primary plot of the novel involves a group of rebels who are trying to overthrow the God-like Lord Ruler of the Final Empire. One might say the story has a caper-like quality to it, but that would be underselling Sanderson’s expertly crafted story far too much. He populates this fantastical, red-skied, ash-falling, mist-rising world with believable characters in a fascinatingly detailed world.

    The novel follows three primary characters, the third character whose presence is felt just as much as the other two, despite sharing very little “on camera” time in the novel. Kelsier holds down the role as primary male protagonist; he is leading the rebellion against the Final Empire. Kelsier is also known as the Survivor, the only person known to return alive from the dreaded prison pits of the Lord Ruler. Though he may seem an outwardly familiar character type, the layers of Kelsier’s character are revealed very nicely over the course of the novel. Upon his escape, Kelsier discovers his Mistborn abilities; he is an allomancer. In Sanderson’s intricately imagined world, Allomancers ingest and burn metals to affect magical/supernatural powers.

    Sanderson’s second focus character is the young street urchin Vin, whose life prior to the novel consisted of roaming the streets with her brother. Upon the opening of The Final Empire, Kelsier invites her to be part of his crew, part of the rebellion. Kelsier sensed something special about the girl, specifically her abilities as an allomancer; he takes it upon himself to train her in the ways of Allomancy. The magic here is thoroughly detailed and well-thought out; one could say the rules dictating its practice are rigid enough to resemble a science. For all the details that inform Sanderson’s magic system, he revealed the inner workings of it slowly. It was an effective, yet simple method for Sanderson to inform, through Kelsier, both Vin and the reader about how the magic works.

    The third character is not seen quite as often as Vin and Kelsier, but his role is just as, if not more important. Each chapter opens with an entry from the diary of the Hero of the Ages, the boy who was prophesized to come into great power, hold a darkness at bay, and rule the world. While the journal entries from the boy who was the Lord Ruler provide insight to the reader of Mistborn, the characters stumble upon the book themselves. Throughout the course of the novel, the characters, specifically Vin, attempt to read into the character of the person who wrote the journal. She tries to make sense of how such a hopeful youth with so much promise and eagerness to do good, a young man who doubts himself, could become the hated dictator.

    Many threads of story are carried throughout the novel on the backs of these primary characters. One of Vin’s roles in Kelsier’s crew is to pose as the scion of a newly arrived noble. Part of the impetus behind Kelsier’s rebellion is his hatred of the noble and the rich. The only hate stronger is his hate for the Lord Ruler, who killed his wife in front of his own eyes. What Vin learns at the various society balls is (not too surprisingly) that not all the nobles should be as hated as Kelsier would have her think. Part of this is because of the attention she gives and receives to young noble, Elend Venture.

    Kelsier spends much of his time scattered throughout the Final Empire. At times he ignites the sparks of the rebellion, others he trains Vin, and in the rarest of episodes, he visits with his estranged brother. Sanderson’s novel and its world don’t rest solely on the three protagonists’ shoulders. He builds up a supporting cast who help to fully flesh out the seeds of rebellion and inform, particularly through the scholarly Sazed, the reader of the great backstory of the his world.

    While I liked the novel a great deal, and my enjoyment truly progressed with each page, Mistborn: The Final Empire, like all novels, is not without faults, even if they are minor. Perhaps my largest stumbling-block was Vin’s name. This is a name I normally associate with males, so it took a while for me to come to grips, for lack of a better term, with the fact that Vin was actually a girl. I also thought that the first few chapters following the prologue moved a bit slow. These are only minor problems I found with the novel, fortunately.

    Sanderson had been on my radar since the release of his debut novel Elantris, though I unfortunately haven’t gotten around to reading it just yet. Mistborn: The Final Empire has convinced me I need to go back and remedy that fact. In this opening novel of the trilogy, Sanderson pulled me into a phantasmagorical world I wasn’t sure about at first. By novel’s end, I felt fully entrenched in The Final Empire, I felt very much in tune with the characters and am glad I have the second book, Mistborn: The Well of Ascension, by my side to start reading. Readers who enjoy Greg Keyes, Robin Hobb, Gary Wassner would enjoy Mistborn.
    Does this bode well for the rest of Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time (which Brandon is currently working on)?
    Mark

  2. #2
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Brisvegas
    Posts
    132
    I must say I enjoyed this book a lot more than I expected to. I came in expecting some middle of the road bog standard fantasy, and got a rather unique and exciting read out of it. This book hooked me from the start and I raced through it as fast as I could. It could just be that I'm a sucker for city novels though, as travelogues tend to get a bit boring after a while.

    The plot was very different to a lot of books out there, not a "grand quest" as such, just a lot of machinations towards a final goal. The story behind the foundation of the final empire and the final revelations make for a lot of suspense, and I'm looking forward to getting the sequel to find out where it was all leading The great pacing and narrative direction in this book came out especially well in contrast to Shadowbridge last month. This book always felt like it was going somewhere, and there was always something happening or something to look forward to.

  3. #3
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    North Texas
    Posts
    108
    I really enjoyed this book when I read it about a year ago, but I don't remember a whole lot of details. I remember thinking that the magic system was quite unique. I bought the 2nd Mistborn book, but I only made it about 30 pages into it before setting it aside for a different book that I was wanting to read at the time. I have yet to go back to the 2nd book. I just have too many books on my to-read pile that look better.

    Also, I actually enjoyed Elantris better than Mistborn. I'd like to see a return to that world sometime.

    One other thing. I remember when I started reading the 2nd Mistborn book that I felt Sanderson was very repetitive a lot of times, especially when talking about the magic system and swallowing the coins. He seemed to use too much detail to describe how things worked even after he'd already told us how they worked a few pages before. I can't recall if the first book had this same issue or not.

  4. #4
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Saint Louis, MO
    Posts
    6
    I just started this yesterday. I am only on the third chapter but so far so good. It has not necessarily "hooked" me... but it has gained my interest. One of the things that I have enjoyed early on is the atmosphere: falling ash, mist, and the effect it is having on the environment. Vivid stuff...
    I am looking forward to where this goes.

  5. #5
    Ooh, I like that cover a lot more than my copy's. Hobbit, which version is that?

    I'm so happy that I finally read this! I agree with Zedar: It definitely benefits from following Shadowbridge. While I kind of slogged through Shadowbridge, I hardly put Mistborn down. Sanderson does such a good job with the pacing. I mean, I knew the story was actually going somewhere! It was very satisfying to watch the progession from the conception of the plan, through the set-backs and complications, all the way to the execution--in one book! While this is the first of the 3 book series, Mistborn stands by itself as a thoroughly enjoyable novel. I can't wait to read the second, because Sanderson left enough mysteries unsolved to keep my attention piqued.

    Some flaws: It took me a while to become accustomed to the magic system. There was a little too much detail overload in the beginning, and I had a difficult time remembering which metal caused which effect. Not a big deal, it just meant I had to flip to the back of the book to keep them straightened out. The magic system itself was pretty cool, and it's incorporated very seamlessly into the story. You know an author does a good job when he takes something completely foreign, then makes it a natural part of the world, so much so that the reader expects to find it even in the most mundane activities. Yeah, some descriptions became a little repetitive, but this was easy enough to overlook. I got the feeling that Sanderson had FUN dreaming this system up.

    On an unrelated note, does anyone know why they changed the artwork for the US paperback versions? I like my books to match--not to mention the fact that I loathe the new artwork--so I'd like to get a paperwork copy of Well of Ascension with the hardback cover art. Does anyone know if this is possible? And if so, where I can find it?
    Last edited by Ademona; September 3rd, 2008 at 01:41 AM. Reason: to add something of substance to my post :)

  6. #6
    Analyze That
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Now off an island
    Posts
    574
    This is a really good book. The magic system is the best I've read as far as a combination of creativity and the way it is entrenched into the story. The plot is exciting, it looks like it's going to be predictable, and then it isn't. You actually care somewhat about the characters.

    However since flaws are always easy to find, here's a couple things that annoyed me:
    1. Vin and Elend romance was pretty well a disney story line. Girl and guy are in love but are from very different social standings so it doesn't look like it's going to work out, but then it does. Nope, never seen that before.
    2.One very small thing that really annoyed me was that one scene when Kelsier was talking to Mennis in the middle of the book (not the prologue). He called Mennis by his name every other sentence. Do you ever talk to someone and keep using the persons name. They're the only person there, obviously you're talking to them. That really annoyed me for some reason.

    Very good book overall, and the second one is even better. Ithink he'll do a good job with A Memory of Light.

  7. #7
    \m/ BEER \m/ Moderator Rob B's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2000
    Location
    Near Cows in the Garden State
    Posts
    10,711
    For folks who did enjoy the first Mistborn novel, I can tell you the quality remained throughout the trilogy. Having said that, here's my review of the third of the trilogy The Hero of Ages (beware some spoilers, though):
    Another thing Sanderson continually does throughout the trilogy is question the role of leadership and its relationship to perspective. At the outset of The Final Empire, the Lord Ruler is portrayed as an uncompromising tyrant. Once he’s dead; however, more light is shed on Rashek, his name prior to becoming the Lord Ruler. Through journal snippets and what Vin, Elend, and their advisor Sazed discover, the Lord Ruler was not the tyrant they thought him to be. They saw the reasons for what he did and why he kept such a strict rule in the Final Empire. Although they react in a way to suggest they might not have approached the problems encountered by the Lord Ruler in the same way, they can understand why he did what he did, which in turn logically informs their decisions and approaches to those same problems. These related themes are also echoed in both Vin’s and Elend’s thoughts as they try to balance their power, they continually brace their actions with thoughts of not wanting to be perceived as they perceived the Lord Ruler. Elend in particular handles this struggle very convincingly and it’s a credit to Sanderson’s great skills at how effectively this is woven into the overall plot of the novel and trilogy as a whole.

  8. #8
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Paris
    Posts
    50
    Great review Rob, thanks !

    I'm awaiting eagerly Hero of Ages to come out ! I loved Mistborn & The Well of Ascension.

  9. #9
    \m/ BEER \m/ Moderator Rob B's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2000
    Location
    Near Cows in the Garden State
    Posts
    10,711
    Thanks annabelle! A nice little perk was seeing part of my review for the second Mistborn novel blurbed on the jacket flap of the third one.

  10. #10
    Gentleman and Scholar Wulfa_Jones's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Oxfordshire, UK
    Posts
    1,077
    I'm about halfway in to The Final Empire and really enjoying it so far.

    The magic system is well thought out, but reminds me of something that could be used in a computer game - would be very cool to use Allomancy powers to swing though a city. In fact, the whole thing kinda reminds of of a Final Fantasy game, not sure why!

    The book also reminds me a little of The Lies of Locke Lamora, but I think that is just because Kelsier is a little like Locke - the cocky thief with grand ideas.

    I like the short passages at each chapter, which I guess tell the story of the Lord Ruler. I get the idea that the Lord Ruler was the "farm boy" who was the chosen one, defeated the evil (deepness?) and then got a little power mad!

    I also like the idea of a revolution - not really read a fantasy book with this as the theme. Sure we have people over-throwing evil empires, but the way the book is written gives it a more grounded feel.

    I've been reading outside the genre for the last few months and this is a nice book to return on.

  11. #11
    Peckish hippokrene's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Between here and now
    Posts
    1,200
    I picked up the book last night, enjoyed it so much I went back for the other two in the trilogy, and then finished around 2 am. The beginning of the story felt very uninspired both at the stereotypical evil slave master and Kell’s interaction with a stock ‘stubborn leader’ who never reappears. I believe Sanderson aimed at a darker fantasy novel, but couldn’t quite deliver.

    At the same time, it was an enjoyable, interesting read. The motley crew was interesting with diverse personalities, the action interspersed well with the planning, and the world building and magic unique.

    I found Vin’s mastery of Allomancy believable, as it’s obvious she has a special heritage. I wouldn’t be surprised the later books showed her mother was also more than run-of-the-mill. Her ability to master court manners seemed less likely. Sure, her street background taught her to adapt, but she’s interacting with people who have dedicated their lives to these sorts of interaction.

    The characterization also fell flat at times. I noticed that if a person waddles, that meant they were bad. Fat cells apparently store evil. Rape was also used for stock characterization.

    I wish Sanderson had been a bit more subtle about the Lord’s ‘secret.’ I figured it out about a third through the book, and then he mentioned that the Lord constant wore metal jewelry (I counted) eight more times. Given that we are told relatively little else about the current-day Lord, Sanderson’s emphasis on this one detail was heavy handed.

    Edit: Vin was originally a boy.
    Last edited by hippokrene; June 2nd, 2009 at 04:03 PM.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •