Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 16 to 25 of 25
  1. #16 DurzoBlint's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Tacoma, WA/ Seoul, South Korea
    Blog Entries
    I just finished this book the other night. I figured with all the hype surrounding it that even at its worst the book would at least be decent. Not the case, the first third was confusing and left unexplained. The next two thirds were boring and what little I could glean from it I found obvious. If this is the first in a trilogy I am going to have to pass on the rest of the series.

    What little action found in the book was over in mere seconds and regardless of the outcome, I found I did not care as the characters were so two dimensional and lame. I am left feeling very disappointed.

  2. #17
    \m/ BEER \m/ Moderator Rob B's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2000
    Near Cows in the Garden State
    I'm about 2/3 into the book right now and I like it a lot. I'm reminded of Iain M. Banks and parts, small parts, remind me a bit of Mark L. Van Name's Jon and Lobo novels. I don't think it will stand up to either of my top two SF reads of the year at this point (Kings of Eternity by Eric Brown and Leviathan Wakes by James S.A. Corey), but I don't know that any SF book this year will stand up to those two

  3. #18
    I really enjoyed it. Pretty sure it could have been twice the size and made me happier though, but that's me.

  4. #19
    The Fifth Dominion Westsiyeed's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Got about half way through this and stopped, and from what I read I agree with Durzo and Suciul. Too much jargon that wasn't explained enough, from the start the story was an information/technical overload, and the characters were uninteresting. It's almost like the author was trying too hard to make an impact with his first novel (though he did!) but for me it just comes off as a fairly unreadable mess.

    Not my cup of tea!

  5. #20
    \m/ BEER \m/ Moderator Rob B's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2000
    Near Cows in the Garden State
    I just posted my review and for the most part, I enjoyed the novel and recommend it. The pacing was a bit uneven and the book really, REALLY should have had a glossary of terms.

  6. #21
    I'd agree with that but I think it'd stand a second reading quite soon after as a result.

  7. #22
    Dazed Rambler Winter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Olathe, KS
    Quote Originally Posted by suciul View Post
    Finished the book and the author's short stories give a good preview of this in some ways, so while the early reviews made me think it will be better, it was pretty mediocre in many ways.

    massively over-hyped debut that has mediocre writing and over-reliance on gadgetry, becoming basically "my magic is bigger than yours" and having a destined boy to boot (all done sf-nally true but in consequences as close to magic as to make little difference except in jargon, including the noble blood/ok genetic factors but same stuff different disguise).

    As comparisons go, this is so far from the great prose of RK Morgan to make it a ridiculous comparison, while in content Liz Williams Solar System novels (Banner Souls, Winterstrike) are more interesting and engaging and better written; a B for its goodies and the ending is interesting enough so i will check the sequel, but unless the author shows he can write fiction and not only gadgetry I am afraid this series will go on my dropped list soon
    This, though chances are I will not be continuing on with the series unless someone sends me the sequel.

    Seems I am agreeing with you a lot lately. I read and reviewed this a couple months ago. I really don't get all the hype surrounding something so mediocre, but oh well.

  8. #23
    AS=1/2(Vf**2-Vi**2) Diosces's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    New Jersey


    Finished reading Quantum Thief and like others I found the first half very confusing and disjointed. Although the book has some interesting concepts, the author fails to integrate these in coherent fashion.

    and the protoganist comes off like a real ass.

    Wanted to like it a lot but can't say I enjoyed.

    Now my follow up read, Rule 34 is going quite grand...

  9. #24
    Registered User Roland 85's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Bloomington, IN
    Wow! I am really surprised with all the negative feedback here. I mean, to each his own of course, but considering how much praise the book has gotten so far, I expected more of it here. Anyway, here's my review:

    Needing a break from the A Song of Ice and Fire marathon that I have been doing, I decided to go for something completely different. Hannu Rajaniemi's first long form work The Quantum Thief was hailed by many as the debut of 2010, and I am a sucker for good space opera, so - mistakenly thinking the book would fall in that genre - I gave it a go.

    The story is set in the far future, in a posthuman solar system where most human minds have been uploaded as "gogols" in virtual environment, indistinguishable from the artificial intelligences that also roam the multiple realities of the ruling entity - the upload collective of the Sobornost. Governed by the copyclans - the trillions of copies of the Founders - the Sobornost turns every other uploaded mind into a slave gogol to serve its mysterious purpose, known as the Great Common Task.

    Meanwhile, in the outer reaches of the system other societies fight to remain independent of the copyclans. The Oortians from the Oort Cloud are transhuman warriors whose society - based on Finnish culture - has adapted their manufactured bodies to zero gravity and the freedom of open space. The Zoku are another posthuman group, similar to the Sobornost, who once lost the great Protocol War with it and as a result had to hide on Mars. They are descendants of MMORPG gamers and their entire culture is shaped around the pursuing of games, achievements and leveling up. For them everyone else is a "meme zombie", one who doesn't "play".

    And on Mars is the Oubliette - the last baseline human society. A walking city constantly on the run from the whirlwind of trillions of self-replicating killing machines called phoboi, the Oubliette is a place of privacy and old technology, untouched - except for the Zoku colony - by the nanotech quantum singularity that transformed the rest of the system. Its citizens follow an endless cycle of death and rebirth. Everyone carries a Watch that measures their Time as a Noble - a conscious baseline human body. Time is both a measure, and a currency, allowing one to shorten or lengthen their human life in exchange for services, goods and the right to create children. When one's Time is up, their body shuts down and is stored while their mind is temporarily uploaded into a Quiet - machines tasked with maintaining the walking city and fighting off the phoboi threat.

    The Quantum Thief's main character is Jean le Flambeur - a notorious thief, alluded to have known many of the Sobornost Founders and possibly hailing from an age close to our own time. Jean has lived many lives in the many societies of the system, stolen both artifacts, ideas and minds, and committed acts that are now a legend. However, he failed in his last project, and as a result was imprisoned in the Dilemma Prison - a structure governed by the Sobornost created Archons tasked with "reprogramming" malevolent minds so they can be uploaded into the collective. But as the novel begins, Jean is saved by the Oortian warrior Mieli and her mysterious godlike benefactor. In return, he has to help them with a theft that only he is capable of, but first, he needs to find the missing pieces of his mind - pieces he hid in the Oubliette a generation ago.

    I spend so much time describing the setting and story because The Quantum Thief has not a single speck of mercy for the reader. It bombards you with terminology only half of which is ever explained properly, and the rest is left to your powers of deduction. Even so (or maybe because of that?), the book is immensely rewarding. The first part of a planned trilogy, it is almost entirely set in the Oubliette, thus focusing on a single aspect of the solar system and giving the reader an in-depth view of this posthuman future where the human mind is only another piece of digital information and bodies are easy to create, replace and upgrade.

    Apart from Jean and Mieli, there is a third main character - the young Oubliette freelance detective Isidore Beautrelet who solves mysteries on behalf of the Tzadikkim (Hebrew for "righteous ones"), a group of mysterious vigilantes that protect the peace of the walking city with their Zoku-based technology far more advanced than anything the Oubliette uses. Isidore has the ability to see patterns in events and make connections that nobody else could make, which makes him an invaluable part of everybody's plans, and thus - the book's fascinating plot.

    And it is fascinating. The Quantum Thief moves with lightning speed, giving you just enough time to kind of orient yourself in the current situation before changing it. Yet the story doesn't feel rushed at all, just charged. Although there are only two plot lines, and the connection between them becomes apparent early on, the finale is still really neat in combining multiple elements of the story so far, and giving a very satisfying conclusion considering that this is only part one of a trilogy.

    Rajaniemi's style of writing is great, without drawing attention to itself. Straight to the point, but with enough flourish not to betray the author's hardcore mathematics background (PhD in Physical Mathematics among other degrees). The Quantum Thief sports zero scientific outbursts of the variety that has completely and forever put me off hard SF writers like Stephen Baxter for example, and yet you can clearly see Rajaniemi knows what he is talking about. He is just far more interested in worldbuilding and storytelling, and he has my utmost gratitude for it.

    That said, his writing style is not without its flaws. Characters aren't especially complex and their development leaves a lot to be desired in terms of change. They aren't one-dimensional, and they do change with the book's progress, but there is definitely a room for improvement in that aspect, even if it doesn't deter from the enjoyment. My more serious problem is the way information is given to the reader. Like I said, The Quantum Thief throws you in the deep water with very little interest in your ability to swim. Personally, I really love that approach, as I choose to trust the author will eventually make it all clear to me. And Rajaniemi definitely does that, but he seems to not be able to strike the balance for it. Half the time information is just too sparse for the reader to be certain of anything (I must admit to going online too look up some of what I wrote in the previous paragraphs), and the other half is given in rather clumsy infodumps. Not long ones - characters don't burst into sudden talking head mode, thank Cthulhu - but still pretty obvious, and considering that they usually describe the things we are already more or less clear on, I would say the effect is quite unnecessary.

    Still, I absolutely loved that book. It is action-packed, and chock-full of ideas. I haven't even touched on the amazing concept of gevulot - the privacy protocol used in the Oubliette - or the walking city's "exomemory", the Sobornost gubernyas, the Zoku Spimescapes, or the cool weapons and other technology used in the action scenes. And the main plot - of which this novel is only the very beginning, even if it is a complete story on its own - seems to be really promising. So, in case it wasn't obvious, The Quantum Thief is a total must read. I am not sure if I would put it above the other great 2010 debut - Bacigalupi's The Windup Girl - but it's definitely among the best SF debuts I've read in a long time, and utterly worth the very little time it will take you to devour it. With a slightly easier access to the world, and a little more character development, it could have been a masterpiece. Still, I can't wait for The Fractal Prince to come out next year!


  10. #25
    Registered User Pennarin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Rimouski, Canada
    I'm thinking the Gollancz first edition may end up like Reynold's Revelation Space Gollancz first edition...that is, a collection item within a year or so of publication; within a few decades, a cash cow.
    For one, I'm buying the Tor version so the cover will match that of the next book in the trilogy (which Tor will also publish), but I'm keeping my Gollancz copy close to my chest!

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts