Results 16 to 30 of 47
May 10th, 2011, 01:16 PM #16
Erf- Thanks for the tip. I'll look into it!
Your other points...
I don't usually read too many amazon reviews, I prefer to see what folks around here, or various bloggers whom I trust think rather than relying on some random amazon reviewer. That said, I can see why some people would be upset about the book being split in two.
Personally, if the whole thing had been printed as one massive 800-1000 page novel, that would have been a big turn off for me. I have a hard time getting through massive tomes like that these days, so splitting it makes the story a lot more accessible to me. However, I'm not such a fan of shelling out the extra money for the cost of two books instead of one, so it is a bit of a wash out. At the same time, I'm gonna spend money on books regardless, so spending it on a sequel to a story I'm looking forward to and already invested in doesn't sting nearly as bad.
May 10th, 2011, 01:48 PM #17
I don't really know how I ended up seeing the Amazon reviews for this one. I don't usually read those, either. Maybe I saw them when I was checking prices and availability for All Clear.
Another point: My money is on an adult Colin showing up at the end. Makes the most sense given how they set up the relationship between him and Polly at the beginning.
May 10th, 2011, 02:41 PM #18
I think Colin coming to attempt the rescue would be more interesting than Dunworthy. The fact that Willis didn't say who it was made me wish for a copy of All Clear.
May 10th, 2011, 03:05 PM #19
I didn't remember he was going for St. Paul's.
May 10th, 2011, 11:04 PM #20
Despite that, I still hope it is Colin and not Dunworthy that came to 1940. I think he'd be a much more interesting character given his crush on Polly, and and all that.
May 13th, 2011, 04:44 AM #21
I'm half way through now and finding it a gently engrossing book. Without the backdrop of the time travel it would be a reasonable soap-opera style account of WW2; as it's SF though it's twisted into something totally different. I can really imagine that this kind of thing actually goes on and we have just never noticed!!
May 13th, 2011, 09:18 AM #22
On the topic of blowing up tanks: I loved that whole sequence. He's so grumpy about having to go blow up the tanks...one assumes detonate. Then they're making big balloon tanks. For some reason the whole thing cracked me up.
May 14th, 2011, 10:39 AM #23
Yeah, that scene was pretty funny. I get the sense that Gerald has a larger part to play in All Clear.
May 15th, 2011, 03:44 PM #24
Did anyone manage the cryptic crossword clues on page 320??
May 15th, 2011, 04:10 PM #25
You know, I didn't spend a lot of time with them, but as someone who does a LOT of cryptics, they did seem a little off. But, then again, I tend to do American-style, National-Puzzlers-League-Style Cryptics, so if they're terribly British, I may have trouble with them.
May 16th, 2011, 09:23 PM #26
May 18th, 2011, 05:02 AM #27
Having got 90% of the way through the book, and knowing that it's just going to cut off before the final half, I think I can now safely say Blackout has been a very enjoyable read. All the usual Connie Willis elements are there, both good - the minutiae of accurate historical facts integrated into the plot; the well rounded characters; the tension - and the bad - the repetitive prose; the long winded passages featuring characters just running around looking for other characters. The scene setting was so successful that at times I found myself believing this was really happening and that there were historians amongst us as I read, lost and looking for their drops!
Stylistically, I wished Willis would stop ending sentences in the middle. Which she did all the time, like that, for dramatic effect. Once or twice was fine; twenty or thirty times was getting a bit annoying. I was not really sure of the success of the 'cliff-hangers' at the ends of each chapter, but it didn't mar the experience. Perhaps the only real problem for me was that the threads involving Polly and Elaine were by far the best: the others involving Dunkirk, the FANYs and the inflatable tanks were just distracting really. Perhaps this will be remedied by the second part, but for now I would have preferred them to have just been isolated chapters that were inserted for interest rather than to return to them more than once. Still, with that in mind, I'm looking forward to reading All Clear later this year.
EDIT - I just realised the chapters featuring the FANYs were the early chapters of Polly's drop - somehow I didn't make the connection between her leaving them and traveling to London. So maybe my comments about the two best threads in the book should really be that I felt little empathy for the two male characters, whose drops didn't inspire quite the same level of believability.
Last edited by Ropie; May 18th, 2011 at 05:25 AM.
May 18th, 2011, 10:25 AM #28
A couple of other thing that bothered me about this book:
Nearly everything that happened was the result of someone's - usually incorrect - assumption. Take a look: it's either a person not turning up when expected or someone thinking someone is talking about one thing when they mean another, or a journey taken on the assumption that something or someone will be waiting at the other end...
Another thing - what's the difference between a divergence point and any other event, no matter how trivial? If, as quoted in the book, a butterfly flapping its wings in one continent can cause a storm in another, surely any action would prevent a time traveller from visiting the past?
May 18th, 2011, 10:32 PM #29
Hello, I am new here and finding my way around. It took me ages to find this thread because I was searching the SF Bookclub thread/section. Is that no longer being used? I'm a little confused.
Anyhow, I have put the Connie Willis book on hold with my library ... just have to wait for it to turn up. I presume it is ok to post into June if I haven't finished the book by then?
I have read two of her books: "Passage" which I loved and couldn't put down and "Bellwether" which left me wondering why I'd bothered. I sent it to the op-shop. I am very fond of time travel stories and am looking forward to giving this one a go.
May 19th, 2011, 02:19 AM #30
- Join Date
- Jul 2001
- Hobbit Towers, England
- Blog Entries
Suzie: thanks for joining in.
Apologies for the confusion, the thread's usually in the area with most traffic, and there's usually a direct link between the thread and the first post in the 'Reading in....' threads, that we do each month.
The threads at the end of the month are usually archived. However they remain open for further discussion as members sometimes don't get to the book until later. Waiting for the book to turn up can sometimes take longer than expected!