
Originally Posted by
emohawk
My sentiments more or less exactly. Imho this is without hesitation the single worst edition to Gollancz' SF Masterworks series. Clearly Harrison has few peers when it comes to beautiful prose, but the story itself is pretty horrifically bad. It's almost like it he spent so much time prettying up the words that he almost completely ignored the content of the book. Half the time it's so convoluted you can barely care to wonder what on earth he's going on about. I have a feeling I've made my comments in this forum before about this book, but I guess it won't kill anyone to read them again. I read an interview with Harrison once and he basically was bemoaning the fact that the he has plently of good books that are out of print and one of the few that actually was in print he was embarrassed to have even published, let alone have it touted in a "Masterwork" series, he thought it was that bad. After hearing that I didn't feel as bad about thinking it was terrible. It was obvious in reading it that he was a fine writer, that much mananged to shine through an otherwise awful book.
Bookmarks