"Guilty Pleasure" books

Alchemist

Registered User
Joined
Sep 26, 2007
Messages
1,117
You know those books that you read when you were young and were amazing then, but upon revisiting them later you found them less than High Literature and Cutting Edge Fantasy? (insert "tm" if necessary). But you still find yourself returning them for an occasional re-read once every few years? I'm talking about those. Books you realize aren't the greatest literature, or even fit your current tastes, but you find yourself returning to and enjoying. I'm not talking about books that sustained their "literary merit" throughout the years, but those you realized weren't quite up to the par of your more developed palate, whether in terms of literary chops or imaginative escapades.

The first that come to mind is The Belgariad. I absolutely loved this series when I first read it, around the tender age of 12--sometimes called "the golden age of scifi." If I remember correctly, upon finishing the series, I picked it up and re-read it again. And then a few years later, and then again sometime in my 20s, and then I started re-reading it in my mid-30s, about six or seven years ago and have considered re-reading it soon. I just feel good when reading them - fun, enjoyable characters. A decent, if predictable, storyline. An evocative, if not crazily imaginative, world.

It is like seeing an old movie from my childhood, like Sixteen Candles or Pump Up The Volume. I no longer relate with the teen angst, but I enjoy visiting an old friend (and the message of PutV is still very relevant, but that's an aside). Or maybe a rom-com like When Harry Met Sally or Notting Hill or You've Got Mail, that you--or at least I--like to re-watch to feel warm and bubbly.

Another that comes to mind is Dragonlance - at least the original Chronicles and, to a lesser degree, Legends. I read them around the same time as the Belgariad, maybe a bit before, and almost equally loved them. I re-read it maybe about 10 years ago and found the prose, at least at the beginning, to be rather poor, but its a great story - even today - with some really human moments (who didn't cry at the Raistlin-Caramon "bunnies" story?).

What about you?
 
p.s. There are other books that I like to re-read every half decade or decade, but I don't consider them "guilty pleasure." These are what I consider my all-time favorite classics - Lord of the Rings, of course, as well as Earthsea, Riddlemaster, and anything written by David Zindell, an obscure favorite of mine who I think is one of the most underappreciated authors out there.
 
I missed out on Belgariad when I was younger. Tried it recently and found it derivative and slow. But I probably would have enjoyed it when I was in high school! Tastes change, I guess!
 
Anne Bishop's Dark Jewels - not without problems, but I still find it as compelling as it was on my fist reading more than a decade ago.
 
I missed out on Belgariad when I was younger. Tried it recently and found it derivative and slow. But I probably would have enjoyed it when I was in high school! Tastes change, I guess!

It is hard for me to say how I'd feel about it now if I read it for the first time. I imagine that I wouldn't love it like I did (and still do), but would still enjoy it for the classic quest story and fun characters that it is.

Also, remember that more books are derivative of the Belgariad than it is derivative of - it was written in 1982-1984 when the modern epic quest fantasy era was just getting going. Before it came LotR, of course, and Shannara, but most of the "vanilla" quest fantasies came after, and many were influenced by the Belgariad.
 
I agree with everything bad that can be said about the Belgariad and I have read it 3 times (all as an adult).
 
Stories from the original Weird Tales. Between the more accomplished stories by Lovecraft, Robert E. Howard, Clark Ashton Smith, C. L. Moore, Ray Bradbury, Robert Bloch, Fritz Leiber, etc., was a good deal of, politely speaking, poop. But a sizable amount of it tickles me in much the same way as the old monster movies I watched Saturday afternoons as a kid (introduced by Dr. E. Nic Witty and his helper, Epal). So I read some of it now and again, and usually with grin.

Randy M.
 
The seventies comic books on The Savage Sword of Conan - the black and white ones penned by Roy Thomas, John Buscema, Alcala and others. Plenty of purple language, fountains of blood, barenaked ladies, monsters everywhere. Great covers too, that you might want to hide when reading in public places.
 
WTF??? Are you my evil twin? Did I transfer over to the bizarro alternate universe? I started a thread with the very same thread title like 6 months ago. Too lazy to find it right now. Plus, I've read both threads, so logically it is more worth your time to search for the old one, not mine :)

I had a few good responses, but also a lot of "Huh, why would I ever feel "guilty" about reading something?".
 
WTF??? Are you my evil twin? Did I transfer over to the bizarro alternate universe? I started a thread with the very same thread title like 6 months ago. Too lazy to find it right now. Plus, I've read both threads, so logically it is more worth your time to search for the old one, not mine :)

I had a few good responses, but also a lot of "Huh, why would I ever feel "guilty" about reading something?".

That's funny. I thought this was that thread.

Here it is: List Your Guilty Pleasure Reads
 
When I was younger I never rear book twice but there are two books which I read more than once. It is To Sail Beyond the Sunset (Robert A. Heinlein) and maybe The Witches' Daughter (Dorota Terakowska). Now I am 22 and I would like to read a few books which I read when I was younger and I am afraid of it because I don' t want destroy beautiful memories (one of the book is not science fiction: Arthur Ransome - Swallows and Amazons) I am afraid of dissapointing my expectations. :o
 
Not "guilty" pleasures at all, but I have found myself rereading any of the books in the Miles Vorkosigan series (I know, sf) and the Dresden series multiple times. And it may be getting time to read LoTR again.

As for the Belgariad -- I couldn't stand it. Read about 1/2 of the first book and tossed it. Sorry! ;-)
 
Guilty pleasures

To be honest mine are often a break from the genre, love reading Lee Child and Clive Cussler. I've seen the Belgariad mentioned a few times but I don't get it, I think thats more down to personal taste than guilty pleasure. I loved them and the Mallorean after that. I do go back and read "the Amtrak wars" now and again as well
 
My latest guilty pleasure is superhero novels. A good chunk of them have silly plots and cheesy dialogue that I wouldn't stomach in traditional fantasy novels, but which I don't mind overly much here. Certainly, I've read some that are fairly well written, but even so, I wouldn't feel comfortable answering honestly if we are at the beach with another couple and they ask what I'm reading.
 
My latest guilty pleasure is superhero novels. A good chunk of them have silly plots and cheesy dialogue that I wouldn't stomach in traditional fantasy novels, but which I don't mind overly much here. Certainly, I've read some that are fairly well written, but even so, I wouldn't feel comfortable answering honestly if we are at the beach with another couple and they ask what I'm reading.

I know exactly what you mean. I have the same fealings about love books about vampires. :o It is just relaxing reading :cool:
 
If anyone mentions Twilight, thats NOT a guilty pleasure, thats just guilty!
 
If anyone mentions Twilight, thats NOT a guilty pleasure, thats just guilty!

There are a lot of better books of this type then Twilight! :o (But I also read Twilight but is just romantic book for teenage girls, there is no dept in this book. But I don't like people who judge it. This book is only overestimated and people don't understand that it is good book in RIGHT category - love books for teenage girls. If you understand what I mean. It is simply another harlequin book)
 
I'm sure we've had this thread before... anyway, I refuse to feel guilty about reading anything but the naffest thing I like is the Warhammer 40k novels, especially the Dan Abnett ones. Yes it's all ridiculous but Rule Of Cool prevails, and Abnett is a good enough writer that he can work genuinely human characters and suffering into what's basically an overblown wargame.
 
Back
Top