“Classic” is a fun way to start a discussion. Won’t beat a dead horse and say it’s
just a little nebulous!
Even so, whatever it may mean, SFFWorld must be the greatest single place in the world (universe?) for learning about “under-appreciated classics” of SF in English!! Look forward to checking out H. Harrison, and Barrington J. Bayley, Harness and scads more... Thanks!
In common speech here in the U.S. “That’s classic” nowadays simply means, “I like it.” It quite often has no reference whatsoever to anything in the past, or anything old, accepted, acclaimed, influential, etc.
From the mouth of a Sci Fi fan, “classic” could refer to the first rank of most influential SF books (Orwell, Huxley, Clarke, etc.) , but to me, somehow it slightly more often might refer to the ranks “below” that first rank. “That’s Classic Sci Fi” could mean -- that’s very famous and influential to people who know Sci Fi (though you may not know it).
(Just a reminder, got my own little
forumite reviews that cover
quite a few books of the authors discussed here!
Really disliked
Odd John, both for aesthetic flaws and for a deeply creepy message. Mark wrote a good review on the book he can link you to. It’s probably much fairer and more objective. That book pushed my buttons no end! You can also see what I thought about City (loved it, highly unique), Tau Zero (for me, solid) and The Humanoids (disastrous ending) and some others… Working on
Bable-17 now.