Horror Jag?

Matt H.

Registered User
Joined
Apr 28, 2019
Messages
1,842
7 Pillars of Horror
7 Horror Writers of the Early 20th Century
Story Collections
Chambers, Machen, Blackwood, M.R. James, Benson, Smith, Lovecraft

Let’s take a fresh look at some of these classic tales and authors. I will try to provide a balanced review considering both reader enjoyment and artistic merit. You are heartily invited to join the discussion!

[*** WARNING SPOILERS!! ***]

You may want to read the stories first!

Responses so far:
Is the Ux Extinct?, Chambers
The Man Who Found Out, Blackwood
Ancient Sorceries, Blackwood
The Harbor-Master, Chambers
A Pleasant Evening, Chambers
The Key to Grief, Chambers
To review soon:
Lost Hearts, James
The Ash Tree, James
The Rose Garden, James
Casting the Runes, James
The Man Whom the Trees Loved, Blackwood
Caterpillars, Benson
The Dead Spake, Benson
At the Court of the Dragon, Chambers
Beyond the Walls of Sleep, Lovecraft
The Devotee of Evil, Smith
Writers, Collections and Responses​


  • M.R. James, Collected Ghost Stories
    (Wordsworth Editions Ltd, 2007, M.R. James ed.)
Canon Alberic's Scrap-Book, Lost Hearts, The Mezzotint, The Ash Tree, Number 13, Count Magnus, 'Oh, Whistle, and I'll Come to You, My Lad', The Treasure of Abbot Thomas, A School Story, The Rose Garden, The Tractate Middoth, Casting the Runes, The Stalls of Barchester Cathedral, Martin's Close, Mr Humphreys and His Inheritance, The Residence at Whitminster, The Diary of Mr Poynter, An Episode of Cathedral History, The Story of a Disappearance and an Appearance, Two Doctors, The Haunted Dolls' House, The Uncommon Prayer-Book, A Neighbor's Landmark, A View from a Hill, A Warning to the Curious, An Evening's Entertainment, Wailing Well, There Was a Man Dwelt by a Churchyard, Rats, After Dark in the Playing Fields, Post-response Research
  • Arthur Machen, The White People and Other Weird Stories
    (Penguin Classics, 2011, Joshi ed.)
The Inmost Light, Novel of the Black Seal, Novel of the White Powder, The White People, A Fragment of Life, The Bowman, The Soldier’s Rest, The Great Return, Out of the Earth, The Terror, Post-response Research
  • Robert Chambers, The King in Yellow and Other Horror Stories
    (Dover, 1970, Bleiler ed.)
The Yellow Sign, The Repairer of Reputations, The Demoiselle d’Ys, The Mask, In the Court of the Dragon, The Maker of Moons, A Pleasant Evening, The Messenger, The Key to Grief, The Harbor-Master, In Quest of the Dingue, Is the Ux Extinct?, Post-response Research
  • E.F. Benson, Collected Stories
    (White Press, 2015, Unknown ed.)
How Fear Departed from the Long Gallery, At Abdul Ali’s Grave, Mrs. Amworth, Between the Lights, The House with the Brick-Kiln, The Man Who Went Too Far, The Bus Conductor, Caterpillars, And the Dead Spake, The Dust Cloud, The Cat, The Gardener, The China Bowl, Gavon’s Eve, The Horror Horn, In the Tube, The Confessions of Charles Linkworth, Negotium Perambulans, The Other Bed, Outside the Door, The Room in the Tower, The Shootings of Achnaleish, The Terror by Night, Mr. Tilly's Seance, Post-response Research
  • Algernon Blackwood, Ancient Sorceries and Other Weird Stories
    (Penguin Classics, 2002, Joshi ed.)
Smith: An Episode in a Lodging-House, The Willows, The Insanity of Jones, Ancient Sorceries, The Man Who Found Out, The Wendigo, The Glamour of the Snow, The Man Whom the Trees Loved, Sand, Post-response Research

  • H.P. Lovecraft, The Call of Cthulhu: And Other Stories
    (independent, 2019, Scheiderman/Morgado ed.)
The Alchemist, At the Mountains of Madness, Azathoth, The Beast in the Cave, Beyond the Wall of Sleep, The Call of Cthulhu, The Case of Charles Dexter Ward, Post-response Research
  • Clarke Ashton Smith, The Dark Eidolon and Other Fantasies
    (Penguin Classics, 2004, Joshi ed.)
The Tale of Satampra Zeiros, The Last Incantation, The Devotee of Evil, The Uncharted Isle, The Face By the River, The City of the Singing Flame, The Holiness of Azedarac, The Vaults of Yoh Vombis, Ubbo-Sathla, The Double Shadow, The Maze of the Enchanter, Genius Loci, The Dark Eidolon, The Weaver in the Vault, Xeethra, The Treader of the Dust, Mother of Toads, Phoenix, Post-response Research
 
Last edited:
P.S. I dared to order The Haunting of Hill House (1959), just based on its fearsome rep. It is really that scary? I'm an impressionable lad and something of a scardy-cat. Don't want my little psyche shattered completely

I hope this novel and the stories too are not awfully gory, or realistically intense. I think I will be a fan of scares, but more in the eerie, weird.
 
If you eventually move into other areas of fantasy I will chime in, but the horror wing of the castle is one I have never cared for. If you decide to wander into the social satire wing let me introduce you to the works of Terry Pratchett.
 
If you eventually move into other areas of fantasy I will chime in, but the horror wing of the castle is one I have never cared for. If you decide to wander into the social satire wing let me introduce you to the works of Terry Pratchett.
Thanks, Windy. I will definately let you know when I get there. Prachett is an author I'm greatly looking forward to. I have some other miscelaneous questions I will be posting soon in the Sci Fi novel thread. Already grateful for your expertise if you have anything to say on them.
 
You haven't hit the really gory, blood-soaked section of horror, yet. James, Benson, Chambers, Blackwood, Machen, Lovecraft and Smith were more concerned with atmosphere and mood, implying rather than describing. Not that there aren't some scenes that might be disturbing, depending on how squeamish you are.

You might look into Ray Bradbury and Fritz Leiber, too. There are also representative collections for Richard Matheson and Charles Beaumont from Penguin. Haunted Castles by Ray Russell is another good collection.

Randy M.
 
You haven't hit the really gory, blood-soaked section of horror, yet. James, Benson, Chambers, Blackwood, Machen, Lovecraft and Smith were more concerned with atmosphere and mood...
Thanks for your input, Randy. I kind of figured that would be the case. I have looked at Leiber. I know there is Conjure Wife (a novel). Are there horror story collecrtions of his too? Will check.

Thanks also for tip on Matheson, Beaumont and Russell. Will see what there is for story collections from them before 1950 or so.

(added)

Have a preference among these Leiber collections (each I think named after one of the stories):

Smoke Ghost
The Black Gondoliers
Horrible Imaginings
 
Last edited:
Of those three, I'd go Smoke Ghost. If it's the Midnight House collections, they can be pricey. Night's Black Agents is maybe preferable; the others were pulling together all of Leiber's dark fantasy/horror, where as NBA has more of his best work plus a couple of his Fahfrd & Grey Mouser stories.

My goof with Matheson, Beaumont and Russell. The first two really came of age in the '50s, and Russell a little later.

Oh, and Conjure Wife is good.
 
Of those three, I'd go Smoke Ghost... My goof with Matheson, Beaumont and Russell. The first two really came of age in the '50s, and Russell a little later...
Oh, and Conjure Wife is good.
Nope, glad you mentioned those 3. Had never even heard of them, and after some quick research seems they are all 3 highly acclaimed and influential. Will do a "Part II" for these somewhat later generation writers, because now I want to read them! :)

(added) Btw, will collection NBA, have any stories also in the other 3, or will they be exclusive?
 
Last edited:
When Midnight House put out its editions -- I'm guessing those are the ones, since the titles match their titles -- they were aiming to republish all of Leiber's weird fiction. NBA gathers the cream of the crop up to the time of its publication, along with a couple of Fahfrd & Grey Mouser Sword & Sorcery stories and another story that isn't really horror or S&S. Contents here. Note, later editions include stories not in the original edition, and very good stories at that (notably, "The Girl with the Hungry Eyes").

If you decide you'd rather do an overview of horror than dig into specific authors, I think you could still find cheap editions of David Hartwell's The Dark Descent and The Foundations of Fear. Both include works from before and after your date range, but the relative ease of finding used editions might make up for that failing. :)

One writer you haven't included in your list is Robert Bloch. Leiber and Bloch were connected to Lovecraft, Bloch more closely and for longer than Leiber, and both were instrumental in moving away from the tone and texture of Lovecraftian and Weird Tales-like horror. Ditto Ray Bradbury, who early in his career published in WT and wrote some spooky stories later collected in Dark Carnival many of which were formed a later collection, The October Country (speaking of collections to look into; while TOC wasn't published until the '50s, most of the stories pre-date 1950). I'm honestly not sure how easy it is to get Bloch collections any more. The Early Fears is a chunk of a book containing the contents of his first two published collections and displaying how his writing matured from its early Lovecraft influenced prose to a later, pared down prose more reminiscent of a James M. Cain or, frankly, radio-ready writing. (A stint in the advertising business actually helped his writing.)

Are you aware of Unknown magazine, John W. Campbell Jr.'s 1940s publication that was his fantasy equivalent to Astounding Science Fiction? Many of his s.f. writers crossed over, including Fred Brown (Nightmares & Geezenstacks among other collections include horror stories), Anthony Boucher ("They Bite" is a great short horror story), Theodore Sturgeon ("It", "Bianca's Hands", etc.), and Robert Heinlein ("The Unpleasant Profession of Jonathan Hoag" is another good story to look out for, also "They"). A fair amount of Unknown's stories qualify as horror. That link goes to a site where you can look through the contents and read the stories -- note, Leiber's Conjure Wife was first published in Unknown.

Randy M.
 
When Midnight House put out its editions...
Thanks again Randy. You gave me a whole lot to chew on there! Well, I asked for it. Will check this info ongoing as I gain more knowledge of the subject. Will have to decide if I want to concentrate on single writer collections or multi-writer anthologies... pros and cons to both. Looks like Dark Descent has a massive number of excellent stories, but I guess some will be dups, if I go with single-writer collections too. Before I get too far ahead of myself, let me dip into Chambers and read The King In Yellow... acknowledged by all it seems as a great classic. I certainly prefer good prose and atmosphere to overt gore. :cool:
 
Thank you again Randy, for that helpful info. Let's talk, after I finish them. Read them recently? Want to complete my first read in critical quarantine, as a pure reader response (no external input). Will check your links, SFF reviews, and will consider any/all external scholarship after I finish the tales. I'll see what the hub-bub is all about first hand. Hahaha They're coming today, (supposedly). Frabjous day! (maybe)
 
Last edited:
Update: read the first four tales in Chambers, and then to mixed it up read two Blackwood stories, including The Willows. WOW! what a story! I will never forget it. Kind of like an atomic bomb. I could write a dissertation on it without even trying.
 
Matt, I know you really perfer holding an actual book to an ebook but the kindle apps are very good I perfer the PadiOS kindle app on iPad Pro to my paper white kindle to the point the kindle paper white lives in the small reading room where it is used sitting on the porcelain throne.

You can save a huge amount of money with authors from the pre 1960 period.
this one for example is less than $2... while in hard cover it’s about $25.
 
Update: read the first four tales in Chambers, and then to mixed it up read two Blackwood stories, including The Willows. WOW! what a story! I will never forget it. Kind of like an atomic bomb. I could write a dissertation on it without even trying.

"The Willows" is certainly that kind of story. Blackwood and Arthur Machen were much admired by Lovecraft. While I've barely dented their oeuvres what I've read by them is often powerful, and "The Willows" is arguably the best story by either.

Randy M.
 
While I agree that 'The Willows' was probably the best of the bunch I did enjoy 'Wendigo' by Blackwood.
 
While I agree that 'The Willows' was probably the best of the bunch I did enjoy 'Wendigo' by Blackwood.
Thanks, Oberon.

I'm genuinely sad I read The Willows so early in my horror reading endeavor. Nothing stacks up! Also hard to stop the automatic comparing.

Finished one more Blackwood, Insanity of Jones, and Machen's Inmost Light. Look forward a lot to The Wendigo
 
I see that you have a collection by Arthur Machen. I don't know if it includes the 'The Great God Pan' but that is also a story well worth reading.
 
I see that you have a collection by Arthur Machen. I don't know if it includes the 'The Great God Pan' but that is also a story well worth reading.
Nope, unfortunately it's not in there! :-( I know that's one of his most famous. Too bad.

Finding some enjoyment though in these writers' continual attempt to create a jewel using a small repetitive toolkit of themes and images. Machen's "Novel of the White Powder" was good along those lines, and a few others not bad. I guess it has its fun - "here comes the inevitable X,Y and Z... wonder how this story will flavor them?" :)
 
Last edited:

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top