A Sci Fi Reading Odyssey - 50 Novels

I personally wouldn't recommend ERB. His stuff was highly influential and captured the imagination of many people, but it hasn't aged particularly well. In some ways it's very conventional pulp adventure, with the square hero who falls in love with the beautiful damsel while they have adventures. Of course, the speculative plots were innovative, but reading it nowadays won't have the same impact due to the "Seinfeld is Unfunny" effect.

It's readable enough, and mostly you can read it as a standalone, particularly the first book in each series, but you keep waiting for it to go a bit beyond what you are expecting, and it doesn't.

If you are curious, you can read one or two. As I said, it's readable enough, but I can't imagine people wanting to read the whole series nowadays.
 
Finished my review of Other Side of Here.

Now I can Space-Beagle to my heart's content (an apt Pogo-ism).

Shame I won't achieve a highly compressed reading of it. That's important, and tends to work in a book's favor. Don't you folks agree? But distractions...

Help wanted! I need to beef-up the 1935-1949 section of my list. Suggestions, other than what I already have?
  • Odd John, Olaf Stapledon [1935]
  • The Other Side of Here, Murray Leinster [1936]
  • *Star Maker, Olaf Stapledon [1937]
  • Lest Darkness Fall, Sprauge de Camp [1939]
  • Gray Lensman, Doc Smith [1939]
  • Genus Homo, Sprague de Camp/Miller (1941)
  • Destiny Times Three, Lieber (1943)
  • One Against Eternity, A.E. Van Vogt [1947]
  • The Humanoids, Jack Williamson [1949]
  • Earth Abides, Stewart, [1949]
  • *The Paradox Men, Charles L. Harness [1949]
1984 by Orwell.
Space Cadet if you want to try a Heinlein juvenile from that timeframe.
Needle by Hal Clement.
What Mad Universe, by Fredric Brown, if you want something with a slight humorous tone.
 
I personally wouldn't recommend ERB. His stuff was highly influential and captured the imagination of many people, but it hasn't aged particularly well. In some ways it's very conventional pulp adventure, with the square hero who falls in love with the beautiful damsel while they have adventures..
Farseer, thanks for this comment. I figured that ERB would have those foibles, but trying for a max. spread of styles/sub genres in my list. I ordered Carson of Venus, so if/when I get to it, we can investigate if ERB is just too formulaic to enjoy much. I suspect it probably will be. Would swap out any other author, but big problem seems to be dearth of important Sci Fi novels pub 1935-49 (aside from those already considered)

Btw, ruled out Orwell, but will take a look at Needle and Mad Universe. Thank you for those.
 
With Lest Darkness---, The Humanoids and Space Beagle you've got a some from your "dearth" period.

Needle was perhaps the first adult SF novel (not seialized in Galaxy) that I ever read. I like Fred Brown, but do not remember What Mad- - -. Donovan's Brain is pretty dry but would qualify. Also Darker Than You Think (verges on Fantasy),
Also Earth Abides, & It Can't Happen Here (Thought of as literary, not genre),
To be honest, even though I started the Classic authors thread, I like very many on your list (see post#1) as yet unread better than the above suggestions. I do not have your fortitude to plow through less enjoyable works in the (your) effort to cover the eras. I admire your dedication.
Darker Than---, Needle & It can't Happen--- would be my favorites of the above.
I know that a couple of the above were already mentioned
 
Last edited:
With Lest Darkness---, The Humanoids and Space Beagle you've got a some from your "dearth" period.

Needle was perhaps the first adult SF novel (not seialized in Galaxy) that I ever read. I like Fred Brown, but do not remember What Mad- - -. Donovan's Brain is pretty dry but would qualify. Also Darker Than You Think (verges on Fantasy),
Also Earth Abides, & It Can't Happen Here (Thought of as literary, not genre),
To be honest, even though I started the Classic authors thread, I like very many on your list (see post#1) as yet unread better than the above suggestions. I do not have your fortitude to plow through less enjoyable works in the (your) effort to cover the eras. I admire your dedication.
Darker Than---, Needle & It can't Happen--- would be my favorites of the above.
I know that you already mentioned a couple of the above.
Great info, Pogo, thanks! Already had Earth Abides since it's well known and influential (?). In fact I started reading it. :) Yes, it's true I have some in there 35-49, but still a few fewer than the other decades, etc. Things like Genus Homo, and Destiny Times Three, are just "penciled in" at this point. Note there are also 5-6 blank spaces which could take anything from 1935-85. I'd like to avoid too many yearly repeats. 3 max is optimum. (example already have 3 from 1949 - corrected)
 
Some resources that may be useful for that period:


Classics of Science Fiction: Books by rank:
This one compiles results from many best of lists and orders books from all eras depending on how many lists they appear in (percentage of appearances divided by number of list that were done after publication of each book)


ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1900s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1910s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1920s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1930s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1940s:
 
To be honest, sean, that's a bit like comparing apples and pears.

However King is more contemporary and writes to more modern tastes, so IMO his writing will be understood and liked by more modern readers.
 
King - A better writer.
Heinlein (specifically early Heinlein) more influential and, in his time, more original.
As a kid, we always used to dis King because he was "popular"...to a young, uncritical mind this being synomous with "bad." But never had occasion to read any of his work. (Lingering prejudice?) Now a slightly wiser me, would be open to it... But anything King under 1,700 pages? lol... Eventually I will get there and if universe is still here will ask all of your advice on a starter King novel. :)
 
Some resources that may be useful for that period:


Classics of Science Fiction: Books by rank:
This one compiles results from many best of lists and orders books from all eras depending on how many lists they appear in (percentage of appearances divided by number of list that were done after publication of each book)


ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1900s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1910s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1920s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1930s:
ISFDB most reviewed titles from the 1940s:
Thanks, Farseer. ISFDB is an awesome resource and I love the fact they let you download the whole database! Will do that soon, since I'm a "database guy" and will enjoy playing with it. Will take requests for any project ideas. :-) Might use it as a framework for my own theme/keyword/writer's resource app for my list of fifty.
 
King - A better writer.
Heinlein (specifically early Heinlein) more influential and, in his time, more original.

I'd modify this. Heinlein was more influential, arguably, but to a much smaller audience. King's influence may not be as powerful because it's more diffuse. For instance, earlier this year I read The Good House by Tananarive Due, and I'd say her approach and, to a degree, her subject matter was influenced by King, something I'm not sure I'd have guessed from reading about her.

Randy M.
 
I read Carrie when it came out and thoroughly enjoyed it. It was horror and I am not a devotee of horror. The Dark Tower didn't make it past 50 pages. There was a Dark Tower board game popular at the time and I knew that one had nothing to do with the other but the book just didn't feel right. Now that's curious because Resnick's Santiago came out 4 years later and then Serenity came out and the opening settings had a similar feel. The difference, I think, is that I expected King's to be horror and I knew Resnick wasn't likely to be doing horror. As gruesome as the Serenity movie could be; it wasn't a horror flick.
Anyway, I've seen a couple of the King derivative movies and the only one that grabbed me was Cujo.
Have I mentioned that I'm not a horror fan? But, I have never been able to get sensation of reading Harris' The Exorcist out of my head.
That given, you can imagine any comparison I might make would be hard put to credit King with influence. OTOH, his book on writing was good stuff.
 
Read the book by King (The first one, Danse Macbre - 30 years ago?) Liked it.
I'll stand with my original comment. Even though Heinlein was read by many fewer people, he affected an entire genre and was definately an original.
Early King (I sort of phased out after the first dozen or so) was certainly riveting. He grabbed you by the short hairs and was certainly - ah - gripping. Also used humor, but most of all was the master at developing a sympathetic character and then throwing him into peril/horror. But I don't think that he shaped anything.
Not having read Due, I'll certainly credit Randy's comment. Still, influence on writers or the public? Not counting inability to sleep, not so much.
Disclaimer: I don't read horror except when it overlaps.
My difference is more a level of degree. Don't really disagree with HE or Randy.

Back to Matt's project?
 
Last edited:
But anything King under 1,700 pages? lol...
Yeah he does write tomes, but he's also a great short story writer, and regularly puts out collections with four novella-size stories. If the tomes put you off I'd recommend something like Different Seasons - Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption, and The Body are two of his better (shorter) stories - and they aren't horror either.

But I agree with Mark on who's "better" - apples and oranges; it's difficult to compare. There's no doubting they both had/have huge influences in their respective genres.
 
I'm not very impressed with King's writing to be honest. I've read a few, but IT was the most pointless waste of time and was the last one I ever read. For me, King's best book was The Running Man.

Heinlein wasn't a complicated writer by any means, but the bulk of his work is eminently readable and very entertaining. I may be biased though as my first true science fiction reads were Space Cadet and Starman Jones..
 
I'm not very impressed with King's writing to be honest...
Interesting Vince. Curious, and I could make all kinds of assumptions... I'll just ask what you mean. Referring to his prose itself, his plots? What aspect?

(added)
Sorry for taking us off topic. (in my own thread no less!) I hope we can return to Sci Fi novels (35-85) after this little King forray.
 
Interesting Vince. Curious, and I could make all kinds of assumptions... I'll just ask what you mean. Referring to his prose itself, his plots? What aspect?

(added)
Sorry for taking us off topic. (in my own thread no less!) I hope we can return to Sci Fi novels (35-85) after this little King forray.
Of the little King I've read I found his plotting rather dull overall and the prose was steady but not gripping to me. The novel IT was just a plodding mess with an ending that put me off his writing for good. I've not read a word of his since.
 
I never warmed to King, Carrie was ok but I never liked Horror and so I too did not finish the Dark Tower and it is very rare for me to quit a book. I hated the dark tower film. I would say Heinlein was the better writer but that is personal taste in reading again.
 
Ok, I think King closed. It's an interesting topic, so anyone feel free to move it to another thread and I will hop in. Partly my fault since I went with the digression :)

Parting shot, lol... surprised Mark un-hesitatingly said King was a better writer than RAH! Would have to read King to judge, but Heinlein is impressively skillful, well-crafted and fun to read, and always gives you something to chew on, and he goes outside conventions, even in a book like Puppet Masters.

On that note, let get back to good old Sci Fi novels. Oooo, got my Space Beagle review ready! Will post momentarily.

Jeepers, Earth Abides is... well, first 85 pages are, well... (see my review!)
 

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top