In 1935 Fantasy tended to be lumped in with Science Fiction I think and really only started to get its own shelf space after WW2... well that is the way things from the interwar period feel to me. As you will see The Circus of Dr. Lao is almost its own category for a mid-1930s novel and to an extent interesting for that just by itself. I look forward to seeing what the other regulars here make of it.Funny story. I spent a good part of my early years in Finney Chapel, the convocation center and campus church at Oberlin College. Looking up Charles G. Finney, I had to fight my way through the author's great grandfather and namesake, who was considered "The Father of Modern Revivalism" a great preacher, was an early abolitionist, the second president of Oberlin and a prolific author.
I've heard of The Circus of Dr. Lao. If I had put the names together I certainly would have read it. Thanks JM, Windy & Mark. Ordered it from the (ahem) library.
I noted from the library catalog that it is listed in Michael Moorcock and James Cawthorn's
Fantasy, the 100 best books, so perhaps Windshadow's comment that it really is fantasy might take it off Matt's potentials list.
They also have access via interlibrary loan to the DVD of the George Pal movie, so I put in for that also. Thanks, y'all.
Randy, The Space Merchants is coming up quick on my reading list. Btw, did you like it? Also, know anything about the Pohl/Kornbluth partnership? Who did what? Always fascinated me..I think a lot of readers would label The Circus of Dr. Lao as satire. In academic circles, I think satire is allowed fanciful and fantastic places. characters and events without being weighed down by being called fantasy. (Years ago I believe I saw that reasoning applied to The Space Merchants and wanted to pound my head against a wall.)
Absolutely loved Gateway too! Wrote this review, which is also one of my favorite reviews of the 21 I did so far. Thanks for the input Randy. My review of SM should be posted sometime soon.It's been about 40 years since I read it, Matt. Liked it at the time, but absolutely loved Gateway by Pohl alone, so TSM came up a bit short there. I do remember feeling like it was a bit long for what it was doing. Not sure how I'd feel now.
Randy M.
Randy, The Space Merchants is coming up quick on my reading list. Btw, did you like it? Also, know anything about the Pohl/Kornbluth partnership? Who did what? Always fascinated me..
Randy, The Space Merchants is coming up quick on my reading list. Btw, did you like it? Also, know anything about the Pohl/Kornbluth partnership? Who did what? Always fascinated me..
Whilst serving in the US Army Air Force during the Second World War, Pohl had been posted to Stornara, in south-eastern Italy, as a weather forecaster. Shortly after learning of his mother's death in 1944, and feeling somewhat homesick, he decided to start writing a novel about New York. He chose to write about the advertising industry, thinking it to be the most interesting topic in the city, and patiently wrote "a long, complicated, and very bad novel" with the title of For Some We Loved.[3]
After the war ended, in early 1946, he re-read the manuscript, and decided that its major flaw was that he had written it despite knowing nothing about advertising. Before rewriting it, he applied for advertising jobs to gain some background, and on 1 April 1946 joined a small Madison Avenue agency as their chief copywriter. He later moved to Popular Science, finding that he enjoyed the work so much he lost track of why he originally took the job.[4]
Some years later, Pohl returned to For Some We Loved. In early 1950, he read through the original manuscript, but found the writing to be completely unsalvageable; he burned it, and decided to forget the idea. The following year, he began drafting a science fiction novel, loosely themed on advertising, under the name of Fall Campaign, and had reached twenty thousand words by the summer, working at weekends and in the evenings. At this point, Pohl's old friend Cyril Kornbluth arrived, having quit his job in Chicago to freelance as a science fiction writer, and offered to look over the manuscript. A short while later he returned, having incorporated some plot suggestions made by Philip Klass and written a new twenty-thousand word middle section; the two men collaborated on the final third, and after Pohl gave it a final revision, the novel was complete.[5]
Read Circus of Dr. Lao.
It is certainly a creature that probably challenged its times. Doing the math, it is 85 years old.
Not so much social satire (although it's in there) as an exercise of the imagination that places the genuinely strange into a context of exceedingly normal Arizona. My impressiom is that Finney simply wanted to let it all hang out., describing as unusual an event as he could conjure. The sexual descriptions and even the racist stereotypes counterposed with (often the same) characters that challenge white superiority are so far outside my vision of 1935 as to make me scratch my head in admiration of Finney. His depiction of almost all of the whites reminds me of Sinclair Lewis. They are deliberately flat.
No plot other than that a weirdy happened. His embedded explanations are as fantastic as his characters. Finney's afterward is deliberately as outre (and non-explanatory) as the book proper.
Finney was a newspaperman. Wanting to go outside the normalities that he had to cover was probably enjoyable for him.
Got a little bored by the end. The outre isn't as striking now as is was 85 years back.
But it is a shortie and it rushed me through the text.
Thanks for the suggestion Windy, Randy, Hobbit and JunkMonkey.
Watched the movie. Using Windshadow's trivia sheet & watching for artifacts almost made it bearable. Almost, but not quite. The book was a genuine weirdy. The movie was genuine pap. It made no real use of the memorable scenes from the book and instead grafted on a boring romance plus nasty capitalist plot. When I realized who had the female lead I kept hoping that Barbara Eden would wrinkle her nose and say, "I' ll dispose of him master."Apollonius of Tyana: Tomorrow will be like today, and the day after tomorrow will be like the day before yesterday. I see your remaining days as a tedious collection of hours full of useless vanities. You will think no new thoughts. You will forget what little you have known. Older you will become, but not wiser. Stiffer, but not more dignified. Childless you are, and childless you will remain. Of that suppleness you once commanded in your youth, of that strange simplicity which once attracted men to you, neither endures, nor shall you recapture them.
Mrs. Cassin: You're a mean, ugly man!
Apollonius of Tyana: Mirrors are often ugly and mean. When you die, you will be buried and forgotten, and that is all. And for all the good or evil, creation or destruction, your living might have accomplished, you might just as well never have lived at all. - - I'm sorry, but, you see, it is my curse to tell the absolute truth.