- Joined
- Dec 7, 2009
- Messages
- 4,572
The Adventures of Amina al-Sirafi – by S.A. (Shannon) Chakraborty
I read this book in January, so it’s still pretty fresh for me. I like this book quite a bit and am tempted to include it in a list of favorites but, since I read it so recently, I’m holding off from doing that.
A pirate queen is pulled out of retirement to rescue the daughter of an old crew member who’s been kidnapped by an French warlord. This is a high fantasy, swashbuckling adventure set on and in the lands around the Arabian Sea during the era of the Crusades. There’s the quest for the missing girl, great sword fights, magic, monstrous creatures of land and sea, all while sailing the seven seas. Oh, and alchemical explosions and truly laugh out loud nonsense. There are themes of road trip, getting the gang back together and explorations of loyalty, honor, true friendship and individuality.
I read this as an audiobook, with Lameece Issaq narrating. I highly, highly, recommend the audiobook. Issaq did such a wonderful job with her performance that I honestly can’t imagine trying to read a text copy of the book. Truly, one of the strengths of the book for me as she took well developed characters, a tight plot with consistent pacing and a vibrant world and brought it to life. Listening to the audiobook, I didn’t feel so much that I was watching a movie as much as watching the characters through a window, feeling the wind and salt spray on my face, and growing warm under the desert sun in my cold, drizzly January apartment far from any desert.
In my last post, I listed the comedic fantasy trilogy The Tales of Pell as one of my favorites. Comedy is hard to do in writing, but Chakraborty found the key for me with this book. Outside of Discworld and The Tales of Pell, I don’t know when I last laughed so much while reading a book. That’s not to say this is a comedic story, because it isn’t. Chakraborty simply told a very well-rounded high fantasy adventure full of drama and deep tragedies, new and old, that were spaced out and enlivened by moments of perfect, character and situational-based comedy that was ridiculously perfect.
I'm still so in love with this book that I struggle to see many, if any, faults; though, I know nothing is perfect and, should someone point them out to me, I'd definitely consider them and would likely agree with at least some. The one criticism I do have is that the pacing fell off a bit during passages of al-Sirafi's introspection. These were, of course, necessary passages for development of both the character and the plot. They served these purposes perfectly, but the an otherwise fast paced story did slow down quite a bit for these moments. I never wondered when they might end, never jumped forward in my audiobook to skip through/over them. Like I said, they were one of the tools used for plot and character development, and used appropriately in my estimation. I just wish they had been a bit faster paced to better match the pacing of the rest of the book.
----------------
This is only the second book I’ve tried from Chakraborty. I previously read her City of Brass and, honestly, I didn’t much care for it. I can see that it’s a good book, a well told story focusing on politics in a fantasy kingdom. However, where the audiobook is a must for me with al-Sirafi, I’d advise against it for City of Brass. The problem for me was that several of the names used in City of Brass were very similar sounding to my American, white-boy ear. I don’t have the greatest ear for languages and I’m not very familiar with Arabic or Muslim names or words. So political groups whose names sounded similar to me, but whose opposition to each other was at the core of the novel’s political plot… And combine that with my expectation of an exploration of late eighteenth-century Cairo, Egypt, based on my reading of the novel’s summary (I love Ancient Egypt, and the Napoleonic world outside of France and Britain is a mystery to me, so I just had to read the book), well, it didn’t work for me. Today, I am fairly confident that I would have liked the book if I had read a text copy rather than listened to the audiobook. Maybe I’ll try it again someday, with that text copy, but not today.
That said, all my personal difficulties with City of Brass were entirely absent for me from al-Sirafi. The books are completely different, with entirely different tones, themes and characters. There are those authors who write multiple books and/or series, with different characters and different plots, but who often turn out to be writing the same thing, only changing the names and details a bit. Chakraborty is not one of these. YMMV, but I’m rather (happily!) surprised they were written by the same author.
I read this book in January, so it’s still pretty fresh for me. I like this book quite a bit and am tempted to include it in a list of favorites but, since I read it so recently, I’m holding off from doing that.
A pirate queen is pulled out of retirement to rescue the daughter of an old crew member who’s been kidnapped by an French warlord. This is a high fantasy, swashbuckling adventure set on and in the lands around the Arabian Sea during the era of the Crusades. There’s the quest for the missing girl, great sword fights, magic, monstrous creatures of land and sea, all while sailing the seven seas. Oh, and alchemical explosions and truly laugh out loud nonsense. There are themes of road trip, getting the gang back together and explorations of loyalty, honor, true friendship and individuality.
I read this as an audiobook, with Lameece Issaq narrating. I highly, highly, recommend the audiobook. Issaq did such a wonderful job with her performance that I honestly can’t imagine trying to read a text copy of the book. Truly, one of the strengths of the book for me as she took well developed characters, a tight plot with consistent pacing and a vibrant world and brought it to life. Listening to the audiobook, I didn’t feel so much that I was watching a movie as much as watching the characters through a window, feeling the wind and salt spray on my face, and growing warm under the desert sun in my cold, drizzly January apartment far from any desert.
In my last post, I listed the comedic fantasy trilogy The Tales of Pell as one of my favorites. Comedy is hard to do in writing, but Chakraborty found the key for me with this book. Outside of Discworld and The Tales of Pell, I don’t know when I last laughed so much while reading a book. That’s not to say this is a comedic story, because it isn’t. Chakraborty simply told a very well-rounded high fantasy adventure full of drama and deep tragedies, new and old, that were spaced out and enlivened by moments of perfect, character and situational-based comedy that was ridiculously perfect.
I'm still so in love with this book that I struggle to see many, if any, faults; though, I know nothing is perfect and, should someone point them out to me, I'd definitely consider them and would likely agree with at least some. The one criticism I do have is that the pacing fell off a bit during passages of al-Sirafi's introspection. These were, of course, necessary passages for development of both the character and the plot. They served these purposes perfectly, but the an otherwise fast paced story did slow down quite a bit for these moments. I never wondered when they might end, never jumped forward in my audiobook to skip through/over them. Like I said, they were one of the tools used for plot and character development, and used appropriately in my estimation. I just wish they had been a bit faster paced to better match the pacing of the rest of the book.
----------------
This is only the second book I’ve tried from Chakraborty. I previously read her City of Brass and, honestly, I didn’t much care for it. I can see that it’s a good book, a well told story focusing on politics in a fantasy kingdom. However, where the audiobook is a must for me with al-Sirafi, I’d advise against it for City of Brass. The problem for me was that several of the names used in City of Brass were very similar sounding to my American, white-boy ear. I don’t have the greatest ear for languages and I’m not very familiar with Arabic or Muslim names or words. So political groups whose names sounded similar to me, but whose opposition to each other was at the core of the novel’s political plot… And combine that with my expectation of an exploration of late eighteenth-century Cairo, Egypt, based on my reading of the novel’s summary (I love Ancient Egypt, and the Napoleonic world outside of France and Britain is a mystery to me, so I just had to read the book), well, it didn’t work for me. Today, I am fairly confident that I would have liked the book if I had read a text copy rather than listened to the audiobook. Maybe I’ll try it again someday, with that text copy, but not today.
That said, all my personal difficulties with City of Brass were entirely absent for me from al-Sirafi. The books are completely different, with entirely different tones, themes and characters. There are those authors who write multiple books and/or series, with different characters and different plots, but who often turn out to be writing the same thing, only changing the names and details a bit. Chakraborty is not one of these. YMMV, but I’m rather (happily!) surprised they were written by the same author.


