Originally posted by Llama
>>Llama: Well, the belief in the coming of the New Sun is just a belief, I don't think it impacts the argument much one way or another. The undines are a bit harder to fit, I agree, but it's not impossible, and I'm curious whether more explanation is given in URTH OF THE NEW SUN, which I am now reading, or in the LONG SUN or SHORT SUN books.
If you haven't finished reading The Urth of the New Sun, I won't give anything away, except to say that that book illumines much about what belief in the New Sun means, and how that belief matches, or doesn't match, reality. And if it counts for anything, I think that Urth was published as a sequel after Pringle published his book. (I'll do a quick Internet check to make sure.)
The rest of your points about tBotNS are well taken. Long Sun and Short Sun likewise are difficult to classify, but have much less of a feel of retro-medieval fantasy. Amazing books all of them, however.


