Opinions on S.L. Farrell?

Random987

Registered User
Joined
May 22, 2006
Messages
26
I just read GRRM's Blog where he explains the delay in his new book and recommends some new writers. I am familiar with a lot of them, but not S.L. Farrell. I checked on Amazon and he has a series called The Cloudmages starting with The Holder of Lightning.

I did my due diligence by running a search first, but couldn't seem to find many reviews or opinions on Mr. Farrell? Is he worth a pick up? My tastes include Martin, Kay, etc. Recently, i've enjoyed Rothfuss, David Anthony Durham, Lynch, etc.

So, what about Mr. Farrell?
 
S.L. Farrell is in fact Stephen Leigh who wrote some good SF in the 80's and 90's. When switching over to fantasy he used a new name (S.L. Farrell).

Holder of Lighting is the first book in the Cloudmages trilogy. It got some mixed reviews so difficult to say whether it's really to your taste. It is however a "Celtic fantasy" series so if you like this particular subgenre it's worth a try.

Personally I feel more intrigued about his new series, the Nessantico cycle which is based on renaissance Italy. The first book Magic of Twilight is just out in hardback.
Since I always like fantasy books based on medieval Italian city states (intrigues, betrayal, plotting, murders, mercenaries etc...) it's likely I give this new book a chance when it comes out in paperback.
 
I have Magic of Twilight and so far like it--though I'm only like 10 or 15 pages in. It's not really like GRRM so much, but still enjoyable. Why not give it a try?
 
Since I lost that football bet with GRRM, Farrell's A Magic of Twilight is one of the books I must read and review. I'm enjoying it so far, though it must be said that I'm only just beginning to read it. :)

Patrick
 
S.L. Farrell

Hey kids -- I'm wondering if anyone has opinions on this author. I've been debating A Magic of Twilight, but a) it's in hardcover, and I'm a cheapskate who is reluctant to pay $20+ on an untried author; b) it's currently rating three stars on Amazon, which is a major red flag since, uh, three stars is getting into Robert Newcomb territory.

Is anyone familiar with S.L Farrell's work? Should I try his earlier series instead? What are the good points and bad?
 
Reviewed it HERE, Liane. Liked it.

And a new author to me too, but would read again.

Mark / Hobbit
 
Pat of the Fantasy Hot list liked it so did kcf/Ken of Nethspace. And it has GRRM's stamp of approval, too.
 
I finished the first book of the Nessantico cycle - A Magic of Twilight

The book takes a while to get into, but there is a detailed glossary that helps ease the transition into the familiar and yet strange world of Nessantico, and then it follows a fairly conventional fantasy plot, but I liked the setting, the characters and the writing so I enjoyed it quite a lot.

The pages turn by themselves and the book flows very smoothly, so it's a relative fast read despite its length.

The ending wraps the main threads and makes the book self-contained. The story picks up some years later in Magic of Nightfall which became an asap read for me
 
Hobbit reviewed it and liked it last year. I received a copy of the paperback from the publisher and plan on reading it, but the when of when I read it is in question.
 
I thought it worth posting this quote from suciul in the Reading in February 2009 (Fantasy) thread since it gives a pretty good summary of the books:

No cliffhangers; book 1 is a standalone, book 2 is a standalone taking place ** years after - I would not read any blurb in book 2 to keep book 1 spoiler free.

Book 3 takes place ^^ years later from book 2, and while I can see a general outline of where it goes from the so called "Encyclopedia of Nessantico" or something like that, dated 100+ years later and excerpted in book 2, I think it will also be a standalone.

In a way the Nessantico cycle resembles historical fiction a lot, with the city/country as the main character, while humans come and go though there are overlapping characters in book 1 and 2 and I am pretty sure they will be from book 2 to book 3

Edit later: actually Mr. Leigh explains it very well on his website:

"Imagine Renaissance Florence blended with late Imperial Rome and spiced with some of the trappings of ‘fin de siécle’ Vienna: a great city of a far-reaching empire; a city situated at the center of civilization; a city where art and music and writing flourish, where the world’s greatest minds and greatest talents come to make their reputations, while the trade of a hundred lesser nations passes through the ports and the streets.

That is Nessantico.

Consider a world where magic has for centuries been linked to a central, dominating religion and secret rituals, a world where magic is an integral part of the ‘technology’ of the world, but where now some people claim to be able to create magic without the rituals, without the religion -- people those in charge consider dangerous enemies. Magic here is created through a devout faith, and can only be performed by a special few whose minds are open to it. Here, magic lights the streets and powers the engines of economy; here, magic is the great weapon of war and forms the foundation of Nessantico’s greatness as well as the chains that bind its servant nations to it.

.........

As with the Cloudmages books, my intention is to make the books as "stand-alone" as possible. Each book will have a distinct beginning and ending, and the main characters will be different in each book. It is the city of Nessantico whose "character arc" will begin in the first book and end in the last, not the people themselves."

FWIW, A Magic of Nightfall arrived from DAW yesterday and a dead mouse was underneath the package. Not really, but the book is huge and based on discussions here (and elsewhere), I'm really looking forward to jumping into the two books and moving them higher up on my To Read pile.

Also, I merged this thread with the previous Farrell thread
 
FWIW, A Magic of Nightfall arrived from DAW yesterday and a dead mouse was underneath the package. Not really, but the book is huge and based on discussions here (and elsewhere), I'm really looking forward to jumping into the two books and moving them higher up on my To Read pile.

Book 2 - Magic of Nightfall is a very fast read despite its size, assuming of course you read book 1; the pages turn by themselves and the book starts with a bang (literally) and does not slow down

Book 1 - Magic of Twilight is slower since in the first 100-200 pages you get the feel of the setting, the language, what's what - the glossary helps a lot and I found myself consulting it extensively in book 1 - but then it picks up and the last half is also non-stop intrigue and action
 
As Rob said above, I enjoyed A Magic of Twilight. I really wish I had better contacts at Daw for getting ARCs as I'd like to read/review A Magic of Nightfall.

I haven't read any of his other stuff.
 
Can any of you who perform reviews from insane TBR stacks recommend his earlier Cloudmages trilogy?
 
Can any of you who perform reviews from insane TBR stacks recommend his earlier Cloudmages trilogy?

Not directly. However, since I enjoyed Magic of Twilight so much, I did track down copies of that trilogy. Someday I'll get around to it, but it'll be a while. I've seen mixed reactions on it, but what I've seen makes me think I'll like it. Slight tangent - those books have some of the worst fantasy cover art ever.
 
Slight tangent - those books have some of the worst fantasy cover art ever.
Agree on the covers, and they are far inferior to most (if not all) other books published by DAW, who usually produces fare superior covers (Tad Williams, C.J. Cherryh, C.S. Friedman). Also, the titles are a little off-putting, too. Especially Book 2: The Cloudmages Trilogy: Mage of Clouds
 

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top