Reading in December 2007

I'm reading Moving Mars by Greg Bear. There are hardly any chapters and it moves at a fantastic pace. I think I have enough time this weekend just to sit down and read it all this weekend and just relax. :)
 
I'm a dozen pages into John Scalzi's 'The Ghost Brigades'. So far so good.

'Old man's war' I enjoyed a good deal, although I think Scalzi was a victim of his own word-of-mouth to a certain extent when people mentioned him and Robert Heinlein's 'Starship Troopers' in the same breath (likewise with Robert Buettner). Those are big shoes to fill, and don't think the comparison with Heinlein was either accurate or fair, given that Scalzi doesn't really write pure Military SF in the vein of Ringo, Drake or Weber. Though the principle protagonists may be military, events have much more of a space opera-ish feel to them.

I've had this one on my shelf for quite a while, and I was paralysed between starting it or Leo Frankowski and Dave Grossman's 'The War With Earth'. There's also a big trade paperback compiling Timothy Zahn's 'Cobra Trilogy'.
 
Peter Reeve's Mortal Engines. Although it is YA postapocalyptic SF - it is so drenched in blood, and so many deaths we are witnessing during this lecture that its YA character is questionable for me.
It's very good written and interesting story. So interesting, that I am looking for next parts of it.
 
Currently alternating between Arthur C Clarke's / Stephen Baxter's Firstborn and Iain M Banks' Matter. Both good in their own way.

Mark / Hobbit
 
Just started reading Sarah Canary by Karen Joy Fowler. This is one of those mainstream/SF crossovers. I think it was nominated for a Nebula in the early 90s. Anyway, it has been recommended to me a few times, so thought I'd finally give it a shot. Like the setting: ~1870s Pacific NW frontier country, with an interesting mixture of cultures at odds with one another.
 
Currently reading Behemoth by Peter Watts and Brasyl by Ian McDonald.
Enjoying the former, but I reading it in short bursts only.
I am not really into the latter, but it shows potential and I might like it better when i get further into it.
 
Just finished Chris Roberson's Paragaea: A Planetary Romance.

The novel was advertized as a great old pulp adventure story, grounded in the latest thinking in the fields of theoretical physics, artificial intelligence, genetics, and more. Paragaea is indeed a throwback to those science fiction pulp stories of yore made popular by authors like Edgar Rice Burroughs, Alex Raymond, Leigh Brackett, etc. Roberson demonstrates that he has a fertile imagination by cramming this work with cool and fascinating themes and ideas.

Unfortunately, I felt that Chris Roberson was never quite able to make this book rise above the traditional scifi pulp subgenre. All the tropes are present, from original monsters and creatures and swashbuckling to narrow escapes from certain doom. With lots of action, Paragaea is an entertaining read. And yet, the storytelling, relying too heavily on action in typical pulp manner, precludes this one from reaching a higher level.

If you are craving a novel which is a throwback to those old scifi pulp adventure stories, Paragaea: A Planetary Romance is exactly what the doctor ordered. But if you are looking for a work that rises beyond that, then you are bound, as I was, to be disappointed.

Check the blog for the full review. :)

Patrick
 
Currently ... Iain M Banks' Matter.
Mark / Hobbit

Droooool.

I'm starting Brasyl by Ian McDonald. I loved River of Gods and this seems to be a good year for post-cyberpunk SF.
 
Managed to get an arc of Matter by I. Banks (not for free :)) and it's brilliant at least the first 100 pages that I've had time to read.

The Culture did not make an appearance yet outside of the prologue and mentions here and there, but lots of new cool aliens, Shellworlds (arithmetic and exponential no less, god inhabited or not - loved that stuff) plus a pretty long glossary and list of characters are some of the highlights.

Now this is an arc so there is different pagination and so on from the final book which I will get too of course, but it seems this may be THE sf book of 2008.
 
Finally finished Rainbows End by Vinge. It was a slow go. I can't say I enjoyed it very much. A huge departure from A Fire Upon the Deep and A Deepness in the Sky in style, content and enjoyablity. Can we compare it to The Diamond Age by Stephenson? If so I do not campare it favorably.
This book won the Hugo. Did anyone read the other nominees?
 
Halfway through Leo Frankowski's 'The War With Earth'. Dave Grossman is a co-author, but thusfar I can't find any of his influence, to be honest. There's none of the insights about combat and its effects that Grossman brought to his own 'The Two Space War'. However, thusfar all Frankowski seems to be doing is building up to a war in the second half of the novel, and in the meantime playing out a few fantasies of his involving making sixteen billion dollars a year and having armies of sexy female AIs at the protagonists beck and call.

I'll give it the benefit of the doubt thusfar, but it lacks the grit of the original 'A boy and his tank'. One thing I note is that Frankowski gives his characters a very old-fashioned turn of phrase, like he's trying to make them sound like they're from the golden age of SF.
 
Finished Matter by IM Banks. It's a very powerful Culture book, dark, violent though less so than Consider Phlebas and Use of Weapons, funny and thought provoking.

The title has a double meaning, but to me the best reference comes from a character commenting that "we are information gentlemen; all living things are. However we are lucky enough to be encoded in matter itself, not running in some abstracted system as patterns of particles or standing waves of probability .... only base reality cannot be fully replayed; anything transmitted can be recorded and usually is"

The book itself reminded me both of "Inversions" and "Consider Phlebas", and is full of wonder (an Arithmetic, Mottled, Disputed, Multiply Inhabited, Multi-million year Safe, Godded, essentially 4 dimensional Shellworld called Sursamen is the main locus of action).

The only slight negative of the book for me is that none of the 4 main characters from which POV the book is mostly written (the 2 princes of the dominant kingdom of the 8th level of Sursamen and their sister, former princess and current SC agent, as well as a "man of the people" and manservant to one of the brothers) takes over the book in the way Bora Horza Gobuchul, Cheradenine Zakalwe or Jernau Gurgeh (to a lesser extent) take over the first three Culture books.

The one character who really is extremely interesting in a Banksian way, the former mentor of the princes' father (a minor king who rose to dominate the 8th level by application of force in a "modern way" - taught by this Culture agent who later asked for one of his children to serve the Culture as repayment) and whom I quoted above appears only in a chapter but he truly steals the show and it's a pity he did not get to have a more central role.

Highly, highly recommended, could be the SF book of 2008
 
Last edited:
I'm about halfway to two-thirds through Matter, suciul: I'm finding I have to take it at a steadier pace.

I am enjoying David Weber's Off Armageddon Reef, which I think was one of your favourites this year. I'm reading it for its Jan 2008 release here in the UK, but am enjoying it a great deal.

Mark / Hobbit
 
I'm about halfway to two-thirds through Matter, suciul: I'm finding I have to take it at a steadier pace.

I am enjoying David Weber's Off Armageddon Reef, which I think was one of your favourites this year. I'm reading it for its Jan 2008 release here in the UK, but am enjoying it a great deal.

Mark / Hobbit

Regarding Matter, indeed it's a pretty dense book with lots of subtext superposed on a relatively routine plot. It took me several bouts of concentrated reading to read it, and at the end I really wanted to find out what happens, so now I've started rereading it to get the nuances I missed.

It's IM Banks best book by far in a long time (since Against A Dark Background at least), and only time will decide how I will rank it relatively to his 3 Culture masterpieces (CP, UofW, TPG); as mentioned the one slight negative is that it lacks a character that takes the book over, but that's considering Mr. Banks' standards of course.

This why for me his 4th best book and close to those 3 is ADB even if it's not Culture, but the characters there are really memorable, and Lady Sharrow the main lead is almost as powerful as Horza or Zakalwe, and definitely more powerful than Gurgeh. Here the only really powerful character is Hyrlis and the scenes with him, though in only one chapter are in many ways the philosophical heart of the book.

In the Algebraist, Mr. Banks had 3 potentially interesting characters (the 3 friends that go those quite separate paths), but somehow neither is developed in a really interesting way.

Regarding OAR by D. Weber, that's a fun book, though with poignant moments if you like the genre. I am eagerly awaiting the July release of volume 2 (By Schism Rent Asunder) of which snippets are posted 3 times a week at Baen's bar in the Honorverse and Mutter of Demons forums, currently at #35. Volume 3 has also been delivered (By Heresies Distressed) so mostl likely we will wait far less for it.
 
Thanks, suciul; I am getting the impression from Matter that important things happen away from the key characters, and that that is deliberate. Though they are clearly affected by it, the key events are not of their doing (though that may change before the end of the book!)

It's also a revenge novel, and clearly works at different levels. The interactions between aliens and the shellworld residents are good.

The Weber is a different thing, though enjoyable nevertheless. Appreciate the update.

Mark / Hobbit
 
And Dats' De End

Eye of Terror -Barrington J Bayley
This concludes my reading of Barrington J Bayley's novels -I've read them all. This is his franchise novel for the Warhammer 40,000 game universe. The human race lives under control of the Imperium -a religio-militaristic Inquisition type empire that spans multiple systems. With a fighting force of specially bred Space Marines, they protect the human race against the demonic forces of Chaos. In the Eye of Terror, a region of space where the rules of the universe are altered by the dark magical forces of the Chaos deities that preside there, there is somehow an unlikely alliance of these deities that threatens war against material galaxy. The Imperium prepares for battle. The second plot concerns a rogue trader and a ship navigator who enter the Eye of Terror in search of exotic treasure. They encounter seductive and terrfiying forces that challenge their sanity.
There are some complaints online from those who play this game, that he takes liberties with some aspects of the game's backstory, but I could give a rat's *** about that kind of stuff, and when don't franchise novels do that anyway. Interestingly, this is his longest novel by almost double the pages ,and he concocts a lurid, vividly imagined gumbo of dark SF flavored fantasy.The thing almost reads like the novelization of a Death Metal concept album, so all the metal heads that read SFF might want to hunt this down and give it a spin. Others might find it a little grim for exactly those reasons.I've read a proposal for a second novel somewhere online.This kind of stuff is not normally my kind of thing, but I liked this novel enough that if a followup were written, I'd buy it and read it.***

Starship Troopers (reread) -RAH
I've been wanting to reread this for the past 2 years. So many discussions of Mil SF and SF in general here, will circle around a consideration of this novel, and I really could not comment on it in depth because I read it so long ago I really didn't remember much about it, other than I thought it was good. As usual after reading something in that context, it was almost like reading it for the first time.
This is a very interesting novel about civics and and individual's responsibility to society. A lot of people seem to get hung up about the "serving in the military in order to vote" thing (which is not exactly an accurate characterization anyway), and dismiss this novel as fascist. It can be pointed out almost immediately, that while this novel is about a miltary meritocracy, and might seem authoritarian in it's leanings, The Moon is A Harsh Mistress, is a novel that is antithetically and rebelliously anti-authoritarian in it's focus and concerns. Serious readers of RAH will have to reconcile the two books and resist coming to an easy, self serving consideration of RAH's political thought.
Having said that, on an action/narrative level,it's interesting how the actual conflict with "the Bugs" is almost anticlimactic. The combat scenes written in the context of how a squadron would systematically sweep a target area, really could have used a little para-first person narrator descriptive writing to create a more exciting conclusion to the book but, alas, RAH does not seem capable of doing that. Still, while IMO not as good as TMIAHM, it is a fascinating novel to read and think about, and deserving of it's reputation. ****

The Seed of Evil -Barrington J Bayley
If one goes online in search of critical evaluations of Bayley's work, one will find this anthology of Bayley's short stories routinely dismissed as "not as good as The Knights of the Limits". I find this determination of little use, as these anthologies are ultilmately arbitrary entities as presentations. Bayleys' short prose will hopefully be collected in a complete anthology where the best stories in this particular volume will not be so summarily dismissed. There is stuff here I liked as much as the stuff in KotL:
Sporting with the Chid is a story of some human hunters on an alien world who must seek aid from The Chid -a race of aliens with an advanced medical knowledge that humans are officially forbidden to contact. A sardonically gruesome little story, that definitely made me realize that the Warhammer novel was given to the right man for the job.****
The Radius Riders which is a story of a submarine type vehicle set to explore the interior of the earth riding through solid rock using a matter displacement technology. The story explores similar thematic territory to the much touted story Me and My Antronoscope in The Knights of the Limits. That story, despite it's epistemolgical concerns, seemed to me to come to the same conclusion as something as old as RAH's Orphans of the Sky. This story had for me a much more offbeat SF idea to offer, and comes to a nifty conclusion.***1/2
Man in Transit seems more like a Kafka/Borges type idea that his buddy Ballard would come up with. Due to changes in international policies, a man born of refugees on an airline, can never legally touch down in any given country, and he grows to adulthood as a passenger on commercial airflights, taken care of by the good will of flight crews and passengers. His unique circumstance conjures up an off kilter take on the JudeoChristian belief system.***1/2
There really is only one bum in this collection as far as I'm concerned -Integrity, which is a take on American Western gun toting machismo individualism and reads like something you'd find in an underground comic from the 70's. A dated weasened bit of business that preaches to the choir.
The story that really stands out, is the story of the title Seed of Evil- an almost medieval morality tale. An immortal turtle like alien named, appropriately enough, Neverdie, seeks sanctuary on a laid back future Earth. He is left alone by everyone but a doctor obsessed with Neverdie's immortality. The story is about the lengths the doctor goes to obtain the secret of immortality from Neverdie. Loved it! A bit like Robert Louis Stevenson's The Bottle Imp. Great, great story. *****
All in all a good collection ***1/2

A Plague of Demons -Keith Laumer
The first half of this novel is one of the greatest SF comicbook hero styled action stories for guys ever written in the history of the universe! An incredibly exciting, often funny, first person hard boiled detective narrative about a covert government agent physically augmented to deal with an invasion of hideous dog aliens, who, unbeknownst to the human population at large, have been harvesting human brains from concocted casualties in areas of human war activity, perhaps for centuries, for their own sinister purposes.
The second half of the novel disappointingly shifts into a talking tank story that bored the snot out of me after the exhilaration of the first part (none of Laumer's Bolo Tank novels for me, I guess;) ) until the admittedly wild VanVogt styled conclusion.The novel has a very similar structure to Dinosaur Beach, and in that regard is less successful, but the first half is just so awesome, anyone looking cyborg vs. alien combat with great action scenes should pick this book up tomorrow. ***

The Best of John Russell Fearn Volume 1 - John Russell Fearn
A Brit Golden Age guy I read about in a Bayley interview that he mentioned as an early influence. Never heard of him before that. Got to give the guy credit: he's an unstoppable force of nature from all i've read about him, writing prolifically and across genre lines for years and years and years, under a multitude of pseudonyms including the one more people might be familiar with -Vargo Statten.
I think John Clute nails him when he describes him as "unpolished and imaginatively reckless", but that "his best work is vigorous and occasionally vivid". Most of the stories here are dated prune-o-reenos, with the silliest dated popular concepts of science, but a few are so far out that they are -well- something.
Mathematica and Mathematica Plus are really fantasy, but have a giddy lunacy about them, as does Deserted Universe. The story that had the greatest appeal to me was a little fever dream called Wings Across the Cosmos, which is about this walnut sized turtle like alien (again with the turtles) of colossal mass, that comes crashing to earth and ends up infecting the narrator who then undergoes a transformation. Just one of those f***ed up little stories that crawls under your skin. The last story The Circle of Life is the most giddy and silly piece of flapdoodle- Good Gosh...wotta way to end the collection...
I can only recommend this collection to people who want to know something about this prolific Golden Age figure through a nice core sample of his writing.
A little dab'll do ya.**1/2

The Collected SF&F of Stanley G. Weinbaum Vol 1: Interplanetary Odysseys-Stanley G. Weinbaum
This guy is one of the best Golden Agers I've run across yet. His stuff despite narrative conventions of the past, has real science in it, is well written and has current appeal. I read at least half of the material collected here in The Best of Stanley G Weinbaum a few months back, but the things that were new for me here, are of interest. Stories like Flight on Titan and Planet of Doubt got me thinking about his possible influence on personal fave Hal Clement.A little Googling brought up an apparent lecture about the story Martian Odyssey that Clement gave at a Chicago Convention and confirmed the suspicion. If you start to Google some of your favs like Arthur C Clarke,+Weinbaum, don't be suprised to find them gushing about some Weinbaum work they read when they were young. This guy is the real deal!
All in all a very appealing writer. I got all these collected works volumes from Leonaur press, and I look forward to woofing them down in the coming year. I feel another personal hero in the making. :) ***1/2

Counter-Clock World -Phillip K Dick
Every year I try to squeeze in one of the last remaining PKD novels that I haven't read ,and this is this years. Notorious for it's illogically selective appllication of the notion of time reversal, it's actually one of the more focused narratives in the third tier of his novels.There is a reverse time effect going on. People are reanimated in their graves, food is expelled, cigaretttes are unsmoked. People continue to regress and then are taken into the nearest womb.Sounds like the kind of stuff that if you gave it to a non SF reader, they'd throw it back in your face, spine first, right? ;)
The story concerns a typical Dick schlub -Sebastian Hermes who after coming from the grave himself, now runs a sort of funeral home in reverse called a Vitarium. They unearth the reanimated departed and are legally and financially involved with their reintegration into society. Upon a routine unearthing, Sebastian notices that a significant religious figure, Anarch Peak, a sort of Martin Luther King/Malcom X is buried nearby, and due to his post rebirthing telepathic sensitivities he knows that this gentlemen is about to be reborn. Resurrecting this figure gets him involved in a political struggle between a Nation of Islam type organization(with robots!), representatives from the Vatican, and "The Library"- an organization seemingly beyond legal jurisdiction that is involved in the eradication of written and printed materials due to the time reverse phenomena .
Quotes from St Augustine, Thomas Aquinas and Boethius abound. Dick's wives make their usual appearances; Anne Dick is the ferocious BOW Library villainess Ann Fisher, and his forth wife is Sebastian's timid wife Lotta Hermes. To be honest, Dicks's attitudes towards women, and his addled headed aphorisms concerning them, distance him from me at this point in my life. Still, despite how truly wonked out all of the above sounds, it almost works. That's Phil Dick for you. But this novel is certainly not for the uninitiated,
and a little bit of a downer for me to read at the Holidays, thankyou. I still haven't made up my mind whether I liked it. But he's got me thinking-clever, manipulative sucker that he is. ***

Venus on the Half-Shell-Kilgore Trout (but really, Phillip Jose Farmer)
Finally got around to reading this. For those who don't know Kilgore Trout is the fictional scifi writer who appears and whose work is often cited in Kurt Vonnegut's novels. Phillip Jose Farmer got permission to write a novel as if he really existed, and here it is. More info can be found here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_on_the_Half-Shell

Some funny stuff,some effective satiric punch, more inventive than I would have expected. As a pastiche of Vonnegut's writing, it only succeeds in the most periperal of ways: he has a scifi writer cited in this book -Johnathan Swift Somers the 3rd, and there are moments of doggeral verse and bawdy song lyrics. But the satiric tone is less Swift and moreVoltaire, and not enough Twain, which is where Vonnegut get's his satiric tone from. Still there are moments that make it worth reading. At about page 160 it gets a little wearying, but picks up for the end, but I really think it should have been more like 150 -175 pages as opposed 204.
The real punchline is this:
somewhere in the middle I started to think "you know this is very similar to Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy, to the point where it's obvious someone is copying someone.
Well...Hitchhikers Guide,was first broadcast in 1978. This was written in 1974.

*With best Jerry Seinfeld sneer voice, as if he's talking to Newman*
So, Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy...not even original as a parody...a rip off of Venus on the Half-Shell...I might have known...

*** for Venus. HGTTG a book I never loved, is now down to no stars.

EDIT: I had forgotten about this even thread though I was in on aspects of the conversation. I'm not the only one who thinks Hitch Hiker's Guide is a ripoff of this novel -maledoro says roughly the same thing:

http://www.sffworld.com/forums/showthread.php?p=403839&highlight=guide#post403839

And if you don't believe it, just sit down and read it when it comes back out in print in February:

http://www.amazon.com/Venus-Half-Sh...bs_sr_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1198946584&sr=1-2
 
Last edited:
One More For the Road

Got one more in addition to the 8 above -Camp Concentration by Thomas Disch, which I'll be talking about with at least 2 other board members above in the January Book Club discussion thread.
What a month of reading for me. Whew!
 
Last edited:
Good to see the Weinbaum's being enjoyed, Arthur. :)

The discussion thread's now up, by the way.

And though I made it by the skin of my teeth, I'm pleased to say I finished Iain M Banks' Matter today, just as 2008 was dawning.

I do think 2008's going to be a good year for the genre. :)

Mark / Hobbit
 
Good to see the Weinbaum's being enjoyed, Arthur.

You bet, Hobbit! Like I said earlier, I owe a thanks to doug1937,rimworlder, and lowlander for clueing me in about him, and you for hipping me to the relatively new Leonaur Press collection. :D

http://www.amazon.com/Interplanetar...=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1199174931&sr=1-3

http://www.amazon.com/OTHER-EARTHS-Futuristic-Including-Revolution/dp/1846770629/ref=ed_oe_p

http://www.amazon.com/STRANGE-GENIUS-Including-Complete-Manderpootz/dp/1846770483/ref=ed_oe_p

http://www.amazon.com/BLACK-HEART-Classic-Including-Complete/dp/1846770491/ref=pd_sim_b_img_1

There have been some interesting discussions here about "the Big Three". Well if SGW hadn't died young, there probably would have been a "Big 4".
 
Last edited:

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top