I don't know about you guys, but I enjoyed Black Lung Captain more than Retribution Falls. I think overall the character interaction was stronger ....
just finished BLC and was going to write a few words but Bastard pretty much nailed it: i enjoyed RF, i _really_ enjoyed BLC.
a few random thoughts to add:
- very much liked the way the world opened up in BLC, felt like the Ketty Jay and crew were part of a large, sad and beautiful place. i think there comes a point in a fantasy series where you either 'feel at home' in the place or you do not. in BLC i very much did.
- as Bastard said, the character interaction really bloomed in BLC, and one got the satisfying comfort that each of them was very much an interesting individual in their own right, even Slag (the cat) which is no small achievement.
- appreciated that the ghost of 'Firefly' was not overbearing in BLC where it did, at times, feel that way in RF. my wife dropped RF because of this (we're big fans of 'Firefly'), she felt it was too close for comfort. not a problem in BLC i'd say, they've become their own people this time 'round.
i'm definitely on board for 'Iron Jackal', whether it morphs into something else or not. guess i'm just a bucklepunk fan-boy now!
