You may remember last year that I reviewed The Wood at Midwinter by Susanna, author of Piranesi and Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell – a modest hardback that was more of a mood piece than anything else. I felt at the time that it was an unexpected surprise from an author who publishes all too rarely these days.
A year has passed and now we have The Bishop of Durham Attempts to Surrender the City, a footnote to Susanna’s Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell. Unlike The Wood at Midwinter, this one is more directly related to the original tome, being an expansion of an event mentioned in Chapter 45 of the original Norrell book that builds up this imaginary history of English magic, but being set in 1110, is much earlier than the 19th century time of Norrell and Strange.
This medieval-ness is also emphasised by the page edges being ornamented by illustrations by Victoria Sawdon, as last time. They have a Bayeux Tapestry-kind of feel, which is of course deliberate.
In terms of plot, and without giving too much away, the title pretty much sums up the main story, such as it is.
The Bishop is Ranulf Flambard, who, after a strangely surreal battle, attempts to surrender the city of Durham to the fairies. The events are a test of character for the Bishop, as much as anything, as surrendering is found to be rather difficult.
The person that the Bishop is attempting to surrender to is one of the Faerie folk, a younger version of an important character in Norrell. It should not be a surprise then that this novella has same tone that Norrell had, that pseudo-folklore-esque feeling of otherworldliness, of strange magic and things beyond our human understanding going on.
At the end Susanna adds a short non-fiction chapter, Childish Things, which explains the context of the story, her writing process and makes a case for adults to not put aside their favourite childhood books, particularly fantasy books. Personally, I couldn’t agree more.
The Bishop of Durham…. (a title nearly as long as the book itself!) was a welcome return to that world of strange magic of Strange and Norrell, even if it was read in less than an hour. (The font is large!)
Like all good short stories and novellas, Bishop of Durham makes its point and has an impact, lingering in the memory a while, but not too long. It is not an essential read, but it is a welcome one.
© 2026 Mark Yon
Hardback | Bloomsbury
THE BISHOP OF DURHAM ATTEMPTS TO SURRENDER THE CITY by Susanna Clarke
A version of this story was first published in Fictionable in 2025.
October 2026 |96 pages
ISBN: 978-1 03 7211850



