Classic authors who you like(d) and who have been pretty much forgotten.

Does 'Classic authors' extend to screenplay writers too? Because if it does I'd like to bang the drum (again) for Ib Melchior

Cut and paste from Wikipedia (I gave them a donation the other day I feel entitled),


As a filmmaker, Melchior wrote and directed The Angry Red Planet (1959) and The Time Travelers (1964). His most high-profile credit was as co-screenwriter (along with John C. Higgins) of Byron Haskin's critically acclaimed Robinson Crusoe on Mars (1964). He cowrote the screenplays for two U.S.–Danish coproductions, Reptilicus (1961) and Journey to the Seventh Planet (1962), and provided the English language script for Mario Bava's Planet of the Vampires (1965).​
​
For television, he wrote the episode "The Premonition" for the second season of the original The Outer Limits series. The episode was broadcast in 1965.​
​
Melchior's short story "The Racer" was adapted as Paul Bartel's cult film favorite, Death Race 2000 (1975), starring David Carradine and Sylvester Stallone and produced by Roger Corman.​
​
He claimed to be the creator of the original idea upon which Irwin Allen based his television series Lost in Space, although he never received onscreen credit for this. In 1960, Melchior had created an outline for a series he called Space Family Robinson, which later became a Gold Key comic book.​
​
Decades later, Prelude Pictures hired Melchior as a consultant on its Lost in Space feature film adaptation, but later sold his contract to New Line Cinema, its production partner on the film. New Line agreed to pay Melchior a $75,000 production bonus and $15,000, but refused him his contractually promised two percent of the producer's gross receipts from the film.​
 
JM,
Far be it from me to cavail about going off topic.
I am a prime offender.
Your Ib is interesting although I have only seen a couple of his films.
You say Ib was responsible for the whole film in a couple of instances.
Still, screenplay authors are rarely responsible fo the final product.
Hard to say that they are the "author."
And as you say, you've been beating his drum elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
Still, screenplay authors are rarely responsible for the final product.
Hard to say that they are the "author."


Then by that argument is Shakespeare an author? Yes, he wrote the words (not all of which necessarily make it to the stage during the production process) but so many other people contribute to putting on a performance of one of his plays. Actors, directors, editors (if it's a filmed version) and so on...

Who is the 'Author' of Roman Polanski's MacBeth, Baz Lurman's Romeo + Juliette, Olivier's Hamlet etc. if not Shakespeare? :)
 
:) Of course playwrights are authors. and I am definately picking a nit to differentiate between them and screenplay authors.
But what the hell.

Great directors are often credited for movies. And sometimes plays. Also actors for their presentations - or even ad libbing dialogue. Haven't heard of editors or other people getting major credit for written work.

Olivier? I was lucky to live in London for three years. Saw Olivier and Maggie Smith in Othello with my own eyes. If you don't think he helped create the product for modern audiences you weren't there. Even if Will wrote it.

Quoting about your example, "Macbeth (or The Tragedy of Macbeth) is a 1971 historical drama film directed by Roman Polanski and co-written by Polanski and Kenneth Tynan ." (Wikipedia) So who "Wrote" it? You use an extreme example to make my point of collaboration.

But the bottom line is that you feel someone created a product, post away. It does seem to expand on what is already a pretty broad subject. I was thinking of books. But this board is about posting on what we love.
 
Last edited:
I am reading a book another author you don’t hear about these days
Lester Del Ray and the book is Police Your Planet from 1956 and under the pen name Erik Van Lhin.
he was an exemplar of the working pulp author writing under a number of pen names and wrote a large series of young adult fiction in the 50s

apparently he was given to telling "stretchers" as in this item I saw on his Wikipedia entry.
"Del Rey often told people his real name was Ramon Felipe Alvarez-del Rey (and sometimes even Ramon Felipe San Juan Mario Silvio Enrico Smith Heartcourt-Brace Sierra y Alvarez del Rey y de los Uerdes1). However, his sister has confirmed that his name was in fact Leonard Knapp"
 
"Haven't heard of editors or other people getting major credit for written work. "

Part of the mystique of 'The Book' is that it is the lone voice of a single artist. It's a romantic and easy image to sell. I'm pretty much sure that all books owe a lot more to their editors than people generally give credit. Just look at the Thanks and Acknowledgements that a lot of authors put in their books these days. Yes, the writers do most of the work and get all of the credit but authors have been profusely thanking their editors for years.

As for film, I know from my limited experience working in cutting rooms that the editor can completely reshape a scene without changing a word of dialogue by selecting different takes where an emphasis was different or cutting away from the speaker to whoever is listening to emphasis their reaction to what is being said - or even their reaction to something completely different. Just because someone on screen is seen nodding in agreement doesn't mean the actor played the scene that way. That nod may have come from some other part of the scene - or a completely different scene in the same location. Editors (usually in collaberation with the director / producer) have a LOT of control.
 
And yet the Oscar goes to writer for best screenplay. They have always thanked those other folks but only the writer went home with an Oscar.
 
And yet the Oscar goes to writer for best screenplay. They have always thanked those other folks but only the writer went home with an Oscar.

Sometimes totally undeserved.

I'm not saying that The original screenplay for Thor: Ragnarok wasn't good - but it's best line was contributed by a kid visiting the set.

Anyway this is wandering way off topic. I'll stop.
 
I don't understand JM.
Are you making my point or yours?
I get HE's, but yours, Huh? ;)
 
I don't understand JM.
Are you making my point or yours?
I get HE's, but yours, Huh? ;)

I think the point I'm trying to make is that (nearly) all writing is to a greater or lesser degree a collaborative effort. My dad used to know a writer who spent an awful lot of time in the pub writing down overheard conversations and lines from other drinkers' jokes. Sometimes those conversations would appear, pretty much verbatim, in the writer's novels and the TV series that was made from them. I regularly use things my kids have said in my comics. Who is the author in those circumstances? I don't originate the thoughts. I just wrote them down. I was reading some bits from Robert Heinlein's Grumbles from the Grave where he was moaning about the huge cuts and changes his editors wanted which in the long run probably improved his books no end. Joseph Heller spent ages working with his editor reshaping the book that became known as Catch 22 - a name that the editor, Robert Gottlieb, came up with. H L Gold edited Galaxy magazine in its heyday and was notorious for demanding rewrites and changes - often rewriting submitted material so that what we readers was told was a (for example) Robert Sheckley story was in fact a Robert Sheckley story extensively rewritten by the uncredited Gold.

The 'author' is the person who gets to put their name on it. (Or gets to demand their name taken off it if too many other sticky finger mess up their 'vision'.) There are very few bits of 'pure' authorship that make it to print. (And having read some of the execrable self-published, unedited novels that have, I think this is a damn good thing.)
 
There were some great editors here at sff world years back, e.g., RocketSheep and Kung Fu, but, oh, did they hurt my feelings a lot. They were invariably correct but that didn't make me feel any better.
Sorry for going off topic so I' mitigate that by pointing that RocketSheep went on to great things. Kung Fu kept doing what he does best.
 
I think the point I'm trying to make is that (nearly) all writing is to a greater or lesser degree a collaborative effort. My dad used to know a writer who spent an awful lot of time in the pub writing down overheard conversations and lines from other drinkers' jokes. Sometimes those conversations would appear, pretty much verbatim, in the writer's novels and the TV series that was made from them. I regularly use things my kids have said in my comics. Who is the author in those circumstances? I don't originate the thoughts. I just wrote them down. I was reading some bits from Robert Heinlein's Grumbles from the Grave where he was moaning about the huge cuts and changes his editors wanted which in the long run probably improved his books no end. Joseph Heller spent ages working with his editor reshaping the book that became known as Catch 22 - a name that the editor, Robert Gottlieb, came up with. H L Gold edited Galaxy magazine in its heyday and was notorious for demanding rewrites and changes - often rewriting submitted material so that what we readers was told was a (for example) Robert Sheckley story was in fact a Robert Sheckley story extensively rewritten by the uncredited Gold.

The 'author' is the person who gets to put their name on it. (Or gets to demand their name taken off it if too many other sticky finger mess up their 'vision'.) There are very few bits of 'pure' authorship that make it to print. (And having read some of the execrable self-published, unedited novels that have, I think this is a damn good thing.)
I take your point. As stated above differentiating between different kinds of writing is definately a nit.
I knew the story about RAH. Also that Gold could not leave a story alone (but not with specific reference to Sheckey) There still are shades of difference. Or frequency of real collaboration. Even with as you say and exemplify, editors don't get enough credit. On another thread I talk about readers and the often fully grateful author appreciates and even lists those who commented on and improved a work. More collaboration.
I still think that there is more than a scintilla of difference as (described) in the way dramatic works are received and often recognized.
But that may not be an even defendable nit. So post away.
(But you already have ;))
 
My dad used to know a writer who spent an awful lot of time in the pub writing down overheard conversations and lines from other drinkers' jokes. Sometimes those conversations would appear, pretty much verbatim, in the writer's novels and the TV series that was made from them.
This strikes me as a very loose application of the term collaboration. I recently used song lyrics as the basis for a story. I gave credit to the songwriter for his lyrics so what I did was either a collaboration or plagiarism or none of the above. I'd hate to think it is plagiarism as I use this technique frequently.
 
I would be more interested in suggestions from y'all as to authors of relatively antiquity who might still be of interest.
A.E. Van Vogt ... no?
Ahhh... I see many posts for the author. Glad to see he's not been forgotten.

The one I haven't seen mentioned that I'll add is James Blish. Star Trek aside I read a number of his works including the Cities in Flight series.
His Star Trek series is true to the TV episodes. I quite liked that. Cities in Flight is an absolute master piece I read about every five years. Never like any of this other works, though. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
As you read Dune, play the album Rubicon by Tangerine Dream in the background. It will move the experience into the realm of spice.

That's a great album, really atmospheric. You could probably pick any TD album. I don't recommend you play the album Dune by David Matthews, which is a whole lot of fun but sets titles like 'Arrakis' in a late 70s Philly Disco, which would ruin the mood for me. Even if 'Sandworms' has one of the best basslines of the era!
 
Last edited:
The soundtrack of the 1984 movie- especially the extended CD version - is quite good as well.
 
The soundtrack of the 1984 movie- especially the extended CD version - is quite good as well.
Please tell me I'm not the only one but do you do the "... the Duke will die before these eyes and he'll know, he'll know, that it is I, Baron Vladimir Harkonnen, who encompasses his doom!" line along with it too... like me?
 

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top