Star Trek Beyond just recently became available to watch on Amazon Prime, so I thought I I'd give it a try. My short take on it is it was a pretty good action movie with good special effects trying to be Star Trek.
I'm a Trekkie who is not a big fan of the Kelvin Timeline, also known as the JJ-Verse. The initial 2009 movie didn't impress me, and Into Darkness didn't resolve my misgivings. However, I knew J. J. Abrams had left the Captain's Chair on the franchise so he can go work on one he actually likes: Star Wars. Beyond was helmed by Justin Lin and Simon Pegg, so I thought I should give this movie the benefit of the doubt. I did find it was better than its predecessors in the Kelvin Timeline, but still not good Trek.
POTENTIAL MILD SPOILERS BELOW:
First I'll address my misgivings, then move onto the better aspects. There was so much that did not make much sense. Kirk has been a Captain for three years of his five year mission and is bored, so he asks for and potentially will be granted a Vice Admiral posistion? This will take him off a ship and potentially that will cure his boredom? Poor baby only has to ask and the Federation will give him whatever.
We then have Krall, who sort of makes sense as a Star Trek villain. At least he's new and not simply just "borrowed" from the Original Series and or movies like Kahn was. It would be nice if they explained how he transformed into this alien-like form, other than a throwaway line near the end. It would also be handy if they explained how at the end he spontaneously turned back into his human form. It seems odd that you get an actor with the gravitas of Idris Elba and keep him in prostetics for 90% of the movie so he can't really emote very well. It also should be said his voice was almost unintelligible for that time period of the movie too. Another loose end was where did he get all these henchmen?
Then we have the alien swarm ships, which were reportedly used for mining? Really? These were then overcome by the power of FM radio and rock-n-roll! OK, I could buy that maybe if the Beastie Boys song had disrupted their communication and ability to maneuver, making them easy targets for Federation weapons. But no, they were rapped out of existence being blown up entirely by the power of the beat! Amazing also that these alien swarm ships can be easily flown by a human doctor, McCoy just leapt into the saddle of one and was flying it like it was second nature.
Now, for the positive aspects. Like I hinted at above, I was pretty happy that this was an original movie with new characters and settings. I really liked Jaylah played by Sofia Boutella. She had a really great look for a Star Trek alien, and had a decent backstory. I also enjoyed Shohreh Aghdashloo of The Expanse as Commodore Paris (I wondered if she was supposed to be related to Tom Paris of Voyager?). There were some good aliens, unlike the TV series, there is plenty of budget for the special effects needed.
One of the finest parts of this movie was undoubtedly the Starbase Yorktown. Wow, this is what the Federation can do with all of its advanced technology! It also shows how average Federation citizens live their lives. When you have gravity control, advanced shielding, unlimited energy, and replicator technology, what kind of place can you build with that? Yorktown is a pretty good answer. My major issue is would you put this relatively poorly defended place on the border with an unexplored nebula? Regardless, it was one of the best aspects of the movie for me.
There was so much angst about Mr. Sulu and his family prior to the release of the movie. Yes, they portrayed him as being gay, and having a husband and daughter. They probably should have discussed this with George Takei in advance, as he felt it was "unfortunate." However, it was really well done. It was understated, just Sulu with his husband and daughter in one scene on Yorktown. Tasteful, and was actually a plot point, as Sulu was later fighting to protect his family who were in danger.
Zachary Quinto's Spock and Karl Urban's McCoy have such a great role in this movie. They really have got the essence of the Bones/Spock relationship down. Their banter is great, and you get that there is real feeling behind it. Since they are on their own for a good portion of the film, they get to act out those roles together.
I guess I should mention that the film does give a form of tribute to the late great Leonard Nimoy in that word of his character's death (Ambassador Spock - or Spock Prime) reaches Quinto's Spock. Its effect is discussed or shown in several scenes. I think this was pretty respectful, and fitting.
All in all, I have mixed feelings about this film. It's a lot better than the other two set in the Kelvin Timeline, but is still flawed in some ways. I would recommend watching it for the special effects, and for those things it gets right. However, understand that for many Trekkies, it will still not be fully satisfying.