Reading in February 2012

Whoot! Finished The Wise Man's Fear. I liked it but I'm eager to move onto something else. (That something else is The Throne of the Crescent Moon by Saladin Ahmed.)

I'm tossing up whether to give TWMF three or four stars on the goodreads scale. Some of it felt like it was too long for the amount of plot, but I can see what Rothfuss was trying to achieve (that immersive effect) and for the most part he was successful. I'll reflect on this for a few days before deciding whether I really liked the book or just liked it.

I've heard great things about The Throne of the Crescent Moon and I'm excited to moving onto it.
 
finished Moon Over Soho by Ben Aaronovich. The adventures of Police Constable Peter Grant remain as entertaining as in the first volume, with the mix of humor, horror, fast action scenes, jazz music and London historical or arhitectural trivia. I thought the plot was less focused, less well structured than Rivers of London and I would have liked the river gods to feature more prominently, but maybe they will in the next book in the series.

I'm considering now trying The Giver by Lois Lowry, mostly because I've seen the book referenced in a lot of reviews or top reader selections.
 
Whoot! Finished The Wise Man's Fear. I liked it but I'm eager to move onto something else. (That something else is The Throne of the Crescent Moon by Saladin Ahmed.)

I'm tossing up whether to give TWMF three or four stars on the goodreads scale. Some of it felt like it was too long for the amount of plot, but I can see what Rothfuss was trying to achieve (that immersive effect) and for the most part he was successful. I'll reflect on this for a few days before deciding whether I really liked the book or just liked it.

I've heard great things about The Throne of the Crescent Moon and I'm excited to moving onto it.

I've still not completed NoTW but I have heard from more than a few people who read TWMF also said that it didn't advance the story as much as they would have liked. (Which is probably one of the reasons I keep setting aside NoTW).

I've also heard very good things about The Throne of the Crescent Moon. I'm glad to see books finding publishing contracts that are coming from a different perspective.
 
Just finished Wintertide on my lunch and then started up Percepliquis immediately. Glad they are together, I can understand why readers may have been a tad hungry for the final volume.

Yeah delaying the book by 9 months was a bit unfortunate - but ultimately, I think a good thing. My wife...who at the time was a workaholic and never took vacations or sick time finished reading Wintertide over a long weekend and then called in to work and got the day off because she just couldn't wait for the next installment.
 
Why so? I have this on my radar, but am still trying to figure out if it will fit me well.

I'm not the one you asked, but I'll throw in my two cents anyway.

It's an odd book. First, it's an epistolary novel -- written as the main character's journal entries -- which is uncommon in fantasy, and which gives the book a bit of an odd structure to start with. Then, large parts of the book are taken up with discussions of OTHER books. Also, there's a large percentage of the book in which nothing "fantastical" happens. Also, the narrative voice -- especially if you're listening to it in audio format, so you get the accent (Welsh) -- is very very distinctive. And finally, there's lots of uncertainty about the fantastical aspects, which I personally liked a lot until near the end (when IMHO the author blew it).

I think it's definitely worth a listen -- but there's not much "typical" about it. It's got a flavor all its own!
 
I've also heard very good things about The Throne of the Crescent Moon. I'm glad to see books finding publishing contracts that are coming from a different perspective.

For all my initital enthusiasm yesterday, I've bounced of The Throne of the Crescent Moon for the time being. After slogging through Rothfuss I realized I can't stomach anymore fantasy right away, no matter how many good things I've heard about Saladin Ahmed's book. I'm heading over to the sf side of the house for a break.
 
sullivan_riyria said:
Why so? I have this on my radar, but am still trying to figure out if it will fit me well.
I'm not the one you asked, but I'll throw in my two cents anyway.

It's an odd book. First, it's an epistolary novel -- written as the main character's journal entries -- which is uncommon in fantasy, and which gives the book a bit of an odd structure to start with. Then, large parts of the book are taken up with discussions of OTHER books. Also, there's a large percentage of the book in which nothing "fantastical" happens. Also, the narrative voice -- especially if you're listening to it in audio format, so you get the accent (Welsh) -- is very very distinctive. And finally, there's lots of uncertainty about the fantastical aspects, which I personally liked a lot until near the end (when IMHO the author blew it).

I think it's definitely worth a listen -- but there's not much "typical" about it. It's got a flavor all its own!
Much of what Contrarius said is true for myself as well. I'm also finding it fairly slow moving, which doesn't always bother me, but I'm getting a little frustrated by the slow trickle of information. At first it was kind of intriguing and was pulling me along in the story, but now its just starting to bug me. Outside of that the thing that is bothering me the most is the constant talk of other books, sometimes discussing the contents of the book without really expanding on it. This makes sense in the context of it being a diary, but for me as a reader it is just frustrating.

Overall I think it is well written, I just don't think it is fitting my preferences. I'm enjoying it well enough, but I'm not engrossed by it like I usually am or like to be. I'm only about half way at the moment, so there is still some time for it to change my mind.
 
I recently read Gene Wolfe's The Knight. It was my first ever Wolfe reading experience and I'm coming away from it with mixed feelings. Some strikes, some gutter balls. Here's a bit from my review:


A lot happens along the way, and reading The Knight sorta made me feel like I was reading someone play an RPG like Skyrim. Like my rpg adventures, Able would set out to do one thing, then see something else that catches his fancy and head off in a completely different direction. This tangential plot movement was a bit of a double edged sword because while it could be frustrating to feel like I was getting dragged along by a blundering imbecile, the plot never slowed down and the pacing was fantastic.

The Knight is told, for better or worse, through Able's first person perspective. I definitely had a hard time trusting him as a reliable narrator though. Even though he was magically given a man's body, Able is still very much a confused, sometimes stupid adolescent. As a reader I was pretty much at his mercy for figuring out what was going on, and there are plenty of times when he doesn't describe things so well, or seemingly omits details, or just completely skips over things he doesn't want to talk about. This led to a few "wait a minute..." moments where I could tell something was fishy, but wasn't quite sure what it was.

Because of Able's whimsical nature, his journeys take him all over, on land, sea, and even to different levels of reality, which are stacked on top of each other, and Mythgarthr, (the realm Abel got transported to), happens to be right in the middle of. Along the way he meets some interesting people like Bold Berthold, a noble peasant who calls Able his brother. Able also acquires some allies like a dog that is more than a dog, a sailor turned faithful servant, and many others. You never know who he's gonna meet or what kind of situations he's gonna get into because his wanderings could lead him anywhere. This free spirit-like approach to adventuring helps flesh out the world, and brings in some interesting characters that help add some life to the novel.

Despite tipping the scales at over 500 pages, I sorta feel like nothing really happened in this novel. There's not really any plot to speak of the and the narrative is the definition of willy-nilly. However, I still kinda liked it. This book is such an enigma though; It's an enigma in the sense that Able's narration and recollection of events is sometimes accurate, sometimes misleading and sometimes veiled, but also in the sense that I'm not totally sure whether I liked it or not. I'm definitely torn as to whether or not I'll read the second novel in the duology, The Wizard. Part of me thinks I should because it'll clear up all the confusion, and another part of me thinks I'll only be more frustrated. The jury is deliberating in my brain.

Any Wolfe readers out there? Should I carry on?
 
I recently read Gene Wolfe's The Knight. It was my first ever Wolfe reading experience and I'm coming away from it with mixed feelings. Some strikes, some gutter balls. Here's a bit from my review:
I'm hoping to get to it one day. I picked up - ages ago - the TPB omnibus edition (The Wizard Knight). It is not small. 900 page TPB. Eeeek.
 
I finished Master of Heathcrest Hall by Galen Beckett (Mark Anthony) the trilogy ending novel after the wonderful Magicians and Mrs Quent and House on Durrow Street; like with the other 2 highly awaited fantasy series ending of this year read so far (Percepliquis and Daemon Prism) I enjoyed this book to a large extent but was not really blown away by it and I felt it the weakest of the series.

Maybe too many pages for the depth, maybe the fact that this book has lots of action and its setup and style favors more intrigue and manners and the action becomes a bit ridiculous on occasion, maybe because Ivy is less of a dominant character and she was the main draw of the series for me... I still liked the style and the book was an easy and pleasurable read but I remember how much I was absorbed by the other two and how pale this one seemed to be in comparison.

Another thing that bugs me is the insistence of dotting all the i's and crossing all the t's in the ending (Percepliquis was worse but this is close) - I do not get what is wrong with leaving stuff to the imagination of the reader, leaving some open-endness?

Well 4 more hugely awaited fantasy series ending novels to come (Anthony Huso, Mark Newton, Robert Redick and Kate Elliott) and a few more of interest or possible like Kings of the Morning, Caine's Law, Rise Ransom City or if Paul Hoffman's 3rd Cale novel or Wanderers by Paula Brandon come up in the fall) and I am curious which if any will really make me say, "well this is how I believe a series should end!"
 
Another thing that bugs me is the insistence of dotting all the i's and crossing all the t's in the ending (Percepliquis was worse but this is close) - I do not get what is wrong with leaving stuff to the imagination of the reader, leaving some open-endness?

I think that is just one of those things where we'll have to agree to disagree on. I personally felt a "responsibility" to tie everything up. After all this is not one of those series that just keeps going. It was designed and written with a specfic beginning and a specfic ending. So it's not like it will be revisited at some point. Thre are certainly some things that can be speculated about (as I've seen fanfic and others have mentioned an interest in seeing...
What the world will be like after the Censars and Teshlor skills are re-introduced. How will Royce handle his new position. A story featuring Allie and Mercy. Where does Nimbus go and what does he do.
So I think there is plenty for the imagination to consider.

That being said...you are not alone in this criticism - There have been a few others that don't like everything being tied up...but overall those are minority opinions and the larger segment of the population actually likes that everything is resolved. Of course I'm glad that is the case, but the choice wasn't made based on what I thought the "audience" wanted to see happen. These books have always been written with one goal...to create a book that I wanted to read, and yes I do like endings that resolve. I'm glad that there are those that the majority feel the same way, but even if I thought that peope wanted it differentlly, I wouldn't have changed it.
 
I'm still reading deadhouse gates smh. I've been reading this since like mid December :confused:
 
I just passed the halfway point of A Storm of Swords. That Scene just happened and I am stunned, appalled and all that. This one is my favorite of the Ice and Fire books so far, and I really liked the first two. Martin is brilliant.
 
I just passed the halfway point of A Storm of Swords. That Scene just happened and I am stunned, appalled and all that. This one is my favorite of the Ice and Fire books so far, and I really liked the first two. Martin is brilliant.

ASoS actually made close the book and kiss the cover a couple times. And even after the incredible emotional rollercoaster that left me completely spent, the very last page has something that forced an out-loud HOLY ****ING **** from me.
 
James Barclay's Elves: Once Walked with Gods - this wasn't on my radar at all, I loved James's Raven books but didn't pick up on this being released until my brother asked me if I wanted to borrow his copy. Really enjoyed it, classic Barclay with free flowing battles, good characters and an interesting world. Seeing a 'young' Auum was neat and I'm looking forward to the next one which should be dropping through my letterbox this week :)
 
I finished Among Others by Jo Walton and don't really know what I think of it. On the one hand, I finished it quickly (for me) and there was enough interesting about it towards the end that I stayed up a little later than I like to last night to finish it. The story is very much centred around the main character, given that its written as an episode of journal entries. This worked in some cases and not as well in others. Its also well written and structured.

On the other hand, the story was slow for about 90% of it, and even the other 10% wasn't exactly quick moving. But that wasn't the point of the story, being character driven and all. There are no real plot twists here, nothing that jumps up and really surprises you, just a straight forward story. The magical elements are odd and sometimes suspect. It's an odd book all around, really.

Still, it's left me thinking more about it after I've finished. I think there are some well established points made throughout, despite not seeming to really have a central theme. Some good points were made on sexuality, religion, politics, and education systems and the environments that kids and teenagers grow up in. Also a lot of dialogue on some classic science fiction and fantasy, most of which went right over my head, given that I've only read maybe 3 of the books the protagonist mentions (out of probably 100+). I guess I'd say I enjoyed it. But I keep getting the feeling that I missed something, that I'm not understanding the central drive of the narrative.

Anyways, not sure what I'm going to get into next. I've got quite a stack of unread books, but none of them seem overly appealing right now. Maybe I need a break from fantasy.
 
I finished Among Others by Jo Walton

I started Among Others a couple of days ago as well, and might come back to it soon. 25% in (on my Kindle) and not a lot's grabbing my attention as yet...

Started Jeffrey Ford's The Girl in the Glass and it's hooked me in the first chapter!
 
I started Jon Sprunk's Shadow's Master this morning.

Wishing (a little) that I'd re-read the first two books beforehand, but largely I'm enjoying it so far :D I think it's the shortest book in the series - it's certainly a little thinner than Lure.
 
ASoS actually made close the book and kiss the cover a couple times. And even after the incredible emotional rollercoaster that left me completely spent, the very last page has something that forced an out-loud HOLY ****ING **** from me.

Wow - that is very high praise indeed. I started the first one and found it not to my liking - as it seemed more of a journalistic accounting of events occuring in Westros than a story that has a goal in mind and you are moving toward. But this makes me rethink my decision and if it could elicit a similar reaction well worth it. I may indeed give it another run.
 

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top