A STIR OF ECHOES by Richard Matheson (Tor, 1999; J. B. Lippincott & Co., 1958)
A Stir of Echoes occurs in a typical 1950s fictional suburb, the houses painted and neat, the lawns green, the residents chipper and prosperous and happy on the outside while underneath a seething mass of repressed and frustrated needs coil and churn. This was what Matheson brought to the horror novel: Mundane, late 20th century life shot through with unspoken desires overlaying a world of paranormal experience that reveals itself to one or a few of the characters. This novel, then, is a precursor to works like Thomas Tryon’s Harvest Home, Peter Straub’s Ghost Story and Stephen King’s Pet Semetary.
After coming out of hypnosis Tom Wallace experiences an awaking of psychic powers allowing him to see what might be a ghost. He comes to realize that the ghost wants something, and that he doesn’t just see ghosts, he sees jumbled and muddy images that might be the future. Wallace’s wife, Anne, is as patient as possible, but the effects on Wallace echo through his relationships – Anne, pregnant, fears for his sanity and their children’s well-being, and their friends realize something is different. Meanwhile, Wallace becomes too aware of his neighbors, one wife desperate for children and her husband who does not want to be tied down, and another neighbor dominated by his wife, a sexual barracuda whose appetite amused Wallace before, but seems threatening to him now. And through all this, the ghost appears again, wanting something, but what?
The role of female sexuality in A Stir of Echoes makes the novel feel like a precursor to Matheson’s later, more explicit horror novel, Hell House, but also dates it. Written near the beginning of the so-called sexual revolution, and drawing on the 1950s preoccupation with post-WWII suburban housing developments as petri dishes for frustration – economic, class and/or sexual – the women are well-portrayed within their types, but are still types: wife/mother, sexual predator, frustrated mother. The portrayal seems to imply that the women are locked into these roles, and while Anne stretches the type through intelligence and compassion, still it’s not far.
That criticism aside, this is an entertaining ghost/horror story.
I bought a paperback of A Stir of Echoes back in the 1980s with the plan to read it immediately; didn't happen. I planned on digging it out from the bottom of the TBR mountain before seeing the movie; didn't happen. Somehow I don't recall, I ended up with a movie edition of the novel and now I've pulled the book out for the worst of reasons, to refresh my memory of a writer I enjoyed who has passed away, a little concerned the book might not live up to my expectations. I shouldn't have worried.
If this novel doesn't attain the level of I am Legend or Hell House, Matheson still does a fine job of gradually depicting the neighborhood the Wallaces live in, unveiling the extent of Wallace's awakening, of the effect on the man and his wife, of the gradual solving of the mystery. A Stir of Echoes has the feel of an extended episode of the original Twilight Zone, not surprising since Matheson was a regular writer for the series, and he packs all this into 211 paperback pages.
If literarily (and, in this case, literally) Joe Hill comes to us by way of Stephen King, then King comes to us by way of Richard Matheson (but only literarily). Matheson has his own literary ancestors -- maybe Fritz Leiber, maybe Robert Bloch, maybe Henry Kuttner -- but like the best writers he took what he learned and turned it to his own uses, and in A Stir of Echoes we can see the seeds not just of King’s brand of horror, but also of current urban fantasy.
About the 1999 movie version of A Stir of Echoes: It's been several years since I saw it, and as I recall the plot diverges from the novel somewhat. (IMDB seems to confirm that) Still, it’s a good movie, respectful of the source though not married to it, and anchored by the usual fine performance of Kevin Bacon.
Hobbit’s review of A Stir of Echoes
RELATED SUBURBAN READING:
“The Hungry House” by Robert Bloch
“Bird of Prey” by John Collier
Next: HELL HOUSE by Richard Matheson
I felt like some sort of fantastic actor who could play two scenes simultaneously using not only the same setting but the same dialogue. That was the frightening thing about it. Anyone could have stood there and watched us and thought it innocuous; a pleasant summer's day flirtation which
lasted a few moments, then ended. They wouldn't have seen the part of it that went on underneath.
-- From A Stir of Echoes
lasted a few moments, then ended. They wouldn't have seen the part of it that went on underneath.
-- From A Stir of Echoes
A Stir of Echoes occurs in a typical 1950s fictional suburb, the houses painted and neat, the lawns green, the residents chipper and prosperous and happy on the outside while underneath a seething mass of repressed and frustrated needs coil and churn. This was what Matheson brought to the horror novel: Mundane, late 20th century life shot through with unspoken desires overlaying a world of paranormal experience that reveals itself to one or a few of the characters. This novel, then, is a precursor to works like Thomas Tryon’s Harvest Home, Peter Straub’s Ghost Story and Stephen King’s Pet Semetary.
After coming out of hypnosis Tom Wallace experiences an awaking of psychic powers allowing him to see what might be a ghost. He comes to realize that the ghost wants something, and that he doesn’t just see ghosts, he sees jumbled and muddy images that might be the future. Wallace’s wife, Anne, is as patient as possible, but the effects on Wallace echo through his relationships – Anne, pregnant, fears for his sanity and their children’s well-being, and their friends realize something is different. Meanwhile, Wallace becomes too aware of his neighbors, one wife desperate for children and her husband who does not want to be tied down, and another neighbor dominated by his wife, a sexual barracuda whose appetite amused Wallace before, but seems threatening to him now. And through all this, the ghost appears again, wanting something, but what?
The role of female sexuality in A Stir of Echoes makes the novel feel like a precursor to Matheson’s later, more explicit horror novel, Hell House, but also dates it. Written near the beginning of the so-called sexual revolution, and drawing on the 1950s preoccupation with post-WWII suburban housing developments as petri dishes for frustration – economic, class and/or sexual – the women are well-portrayed within their types, but are still types: wife/mother, sexual predator, frustrated mother. The portrayal seems to imply that the women are locked into these roles, and while Anne stretches the type through intelligence and compassion, still it’s not far.
That criticism aside, this is an entertaining ghost/horror story.
I bought a paperback of A Stir of Echoes back in the 1980s with the plan to read it immediately; didn't happen. I planned on digging it out from the bottom of the TBR mountain before seeing the movie; didn't happen. Somehow I don't recall, I ended up with a movie edition of the novel and now I've pulled the book out for the worst of reasons, to refresh my memory of a writer I enjoyed who has passed away, a little concerned the book might not live up to my expectations. I shouldn't have worried.
If this novel doesn't attain the level of I am Legend or Hell House, Matheson still does a fine job of gradually depicting the neighborhood the Wallaces live in, unveiling the extent of Wallace's awakening, of the effect on the man and his wife, of the gradual solving of the mystery. A Stir of Echoes has the feel of an extended episode of the original Twilight Zone, not surprising since Matheson was a regular writer for the series, and he packs all this into 211 paperback pages.
If literarily (and, in this case, literally) Joe Hill comes to us by way of Stephen King, then King comes to us by way of Richard Matheson (but only literarily). Matheson has his own literary ancestors -- maybe Fritz Leiber, maybe Robert Bloch, maybe Henry Kuttner -- but like the best writers he took what he learned and turned it to his own uses, and in A Stir of Echoes we can see the seeds not just of King’s brand of horror, but also of current urban fantasy.
About the 1999 movie version of A Stir of Echoes: It's been several years since I saw it, and as I recall the plot diverges from the novel somewhat. (IMDB seems to confirm that) Still, it’s a good movie, respectful of the source though not married to it, and anchored by the usual fine performance of Kevin Bacon.
Hobbit’s review of A Stir of Echoes
RELATED SUBURBAN READING:
“The Hungry House” by Robert Bloch
“Bird of Prey” by John Collier
Next: HELL HOUSE by Richard Matheson


