SFFWorld's unofficial Top 20 Fantasy Series List

Status
Not open for further replies.
  1. Lord of the Rings by JRR Tolkien
  2. Wheel of Time by Robert Jordan
  3. A Song of Ice and Fire by George RR Martin
  4. Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson
  5. First Law Trilogy - Joe Abercrombie
  6. Malazan by Steven Erikson
  7. King Killer Chronicles by Patrick Rothfuss
  8. Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson
  9. Codex Alera by Jim Butcher
  10. Broken Empire by Mark Lawrence
 
Last edited:
1. Earthsea - Le Guin
2. Lord of the Rings - Tolkien
3. Thomas Covenant - Donaldson
4. Lyonesse - Vance
5. Malazan - Erikson
6. Winter of the World - Michael Scott Rohan
7. Dark Tower - King
8. Discworld - Pratchett
9. Chronicles of Amber - Zelazny
10. Black Company - Cook
 
Interesting because I've wanted to read this one... but it isn't a series yet, is it?
well, it is, but only book 1 is out so far. i really can't wait for her next one. mind you, i'd have liked her to have been able to continue the bel dame series. that was awesome. given the mad max frenzy right now, this book should be pushed hard. it's essentially mad max in a kind of fantasy setting with scifi. dune mixed with mad max and pulp sword and sorcery. brilliant stuff.
 
1 Farseer by Robin Hobb
2 Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson
3 Dark Tower by Stephen King
4 Book of The New Sun by Gene Wolfe
5 Bas-Lag by China Mieville
6 Shadowmarch by Tad Williams
7 Riftwar Saga by Raymond E Feist
8 Viriconium by M John Harrison
I am fairly new to fantasy(less then five years) so can list no more. So far I have only completed Farseer, Dark Tower and Book of The New Sun. Stormlight Archive intrigues me so much as it is so far away from completion but seems to be very highly regarded. Really enjoy reading everyone's list and comments.
 
Last edited:
Just wanted to post some of the interesting things so far. These are listed on the link of the original post, but I'll paste them here too.

  • LOTR and ASOIAF are always #1 and #2 in any order on our lists.
  • Lots of authors have 2 series in the entire list. David Gemmell & Robin Hobb are the only with 3 .
  • Lyonese ranked 22nd with 3 votes and Sword of Truth ranked 79th, also with 3 votes.
  • Brandon Sanderson has 2 in the top 20.(3 of you count Wheel of Time!!)
  • Only 4 books have more than one 1st place vote: Lord of the Rings, As Song of Ice and Fire, First Law, Malazan

It is always interesting to see the favorites of other people. However, anything else than ASoIaF and LotR occupying places 1 and 2 would be hilarious.
These 2 series (or books as LotR is just one long book) have defined Fantasy in a way nothing else comes close to.
 
It is always interesting to see the favorites of other people. However, anything else than ASoIaF and LotR occupying places 1 and 2 would be hilarious.
These 2 series (or books as LotR is just one long book) have defined Fantasy in a way nothing else comes close to.
How has ASoIaF defined fantasy? It is a grand and complex story with many twists, but to me it only made a change in the way it treats its central characters; as in that they can be killed off or that their lives turned into a terrible mess at any moment so that any attachment is held in fear by the reader.
 
"These 2 series (or books as LotR is just one long book) have defined Fantasy
I started to debate this with respect to Martin, but then I thought about what it means to "define" fantasy. I guess one valid definition would be that when people define the fantasy genre, they use a certain book series as an example. For many people, Martin probably fulfills that, especially for younger readers who didn't grow up on Belgariad, Shannara, Thomas Covenant, Elric, Amber, etc. I don't know if I would say nothing else comes close (for anyone over 35, any of the series I list probably come close or surpass it) but I'd guess its the most popular fantasy series of the last 20 years.
 
I started to debate this with respect to Martin, but then I thought about what it means to "define" fantasy. I guess one valid definition would be that when people define the fantasy genre, they use a certain book series as an example. For many people, Martin probably fulfills that, especially for younger readers who didn't grow up on Belgariad, Shannara, Thomas Covenant, Elric, Amber, etc. I don't know if I would say nothing else comes close (for anyone over 35, any of the series I list probably come close or surpass it) but I'd guess its the most popular fantasy series of the last 20 years.
That is a valid definition, although the thing is: These statements have been made every handful of years about a series. For years I read that the Wheel of Time would define fantasy for decades to come as well, but seeing the recent responses on this forum the WoT's impact is growing less and less. Before ASoIaF became a TV series the books were popular enough but nothing out of the ordinary (if I compare it to WoT and Sword of Truth). Similar things happened with Twilight and True Blood when they were adapted into movie and TV series. For some time I even feared vampire novels would swamp the other kinds of fantasy.

Fantasy has been finding success with the mainstream public for some time now allowing more different and far better adaptations than in the past. Game Of Thrones is setting a new milestone but the multitude of series and movies give new fantasy fans a far wider spectrum of what kind of fantasy is out there. Once GoT is done there will soon be another series that dominates the popularity.
 
It is always interesting to see the favorites of other people. However, anything else than ASoIaF and LotR occupying places 1 and 2 would be hilarious.
These 2 series (or books as LotR is just one long book) have defined Fantasy in a way nothing else comes close to.

If this list were Most Influential Fantasy, I would put them on my list. As it is, there are countless series I've enjoyed a lot more than these two. For me personally, Lord of the Rings has been a lot more influential than ASoIaF.
 
If this list were Most Influential Fantasy, I would put them on my list. As it is, there are countless series I've enjoyed a lot more than these two. For me personally, Lord of the Rings has been a lot more influential than ASoIaF.

You are right. This list should be about the favorite series of our community.

I generally see 2 different directions of the "pure" Fantasy genre:

1) The "classic" one. Good vs. Evil. Epic Quests and Fights. Magic and various races, creatures and beasts. The glorious heroes triumphate at the end.
2) The "modern" one. Everything is Grey, nobody is pure good or evil. Lots of intrigues, politics, economy. Very character driven. "Realistic". Main characters are not save etc.

I know this has already been discussed without end and it is not as simple as that. E.g. one can argue that authors like Robin Hobb have already used "Grey" characters (have not read her yet so I might be wrong) before Martin.

However, if there is any Consensus that more or less these 2 directions exist ASoIaF and LotR are more or less the master templates. Some authors might mix the formula a bit and put some new ingredients into it. Throw some philosophic or religious elements into the soup. Or some humorous aspects. Or put the Focus on one character instead a whole cast.

I would also consider GoT and the LotR/Hobbit movies the only "A" rated TV adaptions of traditional Fantasy literature. People I know who normally cannot stand Fantasy tell me how fantastic these movies/this Show are.
 
1. Malazan
2. Sword of Shadows
3. Black Company
4. Harry Dresden
5. First Law (and Best Served Cold my favorite Abercrombie book)
6. Mark Lawrence, Broken Empire
7. Gentleman Bastards
8. Eddie Lacrosse series
9. Morgan - Land Fit for Heroes
10. Hmmm. I'll go with Illona Andrews Kate Daniels books

I couldn't vote for ASOFAI given i found the last two books to be disposable.
Stormlight might enter my top 10, but book 2 was a step back
Brandon Sandersons Reckoners books might enter my top 10, i loved the first two book
Wheel of Time would have been reached my top 2 if it had ended after book 6
 
1. Tolkien
2. Glen Cook-Black Company
3. Rothfus- Kingkiller Chronicles
4. Susan Cooper- Dark is Rising (Have yet to read a better Children's fantasy series)
5. Tad Williams- Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn
6. Glen Cook- Dread Empire
7. Paul Kearny- Monarchies of God
8. Jordan- Wheel of Time
9. Butcher- Dresden Files (I didn't particularly like Skin Game)

I would have to think about a few more.. I have a hand full of big and classic ones that I haven't read yet like Malazan, Stormlight Archive, and Shadowmarch. Although I am just about to start Acts of Caine and Fionavar Tapestry..
 
Out of curiosity, have you read Harry Potter?
Absolutely! I was eleven or twelve when the first one came out. I read all of them, but I have a love/hate relationship with the series. My mom read the Dark is Rising Sequence to me even before I read Harry Potter. I think that it is more sophisticated, more interesting, and a heck of a lot more consistent than Harry Potter.
 
Don't have a top 10, but my favorites are

1) Dresden Files
2) Discworld especially the ones involving the Night Watch
3) A Song of Ice and Fire
4) Codex Alera
 
GET YOUR VOTES IN BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE

Just FYI, we are going to close voting completely on June 2nd. I will tally votes one more time after that, and the thread will be closed and no more voting!

Please get your votes in before then!!
 
1. Wheel of Time - Jordan
2. Stormlight - Sanderson
3. Lord of the Rings - Tolkien
4. Song of Albion - Lawhead
5. King Killer - Rothfuss
6. Shannara - Brooks
7. Riddle Master - McKillip
8. Farseer - Hobbs
9. Recluse - Modesitt (really SciFi??? Fall of Angles seems to indicate it)
10. Memory, Sorrow, Thorn - Williams
 
Absolutely! I was eleven or twelve when the first one came out. I read all of them, but I have a love/hate relationship with the series. My mom read the Dark is Rising Sequence to me even before I read Harry Potter. I think that it is more sophisticated, more interesting, and a heck of a lot more consistent than Harry Potter.

Likewise, Dark is Rising along with Lloyd Alexander's work were early stepping stones into the world of fantasy.
 
1. Dresden Files by Jim Butcher
2. Broken Empire Trilogy by Mark Lawrence
3. Prince of Nothing Trilogy by R Scott Bakker
4. Kingkiller Chronicles by Patrick Rothfuss
5. Shadow Ops by Myke Cole
6. A Song of Fire and Ice by George RR Martin
7. Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson
8. Mistborn Trilogy by Brandon Sanderson
9. Lightbringer Series by Brent Weeks
10. Demon Cycle by Peter V Brett

There are some series that I would like to include, but they are either too short (at the moment), science fiction rather than fantasy, or fall just slightly below the top 10 at the moment:

Daemon by Daniel Suarez (SF)
Old Man's War by John Scalzi
Reckoners by Brandon Sanderson
Moontide Quartet by David Hair
Raven's Shadow by Anthony Ryan
Ryria Revelations by Michael Sullivan
 
Wow, apparently our forum members (as a whole) don't read fantasy/fantasies written by women.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top