MattNY
Registered User
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2009
- Messages
- 574
Surprisingly, even with my limited reading of the scifi/fantasy genre (compared to most of you, anyhow), weeding down to five will be difficult. The biggest problem is that I have read one book from many esteemed authors, but I have not read several from one particular author. I would like to eliminate those I have only read one book from, but then my list would be rather disappointing.
I suppose, this is who they would be:
1. J.R.R. Tolkien - The Hobbit and the LOTR series are all as close to 'perfect' as any novel I have ever read. It is definitely the standard to which I compare all fantasy novels to.
2. George R.R. Martin - The ASOIAF series is the best thing I have read from modern fantasy, or from any genre recently for that matter. Outside of that series, I only have read Fevre Dream from him, but that, too, was quite excellent.
3. China Mieville - I have only read Perdido Street Station from him, but it was an amazing read. The city of New Crobuzon was incredibly deep and powerful. I adored the truly shaded and colorful characters and the impacts of their decisions. I also thought the ending was fantastic and impactful. I look forward to moving onto The Scar soon.
4. Joe Abercrombie - Again, I have only read one book from Joe (Blade Itself), but it was a fantastic read that got better with each chapter. I enjoyed how each character's POV read completely different from another's, truly giving the sense of being with that character, rather than having someone tell you their POV. That is how it feels reading most fantasy POVs and I felt Joe really broke past that barrier, and in his debut novel no less. I shall finally be getting to Before They Are Hanged soon, and look forward to further dwelving into one of my all time favorite characters, Glotka. It also doesn't hurt that he frequently comes around here and posts randomly, without any pretentiousness either.
5. Guy Gavriel Kay - I have only read Tigana, but I found it to be a beautiful read, and the closest I have found an author be to Tolkien without it feeling like a copy or a fake. Of course, when I look back, I try to forget about the terrible epilogue that followed a wonderful ending. I have several of his other books and will be reading them eventually.
Honorable Mentions - George Orwell, Ursula K. Le Guin, Brandon Sanderson, Susanna Clarke and Dan Simmions. Especially Sanderson, who I think may have the best chance of this group to break my Top 5.
I suppose, this is who they would be:
1. J.R.R. Tolkien - The Hobbit and the LOTR series are all as close to 'perfect' as any novel I have ever read. It is definitely the standard to which I compare all fantasy novels to.
2. George R.R. Martin - The ASOIAF series is the best thing I have read from modern fantasy, or from any genre recently for that matter. Outside of that series, I only have read Fevre Dream from him, but that, too, was quite excellent.
3. China Mieville - I have only read Perdido Street Station from him, but it was an amazing read. The city of New Crobuzon was incredibly deep and powerful. I adored the truly shaded and colorful characters and the impacts of their decisions. I also thought the ending was fantastic and impactful. I look forward to moving onto The Scar soon.
4. Joe Abercrombie - Again, I have only read one book from Joe (Blade Itself), but it was a fantastic read that got better with each chapter. I enjoyed how each character's POV read completely different from another's, truly giving the sense of being with that character, rather than having someone tell you their POV. That is how it feels reading most fantasy POVs and I felt Joe really broke past that barrier, and in his debut novel no less. I shall finally be getting to Before They Are Hanged soon, and look forward to further dwelving into one of my all time favorite characters, Glotka. It also doesn't hurt that he frequently comes around here and posts randomly, without any pretentiousness either.
5. Guy Gavriel Kay - I have only read Tigana, but I found it to be a beautiful read, and the closest I have found an author be to Tolkien without it feeling like a copy or a fake. Of course, when I look back, I try to forget about the terrible epilogue that followed a wonderful ending. I have several of his other books and will be reading them eventually.
Honorable Mentions - George Orwell, Ursula K. Le Guin, Brandon Sanderson, Susanna Clarke and Dan Simmions. Especially Sanderson, who I think may have the best chance of this group to break my Top 5.

