December Flash Fiction Voting Thread

Fave Festive Fable?

  • Joys of Christmas by Sid Arbaon [url]http://www.sffworld.com/community/story/3421p0.html[/url]

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Christmas Wish by Steve Jones [url]http://www.sffworld.com/community/story/3426p0.html[/url]

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Intercalary Christmas by Chuck Reina [url]http://www.sffworld.com/community/story/3436p0.html[/url]

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    11
  • Poll closed .
Dawnstorm;499554 [i said:
A Christmas Wish[/i]: I can't say I get the "rule" behind the ending, and neither do I understand this line in the light of this ending, which sounds key: "Incidently, I was asked that very question once, a long time ago. My answer was how I came to be a genie." Shouldn't the final wish have affected the wisher? What am I missing? (I do like the cross-cultural wishing index you set up, though.)

... and other comments to the same point...

Yep, this is what happens when I write something in a hurry. This is why editing is my middle name, or should be. (That might draw some attention at the DMV:D--just call me "ed")

Actually, I had no idea, I just thought it'd be fun. I may go back later and add something about how a non selfish wish which benefits a large number of people causes any inheirent cursiness to turn back on the genie, something like that.

Him saying he would like to keep the lamp played out as a wish, as the genie, he gets to keep the lamp. That's all.

Thanks for the comments, good and bad. I really do listen. My life is being too interesting at this point, but if I can write comments I will do so. ...way too interesting...

The thought occurs, with the way the self-publishing industry is going. We could have the Christmas contest in July, and then, properly edited, publish a sffworld flash fiction contest christmas magazine by next November. --just a thought.

I'll vote sometime soon too.

B5
 
Hi everyone!

Great Christmas stories! I hope to post comments on everyone over the weekend (holding thumbs), but for now, I just want to say that my vote went to Nils' story. The best way I can describe it is Snot en trane, my ou, snot en trane [I]Wow, that one really got to me (may have been all my war-literature reading the pat few months). Brilliant, tugged at the heartstrings and had me in tears. Can I vote twice?

O, and a very brief explanation of "Cookies and Milk": What happens when the north pole is being watched and all the toys are store bought? Old Nick (Santa) retires to an awful suburban estate. At least he has an "elf" coming to visit. Both dislike what Christmas has become. Both dislike Google Earth even more because now even the North Pole can be watched... (Hence "Bloody Google Earth"). Santa is real and his house is hidden beneath the ice at the North Pole. Hope that helps :)

Write to all later!
[/I]
 
Gift Giving: another well put together conversational piece from the enticingly subdued surroundings of Senor Viejo's bar, finishing up with a feel good factor.

The Joy's of Christmas: Very amusing and fun to read. A refreshingly light-hearted entry.

Heavenly Peace: I have been knowingly guilty throughout these contests of trying to pack too much into a thousand words. I always felt compelled to attempt a full story with beginning, middle and end (bit of a back-story as well very often) rather than something that was Flash Fiction in its true sense. Just couldn't help myself! I tried to overcome this in a couple of the entries for the previous 'vs.' contest and I seriously tried to achieve it here too. Fingers crossed.
I had my eyes wide open to the fact that I was possibly treading on rather thin ice regarding historical fact and cultural sensibilities. I carry out only minimal research for these things. Having digested Dawnstorm's earlier post it appears that I may have just gotten away with it.

A Christmas Wish: I did enjoy this little tale of a genie with attitude, but must admit to being a little confused by the ending at the time of reading. Your later post explained things and also made me chuckle, Steve. Also like your Christmas magazine idea for next year - you can certainly count me in.

Faraway Holiday: Nice job! I thought you got the solitude just right. I was beginning to wonder where you were going. The heart-warming magical touch of a conclusion was, I felt, just right.

Merry Christmas Larry!: Where (or when) on Earth do these folks live? Harsh, or what!? Great imaginative stuff that makes National Lampoon's Christmas look like a walk in the park!

Cookies and Milk: As ever, Carin, I loved the prose. You certainly have a knack for drawing the reader into what can sometimes appear to be the most innocent situations. I was glad of your later explanation because, I must admit, I hadn't really twigged your full intent by the end of the story.

Letters from the Diaspora: Intriguing. Compelling. Haunting. Nice idea, beautifully captured. I was instantly hooked by this piece, Sean, and was left wanting to know more, both about the charachters and the period. What was your inspiration? The names and events fit together so perfectly that I cannot believe that they do not have an actual place in history. Tell me more please. I need to know!
The format, again, was a pleasant change and one that could, perhaps, form the theme for a later contest. Hmmm.

1200 Glenview Road, or, the Marriage of Time: Hats off to you Chris. This was both original and emotional. I did struggle a little with the whole 'timelines coming together thing' and was glad that you didn't launch into a complete scientific explanation (go on, another five hundred words and you would have, wouldn't you!). It came together really well at the end, though, and was most definately amongst my favourites this time around.


Intercalary Christmas: Great story, Chuck. Don't mean to be derogatory, but it was a nice, straightforward, well explained read and sometimes that's all you need. Ditto to a previous post: Intercalary - I had to go and look it up too!


Nativity: Not quite what I was expecting, Pete, I must admit. I felt it was a departure in style (or maybe I just haven't read enough of your stuff yet) but, hey, it really worked for me anyway! The atmosphere of the stranded and ancient ship, the shooting star, the mysterious and uneqivocal angels and, best of all, the marvellously juxtaposed Judas. Superb.


Crikey, this is going to be really difficult.:( First off, I have to say that there isn't a single story that I dislike and, in all honesty, that's quite rare for me. There are normally one or two that I can rule out straightaway, but that's just not the case here. I like different stories for different reasons so I'll have to go away and deliberate.

Back soon.

ND
 
Some of the history is genuine, some made up with names and places I pulled from Wikipedia. I have been to the fortress of Turnaida, which is about an hour northeast of Riga, so that's the inspiration. A small fortress, but I've always been struck by the fact that the Baltic states were also one of the borders of Christianity, parallel with the better-known Crusades in the Holy Land.
 
Senor Viejo, Judas and an alien… sounds like a bad joke…

Sort of as promised (but hey, it must still be weekend somewhere in the world) a couple of musings very early on a Monday morning...

What can I say, I liked all the stories, loved some of them, but voted only for one (I promise!).
Here's my comments on the ones I didn't vote for.

The Joys of Christmas: I liked this one somewhat – don't get me wrong, it's not the story, as such, I just don't like aliens that much. And I got awful flashbacks from two Christmasses ago. Let's just say I'm not a fan of people dressed up as Santa… Cute and fun – and it wasn't depressing!

Far away holiday: Me like! Especially the ending. :)

Merry Christmas, Larry: Strong contender for my vote, but, alas, just missed out. Love your sense of humour. Made me thankful that our apartment block is one of the 'less is more' blocks with no fake snow in sight. Though some do the whole 'dead thorn tree with wire and bead decorations' thing… Thanks, man, you make me count my blessings… one tree and a couple of candles are enough for me… :D

Letters from the Diaspora: A bit difficult to read, but well worth it!

1200 Glenview Road: I'm always up for time-travel and loved this one – it was also a contender for my vote. The tragedy of it all really stuck by me. This is one I will remember for some time to come. I am really jealous. Good for you!

Intercalary Christmas: Nice one! I liked it, but felt that it could use a bit more work. I would like to know what they were giving for presents after all that time in the bunker…

Nativity: Freaky. But loved the Biblical imagery, especially the "thirty frozen silver tears". Nice. Very nice.

Merry Christmas to all and a happy and blessed 2009! :D
 
From marshwriter: The Joys of Christmas: I liked this one somewhat – don't get me wrong, it's not the story, as such, I just don't like aliens that much. And I got awful flashbacks from two Christmasses ago. Let's just say I'm not a fan of people dressed up as Santa… Cute and fun – and it wasn't depressing!

Thanks! I'm glad that you liked it. And don't worry, I don't like aliens that much too- I wrote this up when I was on a high of exhaustion at two o'clock in the morn. XD

From NilsDesperandum: The Joy's of Christmas: Very amusing and fun to read. A refreshingly light-hearted entry.

I'm glad you liked it! Too my unexpected surprise, I too enjoyed this. Maybe I should start writing my stuff when I'm about to fall asleep...;)

Thanks for the comments!
 
Well it is time to vote. For the first time I will also critique the stories since this is also part of what we are looking for here and I've participated myself a few times. I know that people's comments in earlier contests have helped me pay closer attention to my weaknesses and strive to fix them

I liked all the stories, some better than others of course.

Gift Giving - Dan Biegar
I enjoyed the story being virtuall all dialog based making it different. Senor Viejo is apparently a recurring character for Dan, but I think this may be my first encounter. I had some problem with the dates, as I read it it is Christmas Eve, but they talked about the Black Friday store stampede as if it happened the previous day, but Black Friday occurs a month earlier.

Joys of Christmas - Sid Arabon
I had some trouble with this one simply because it felt like there was some context that I was missing. Who (and what) were the aliens and why are they exiled. I was hoping the spoiled alien would get her comeuppance, but not this time.

Heavenly Peace - Nils Durban
Very nice story about historical accounts of what really happened in WWI on Christmas (in many locations it was said). Excellent scene setting and believability.

Christmas Wish - Steve Jones
Nice twist on the venerable genie/lamp story I just got a little confused at the very end. People really don't think over wishes very well and they seldom turn out as planned.

Far Away Holiday - Jim Washburn
My story. I really need to work on my tense as it can get garbled as I write and even rereading does not seem to help me. I also did not know there was an 'Addressing Comma'. Now I do and I'll use it in the future.

Merry Christmas Larry - Thomas Vand
This was a bit tough to read (the first time) because the descriptions and dialog were very mixed together, but it also set a scene of a mixed up man in a confused setting. Very cynical and the kind of storyworld you hope never comes to pass (but could).

Cookies & Milk - Carin Maraias
I did not really get this story until I read someone elses critique and they refered to the characters as 'The Fat Old Man' and 'The Carpenter', implying Santa and Jesus. I reread it after that and believe I picked up on the allusions thereafter. Better late than never in picking things up.

Letters from the Diaspora - Sean Regan
I liked the way this was crafted, as if a historian was reading back about what happened centuries ago. I've always been a history buff so this really hit the spot and makes me want to do a bit of research on some of the places and people mentioned (the latter may or may not have existed).

1200 Glenview Road - Chris Alen F
Is this part of the same world as some of the previous stories? The Nexus was mentioned but that may be just coincidence. A good take on what happens as disparate time lines begin to remerge. I did not pick up on the address/word count though. Just dense I guess.

Intercalary Christmas - Chuck Renia
An at first sad story, 2 lost survivors arguing over Christmas in a hopeless setting, then getting the best present of all. Written from a young person's perspective quite well.

Nativity - Pete Warner
The writing was very good, and the scenes very vivid and intense. This one left me feeling however as if I was missing something, some need for context as to whats and whys that led to the situation in the story.

Well now I have to vote, sometime before I leave work today.
 
Well, the word count has nothing to do with the title ;)

The "koo koo ka joo" is a hint -- it's not referencing Fung Koo, either, but rather a pretty famous song.... :p
 
Joys of Christmas - Sid Arabon
I had some trouble with this one simply because it felt like there was some context that I was missing. Who (and what) were the aliens and why are they exiled. I was hoping the spoiled alien would get her comeuppance, but not this time.

Yeah, I did this on purpose. I wanted to leave the reader asking themselves those questions. I don't really intend of making this an actual novel, so I guess that was pretty mean in a sense. ;) But I'm sorry it troubled you. No one else before you had really commented on it, so I didn't think it was really a problem.

Now, do you want those questions answered, or would you rather just let them be?
 
OK. I managed to narrow it down to four and in the end plumped for Hoodwink's 'Nativity'. Although, for me, my final selections were equally meritous, I felt that Pete had gone above and beyond in his exploration of the theme, the end result being something novel, provocative and deserving of at least a single vote.

This was very difficult though :confused:

ND
 
Rats!

I was hoping to vote today, but the pol was already closed.

Anyway, nice stories everyone. And thanks to everyone for the input on my story. I had written it very fast and curse the 1000 word limit the whole time.

What will the next topic be!
 
I've no idea, but it looks as if it's down to me again (double rats!)

Well, it's already Christmas day here (just) and the turkey's been prepped, so I'll take this opportunity to wish all of you a merry one. :)

ND
 
Gift Giving - It held a LOT of concepts in a simple scene of dialogue. The challenge I had was some of the imagery didn't work (the opening paragraph took a few times to get through). The conversation itself was nice and realistic IMO.

Joys of Christmas - The joke was forced. I was expecting SF and found it odd when you went the "magic" route w/ a binding spell, really didn't fit the story in my head (right or wrong). The story seemed a bit forced, which happens, though you did get the overbearing little alien girl down quite well.

Heavenly Peace - Excellent opening. I just watched a history channel special on Christmas in the trenches during WWI - 1914 to be exact. It's one of those great moments in history shared craftily in this story. Just some history for you. Depending on what trench you're talking, the English began singing the carols w/ them. Yet another trench had a German soldier carry a Christmas tree onto No Man's Land. They also started lighting candles in their trench prior to much of this and the British thought it was some trick. All in all, a great moment in history. Now, perhaps you can tell the story of how the officers stopped this great moment (One of the saddest in history). Great story, but I'm a bit biased to history (as you can no doubt tell). Excellent choice of source inspiration!

Christmas Wish - OK, you're opening of a Christmas story has me interested - a genie? This should be good! Loved the diamond gag. This world is odd though given that the men who find him laughed for 5 minutes??? Why? Intoxicated? I LOVED how the genie ended up becoming a genie. Excellent wittiness! The bad is that, well, that final wish needed to be set up somehow, and the genie becoming Santa just didn't work for me. Given that this was based on Christmas, that theme isn't served well w/ the story given - even though this is my favorite so far and could easily win w/ any other contest.

Far Away Holiday - The first challenge I'm having is getting used to present tense. I'll try and not let that bother me. I definitely lack the way you're working the character's loneliness and how she's dealing w/ it. The ending was alright, a bit given w/ the dream, but fitting for the subject matter. I do wonder if you could've given me a clue as to that particular book's importance!

Merry Christmas, Larry - I was initially confused on how Larry ended up in jail, but these people are serious about their joy-spreading, or at least decorating. I was unsure of why you told the security comments, but I'm hoping it makes sense in a sec. You are slipping out of your POV. This story, as a whole, didn't work for me.

Cookies and Milk - Overall, this is a great section of dialogue. I also liked that they didn't answer the door and knew that others would blame it on their hearing. Cute! I liked it, but I didn't feel the payoff was strong enough.

Letters from the Diaspora - This was finely crafted w/ what appears to be a good deal of research, or at least faux research that would fool most people not directly knowledgeable of the history surrounding your story. As w/ the Genie story, it's wonderful, however, I didn't see much Christmas in it and that was the agreed upon theme (I feel like those irritating judges on Top Chef - my wife watches that show all the time!).

1200 Glenview Road, or, The Marriage of Time - much like the above story, this is well done, though in different ways. It's a classic time-travelling story and though most of it I doubted its Christmas connection, the "gift" concept made up for that.

Intercalary Christmas - Excellent opening w/ the beacon going off. That was something I hadn't anticipated! Seems odd that he is so dead-set on having Christmas in such a bleak situation, but if you don't have anything else to look forward to... It was a nice, SF story. You set up the world beautifully w/o wasting verbage. Nice job.

Nativity - Opening w/ Judas? I'm hoping you're using the name for a purpose! "Hailstones as big as skulls". That was wonderful word pictures! That's the strong suit. The bad was that I got lost in all the imagery and couldn't follow the storyline. It had some great imagery, some connection to allegory, but it didn't seem tied together well.

That's it - all of them! I wish I could've voted, but I waited to Christmas Eve to do the reading and that day my wife needed me a bit more than anticipated. Christmas w/ family. Sounds like one of those cheezier Christmas stories!

wf
 
Joys of Christmas - The joke was forced. I was expecting SF and found it odd when you went the "magic" route w/ a binding spell, really didn't fit the story in my head (right or wrong). The story seemed a bit forced, which happens, though you did get the overbearing little alien girl down quite well.
wf

Hm- what joke? I didn't realize there was a joke involved. I just wrote it up for comedic purposes. But a joke? Excuse my confusion, but I really didn't see a joke in this.
Science Fiction is a tough spot for me, so I usually resort to Fantasy. SFF world, right? The last F has to stand for something.
And how did it seemed forced to you? I mean, when I finished it this, I was about ready to die from exhaustion (which I highly doubt is possible), so this was the result of writing from a high of exhaustion. When I write, it's a "geez-I-hope-this-turns-ok" kind of thing. The only time where my writing is forced is when I have a writer's block, or I'm not into the piece. This, I was in to, and the writing came fluent to you, so however you came to that conclusion of it being "forced", I'm lost.
Oh, and I'm glad you liked Kyrstael- I liked her too.
 
Hm- what joke? I didn't realize there was a joke involved. I just wrote it up for comedic purposes. But a joke? Excuse my confusion, but I really didn't see a joke in this.
Science Fiction is a tough spot for me, so I usually resort to Fantasy. SFF world, right? The last F has to stand for something.
And how did it seemed forced to you? I mean, when I finished it this, I was about ready to die from exhaustion (which I highly doubt is possible), so this was the result of writing from a high of exhaustion. When I write, it's a "geez-I-hope-this-turns-ok" kind of thing. The only time where my writing is forced is when I have a writer's block, or I'm not into the piece. This, I was in to, and the writing came fluent to you, so however you came to that conclusion of it being "forced", I'm lost.
Oh, and I'm glad you liked Kyrstael- I liked her too.

I apologize for not being more clear in my response to the story. The joke I'd referred to (so poorly) is the Santa Clause outfit that Matnis was forced to wear - the closing line of "tis the season to be jolly" as well as the concept of a crumudgeon being the unwilling representative of the holiday season.

The "forced" part was that the plot or the story's flow seemed to be obvious from the beginning, at least to me, and was pushed toward that goal. From my perspective, that's what it felt like, right or wrong.

In regard to the comment about the magic element not fitting my view of a SF world, that's built on the basic tenets of the genre. It can be adjusted and changed, as no doubt countless writers have done. I would comment on some if I was a reader of SF (I, too, prefer fantasy). I think it would've worked better (again, in my opinion) if it would've been established earlier than the first use of a magic spell so it didn't seem to come out of nowhere.

Anyway, thanks for sharing. You did more than I did (though I did try - I couldn't figure out how to post stories) and that's always admirable. My hope was that my opinion would help you. If not initially, I hope this clarified it a bit more. Have a great Christmas and holiday season!

wf
 
Congrats again, Nils. Should we impose term limits a la presidents? :D

Merry Christmas to all. My belly is full and soon to fuller ;)
 
It was a bit of a fluke when you consider how evenly the votes were spread. plus, I have now realised my error, i.e. I could have voted for your story (which I came very close to doing), making you joint winner and then simply novated you to run the next contest. Oh well, you live and learn! :rolleyes:

Regarding bellies: ditto! :D

Back to the mayhem. Have a good one.

ND
 

Sponsors


We try to keep the forum as free of ads as possible, please consider supporting SFFWorld on Patreon


Your ad here.
Back
Top